List Mgmt. 2015 AFL Draft - what type of players should we be looking at & who do we take? (Poll added)

[Peter Bell]

We'd also have to de-list a bunch of contracted players to fit all those guys in.

 

[Lace_Out]

7:00 old boy.

Its live on fox at 6:30
If it is on live at 7 on the AFL site then there must be 1/2 hr of crap talking b4 they start reading out names I guess.

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

 

[thylacine60]

7:00 old boy.

Guess I could watch it in bed.

 

[Peter Bell]

Draft day will start on AFL.com.au and the Official AFL Live App with the NAB AFL Draft Countdown, hosted by Matt Thompson, Callum Twomey and Garry Lyon live from 3.30pm AEDT.

 

[coryne]

Its live on fox at 6:30
If it is on live at 7 on the AFL site then there must be 1/2 hr of crap talking b4 they start reading out names I guess.

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

Unless there is also 30 mins of pre draft crap on the afl site too .....

 

[true blue19]

We'd also have to de-list a bunch of contracted players to fit all those guys in.

Your right I forgot about Gower and Gorringe. I'll take out g.clark and Snadden and move SOS2 to pick 59

 

[HARKER]

Callum Twomey's 2015 phantom draft

THIS year's draft has been one of the most challenging in years for experts to predict, with both the even spread of talent and the distribution of picks in the top 10 making it tough.

Here is how AFL.com.au's draft expert Callum Twomey sees the first 30 picks panning out, including the impact of the new bidding system. Be sure to click through all the links for exclusive stories and video telling the stories of this year's crop of young talent.

After the top 30, keep reading for Cal's club-by-club rundown of how the remainder of the draft could pan out on Tuesday night.

Weitering...McKay...Curnow...Tucker.................No problem.

 

[Azul]

Ah Chee a real bolter!

 

[Soapy V]

Callum Twomey's 2015 phantom draft



Weitering...McKay...Curnow...Tucker.................No problem.

id be very happy with that

my only question would be if tucker and bonner were both available at 19 would be take bonner? elite kick and what bolton would want

ah chee at 7 is a big call but it helps us

 

[BringBackSimmo]

Callum Twomey's 2015 phantom draft



Weitering...McKay...Curnow...Tucker.................No problem.

We'd take McKay before Curnow? Is he really going to slip to 14 anyway?

And i don't see why we'd take Tucker?

They really need to stop using this picture of Clayton Oliver

 

[ferrisb]

Weideman's foot may be Selwood's shoulder.

Andrew Walker's foot was jake Carlisle's shoulder once...

 

[Matty411]

We'd take McKay before Curnow? Is he really going to slip to 14 anyway?

And i don't see why we'd take Tucker?

Apparently we're hugely into him - was a top 5 prospect and bottom-aged AA last year. Definitely a long-term midfielder but looks a slightly quicker, cleaner version of Docherty - leadership and AFL-ready body, too. At 19/23 I'd be all over him.

Also re Curnow - on the basis Milera, Burton and McKay are still there it seems common knowledge that Curnow would last but McKay would not… hence the order. At 14, Curnow would be a steal.

 

[HereComesJuddy]

Stoked if we get McKay at 8. Even more stoked if we got Curnow at 11!!!

 

[coryne]

Apparently we're hugely into him - was a top 5 prospect and bottom-aged AA last year. Definitely a long-term midfielder but looks a slightly quicker, cleaner version of Docherty - leadership and AFL-ready body, too. At 19/23 I'd be all over him.

Also re Curnow - on the basis Milera, Burton and McKay are still there it seems common knowledge that Curnow would last but McKay would not… hence the order. At 14, Curnow would be a steal.

There is also only 1 "live" selection between the two with the belief that the Crows would go with home grown talent (Milera) over a Vic kid who was just arrested. Sounds like a "Roughead/Franklin" situation where you select the player that the opposition would be most likely selection and hope to get both.

 

[Blugazi]

Weitering, H. McKay, Curnow & Tucker would be huge for us.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Callum Twomey's 2015 phantom draft



Weitering...McKay...Curnow...Tucker.................No problem.

I'd prefer Bonner or Clarke to Tucker at our last and can't see Rioli or Ah Chee going that high at all.

Everything seems to be pointing towards us getting H McKay and maybe i'll have to learn to live with that. If that was me I'd lock in Curnow at #8 and then hope Milera slid to #11(#10) because I wouldn't flirt with losing out on Curnow, and if Adelaide snap up Milera we can look at Burton or McKay (or Clarke/Balic/Gresham/Hibberd/Donner, but thats just me)

 

[Bostonian]

My final and hopeful wish list is
1 Weitering
8 Milera
11 McKay Harry
19 Gresham
Together with Silvani that would haul.

You seemed to have dropped your g, here it is.

*hands back the lost g*

 

[Soapy V]

with us adelaide melbourne essendon & melbourne all having two picks between 3 & 13 it makes it a bit of a game of poker as much as anything. will be very interesting

 

[Matty411]

I'd prefer Bonner or Clarke to Tucker at our last and can't see Rioli or Ah Chee going that high at all.

Everything seems to be pointing towards us getting H McKay and maybe i'll have to learn to live with that. If that was me I'd lock in Curnow at #8 and then hope Milera slid to #11(#10) because I wouldn't flirt with losing out on Curnow, and if Adelaide snap up Milera we can look at Burton or McKay (or Clarke/Balic/Gresham/Hibberd/Donner, but thats just me)

I'd probably personally rather Curnow/Collins or Curnow/Gresham but would be happy with Tucker at 19*.

Weitering - future CHB and start defender
Curnow - roaming CHF and part-time bullocking midfielder.
Collins - future FB and #2 to Weitering. Think JW will bring out best in him as he's done so far.
Tucker - outside mid with speed, efficiency and a balanced game. Also has leadership credentials.

I'm still line-ball as to whether Collins or McKay would be the better pick - but I'd 100% take Curnow regardless. Whilst I can see Crows taking Milera/McKay first, it's probably not the time to risk a guy who's probably top 5 on talent/potential.

Very surprised Ah Chee and Rioli might feature top 15...

 

[Weiterbot23]

with us adelaide melbourne essendon & melbourne all having two picks between 3 & 13 it makes it a bit of a game of poker as much as anything. will be very interesting

Any possible collusion between us an Adelaide as part of our deal.

"We will give you Menzel, but you can't take curnow in the draft."

 

[HereComesJuddy]

Another phantom

 

[coryne]

Any possible collusion between us an Adelaide as part of our deal.

"We will give you Menzel, but you can't take curnow in the draft."

So you think that Carlton put Curnow up to being arrested? I mean the "Deal" wouldn't be possible without Curnow sliding, which only became a possibility a couple of days ago due to the arrest .....

 

[Red Bull]

Weitering, H. McKay, Curnow & Tucker would be huge for us.

Yep , I'd lock that in right now if i could .
Also don't forget Silvagni for virtually nothing as a very sweet bonus at the end to round out a ripping draft haul !!

 

[ParapMarkets]

Apparently we're hugely into him - was a top 5 prospect and bottom-aged AA last year. Definitely a long-term midfielder but looks a slightly quicker, cleaner version of Docherty - leadership and AFL-ready body, too. At 19/23 I'd be all over him.

Also re Curnow - on the basis Milera, Burton and McKay are still there it seems common knowledge that Curnow would last but McKay would not… hence the order. At 14, Curnow would be a steal.

You hit the nail on the head! With those players still on the board we would take McKay first. Also, I think Cal is a lot closer to the mark than Landsberger's with Fu.... I mean Tucker at 19. Seems a good mix, I like it

 

[ParapMarkets]

I was wondering who GC were into that made them so happy to trade down the order (and even try and trade pick 6 to us). Ah Chee - very interesting!