List Mgmt. 2014 Draft Trade FA Megathread

[dewah07]

Is it possible to trade a rookie when their contract is up and can't rookie them anymore?

 

[TheLastEmperor]

Is it possible to trade a rookie when their contract is up?

Yup. See Tommy Gun Walsh.

 

[Periphery]

I wonder if we could trade JOR and Jaksch to a 3rd club? No idea what they would get us though. You'd like to think something like pick 7-10 but they are some very hard players to put a value on due to how little they have played and injuries etc.

Sounds too good to be true. I reckon they will want our second rounder.

What if they REALLY rate Petracca as another absolute future superstar? They know for a fact they wont get him with 3 so if they rate him highly enough they will have to make a play for pick 1 and we will make them pay for it.

 

[dewah07]

Yup. See Tommy Gun Walsh.

Was that his last year he could possibly be a rookie like Minch tho?

 

[Manimal_Dunstan]

7 senior list positions free already.

We really are having a cull! i like it.

 

[MightySaint]

interesting

Jaksch is worth around a late teen/early 20s pick. so we'd want more than just him for pick 1.

add pick 3 and we are getting a bit warmer. add a better player and we've got close to a deal or add another pick inside 10 and yeap deal done.

but if its the rumor Jacksch + JOR + Pick 3 for Pick 1, we are getting ripped off

Don't agree here. Jaksch, JOR & Brayshaw vs McCartin? Those 3 all day long.

 

[Manimal_Dunstan]

Don't agree here. Jaksch, JOR & Brayshaw vs McCartin? Those 3 all day long.

We'll probably still get McCartin at Pick 3 if those Melbourne flogs don't get extra picks.

 

[TheLastEmperor]

Was that his last year he could possibly be a rookie like Minch tho?

His rookie contract was up

 

[stkildathunda]

Yup. See Tommy Gun Walsh.

You can trade rookies, but the new club must put them on senior list

 

[dewah07]

Minch is surly on the trade table if we don't want to upgrade him then.

 

[stkildathunda]

What if they REALLY rate Petracca as another absolute future superstar? They know for a fact they wont get him with 3 so if they rate him highly enough they will have to make a play for pick 1 and we will make them pay for it.

They do, thats who they want.

 

[bird_man]

Sounds too good to be true. I reckon they will want our second rounder.

Sounds about right to me. Sure both were high picks but most GWS players have gone past these two and they haven't been able to get a game at the club. Still question marks over both of them.

I wouldn't do the deal if it was just one of them.

 

[Defacto]

I hope not, that's not a trade, it's theft

if it did happen..'m sure you and hawthorn supporters can join some therapy group to deal with that hahahaha

 

[TheLastEmperor]

We'll probably still get McCartin at Pick 3 if those Melbourne flogs don't get extra picks.

You reckon? I guess Roos did say he doesn't like taking talls with early picks. Also reckon they would favour Wright over Paddy.

Even with Frawley compo;
1. Petracca - GWS
2. Brayshaw - Melb
3. Wright - Melb
4. Paddy - Stk

That would be amazing-ballz.

 

[dewah07]

They do, thats who they want.

Is that from a tommy sauce or just a guess?

 

[TheLastEmperor]

Sounds about right to me. Sure both were high picks but most GWS players have gone past these two and they haven't been able to get a game at the club. Still question marks over both of them.

I wouldn't do the deal if it was just one of them.

Look at it this way.

Petracca vs JOR + Jaksch + McCartin/Wright

?

 

[stkildathunda]

Is that from a tommy sauce or just a guess?

 

[Manimal_Dunstan]

You reckon? I guess Roos did say he doesn't like taking talls with early picks. Also reckon they would favour Wright over Paddy.

Even with Frawley compo;
1. Petracca - GWS
2. Brayshaw - Melb
3. Wright - Melb
4. Paddy - Stk

That would be amazing-ballz.

That's why i said if those Melbourne flogs don't get extra picks.

Petracca, Brayshaw and McCartin in that order.

 

[God Save Max King]

Thunda, are we definitely after O'Rourke/Jaksch, or would we consider on-trading them in a 3/4 way deal?

 

[_Maximus_12]

Elite endurance, quite quick and has a wicked sidestep. Good in traffic. Skills good. Highly rated junior but we haven't seen enough to make a call.

You had me at wicked side step.
Lenny MKIII (behind Dunstan)

 

[Defacto]

Don't agree here. Jaksch, JOR & Brayshaw vs McCartin? Those 3 all day long.

i just dont rate JOR at all, right now i wouldnt give up anything inside the 3rd round for him. Jaksch is an early 20s, maybe late teens pick trade.

Pick 1 for 3, 20, 57+. maybe i rate pick 1 too highly or our ability to claw something nice out but i thought we could do better than that

just my opinion happy to be wrong/alone on this

 

[dewah07]

Surly we try and get GWS to trade JOR and Jaksch for more first picks to trade to us

 

[MightySaint]

i just dont rate JOR at all, right now i wouldnt give up anything inside the 3rd round for him. Jaksch is an early 20s, maybe late teens pick trade.

Pick 1 for 3, 20, 57+. maybe i rate pick 1 too highly or our ability to claw something nice out but i thought we could do better than that

just my opinion happy to be wrong/alone on this

I guess it comes down to how highly you rate McCartin. I just don't see a top 10 dominant forward (highlights only). Rahul, what do you say?

 

[Manimal_Dunstan]

I guess if we get Jaksch that Tom Lee trade doesn't look bad.

 

[Defacto]

You reckon? I guess Roos did say he doesn't like taking talls with early picks. Also reckon they would favour Wright over Paddy.

Even with Frawley compo;
1. Petracca - GWS
2. Brayshaw - Melb
3. Wright - Melb
4. Paddy - Stk

That would be amazing-ballz.

one of durdin,wright,mccartin. i wouldnt be too upset with that. all three have just as much concern/risk