Mega Thread 2013: Trade Hypotheticals

[Sydswans0512]

As a developing KPP he's worth more to Carlton than anyone would be willing to pay.
Could probably get Duigan or Davies for free though, maybe even Laider (although I'd prefer we held on to him).

I'd agree with that if your looking for key backs I wouldn't bother speaking to Carlton at trade week

 

[St K1LD4]

Not much apparently. Injury prone and has had the number 1 ruck role taken away from him, so everybody seems to think

2nd, 3rd round? Between 25-35?

 

[Sydswans0512]

I wouldn't like to give him away for anything less than pick 20

 

[GoldenEagle]

With Adam Selwood coming to Geelong at the end of the year to play VFL and be an assistant coach, surely geelong and west coast can do a deal to re unite all 4 brothers. Scott Selwood to Geelong in exchange for Mitch Duncan and Cam Eardley. Or Mitch Duncan and a second round pick.

I rate Mitch Duncan highly but I wouldn't see Scott leaving. Whats your source for Adam leaving? On a side note I would think Freo would be highly interested in Kersten. Hows he travelling?

 

[Cat Addict]

I rate Mitch Duncan highly but I wouldn't see Scott leaving. Whats your source for Adam leaving? On a side note I would think Freo would be highly interested in Kersten. Hows he travelling?

Kersten kicked 6 yesterday in the VFL

 

[Two Planks]

I rate Mitch Duncan highly but I wouldn't see Scott leaving. Whats your source for Adam leaving? On a side note I would think Freo would be highly interested in Kersten. Hows he travelling?

Basil Zemplas (dont know how to spell his name) mentioned this on SEN1116 last wednesday when Harf asked him the future of all the veterans on the eagles list. He said it like everybody knew it and it was no secret.

The cats rate Kersten highly as well. Expect them to give him some game time this year to show him there is a future at Kardinia Park. Freo will be hard for him to knock back though with the ability to get more game time and also play in a competative team.

 

[saintsrfreak]

2nd, 3rd round? Between 25-35?

Why would we want Mumford?

 

[St K1LD4]

Why would we want Mumford?

My idea is to trade McEvoy, Gilbert and 4th round for Pick 1 and 2nd round.
Mumford would provide good leadership for Pierce and Hickey

 

[St K1LD4]

I wouldn't like to give him away for anything less than pick 20

25-30? Gentle men's agreement because we took TDL off your list?

 

[Turboman1994]

With Adam Selwood coming to Geelong at the end of the year to play VFL and be an assistant coach, surely geelong and west coast can do a deal to re unite all 4 brothers. Scott Selwood to Geelong in exchange for Mitch Duncan and Cam Eardley. Or Mitch Duncan and a second round pick.

scooter for Duncan and a second rounder I would snap ya hand off for that trade

 

[Sydswans0512]

25-30? Gentle men's agreement because we took TDL off your list?

Chuck in Stanley

 

[Two Planks]

scooter for Duncan and a second rounder I would snap ya hand off for that trade

Done deal !!!

 

[DivideandMultiply]

scooter for Duncan and a second rounder I would snap ya hand off for that trade

Hi mister 15 posts, new account?

As for the trade, would not do.

 

[DivideandMultiply]

Done deal !!!

No chance.

 

[Two Planks]

No chance.

Fax has already gone through !!!

 

[St K1LD4]

Chuck in Stanley

Haven't you learnt with Walsh?

 

[Turboman1994]

No chance.

Scooter was very lucky to win our b&f Duncan is exactly what we need and younger whilst being a west Australian
not saying I would trade scooter good solid B grade player but Duncan plus geelongs second round pick is on the money imo
scooter is an elite pressure mid and should only be used as a tagger breaking forward his decision making and kicking is questionable we could use some better kicks in our side

 

[Gezim]

what would be a good trade week and free agency win for carlton, to what they need to get better....

 

[ArjenTheGreat]

Franklin yes. The rest are questionable at best. For consistency jack wins out

Kennedy is ultra consistent and a superstar, and I think we all agree that Cameron is an outrageously good player at 20.

I love Jack, but consistent and him can hardly be put in the same sentence and you know what, there's nothing wrong with that, playing one out in a crap team can do that to you.

 

[Sydswans0512]

Haven't you learnt with Walsh?

I can't believe St Kilda wanted to hang onto him

 

[DivideandMultiply]

Scooter was very lucky to win our b&f Duncan is exactly what we need and younger whilst being a west Australian
not saying I would trade scooter good solid B grade player but Duncan plus geelongs second round pick is on the money imo
scooter is an elite pressure mid and should only be used as a tagger breaking forward his decision making and kicking is questionable we could use some better kicks in our side

No, it really isn't. I also doubt you are a WC supporter, so whose sock puppet are you?

 

[Oddhawk]

Mumford to hawthorn?
2nd rounder (35-40) and a player? What kind of player would the swans be chasing?

 

[Sydswans0512]

Mumford to hawthorn?
2nd rounder (35-40) and a player? What kind of player would the swans be chasing?

Straight swap Issac Smith

 

[Turboman1994]

No, it really isn't. I also doubt you are a WC supporter, so whose sock puppet are you?

Being an eagles supporter as long as I can remember some ones post count doesn't not represent there knowledge of footy. the point of a forum is for debate. Everyone has there opinion and this is mine.

 

[Red Black and Blue]

Straight swap Issac Smith

I doubt they'd make one of their biggest competitors heaps stronger.