2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[pulpdriver]

JPK v Parker

Danger v Wines

Christensen v Dahlhaus

JPK - contested beast though I don't think he'll score too much higher than Parker, likely one will outscore the other every 2nd week and they'll finish within a hair of each other. JPK's just been doing it for years.
Danger - Both look set for a big year but Danger has really impressed me. Proven to go very big.
Dahlhaus - Christensen has a few question marks for mine. Dalhaus steadily improved every year and should get some more mid time. Good for a couple goals and bundle of tackles a game even if not in the mids.

 

[Samples]

JPK v Parker

Danger v Wines

Christensen v Dahlhaus

JPK

Danger

Dahlhaus

Danger & Bartel

vs

Selwood & Bennell

Selwood and Bennell

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

How would it change taking price into account?

Without knowing exact prices.

Parker > JPK > Griffen > Wines

 

[jjsmitty8]

Gotta be one or the other. No combos.

Minson, Maric, Ibbotson, Wines

vs

Luey, Goldstein, Hibberd (pending suspension), Neale?

 

[Kk1ll]

Gotta be one or the other. No combos.

Minson, Maric, Ibbotson, Wines

vs

Luey, Goldstein, Hibberd (pending suspension), Neale?

First one, although can't say i really like ibbo.

 

[jjsmitty8]

First one, although can't say i really like ibbo.

Yeah me either, but I can't really find any more satisfactory options for D4. Clancee doesn't satisfy me either.

EDIT: Ended up going KK, Wines, Minson, Naitanui.

 

[buttox]

selwood + adcock
vs
boak + shaw -14ppg
as selwood would be captain over kennedy

 

[Chappycats]

Wines, Griffin, def rookie
Vs
Beams, Newnes, Heeney

 

[Chappycats]

selwood + adcock
vs
boak + shaw -14ppg
as selwood would be captain over kennedy

Selwood plus Doodle

 

[Thuggee_Cult]

Danger vs Griffen?

I have had both as my M4/M5 for a while

However if I was forced to choose between the two I would pick Griffen.

 

[Goats]

the decisions that'll twist me up right until lockout

[D1] Simpson vs Shaw vs Hibberd (banned??) vs Birchall (injured??)
[M5] Wines vs Swallow
[with Goldy] Jacobs vs Minson
[F2] Bartel vs Franklin

Simpson
Wines
Minson
Franklin

 

[Kadog]

Ibbo v KK

 

[Flandersss]

Ibbo v KK

Tough one.

I'm going to say KK, for durability, 26 touches in the last nab challenge helps to

I have both FWIW.

 

[toxic]

Wines, Griffin, def rookie
Vs
Beams, Newnes, Heeney

Griff newnes heeney.

$$$left over and all 3 will appreciate

 

[PowerDrafter]

Wines and Bennell (also have Mitch Duncan)

Swan and JPK


Sent from my iPod touch using Tapatalk

 

[rocker_oz33]

i'm tossing up Higgins (f5) and bonts (f4)

v

Goodes and franklin

(pending upgrade)
tia

Goodes and buddy if goodes gets the upgrade going with the old gun and rookie pricey rooke at that.

 

[Sprout]

Maric + H.Taylor vs NicNat + Gibson

Not sure if Taylor can keep up his scores from the NAB. NicNat remains a risk all round. Leaning towards option 1 but not sure.

 

[_M_16_]

Okay guys, trying to decide between various combinations to finalise my team, both a midfield and a forward spot

Macrae and Swan
or
Macrae and Bontempelli
or
Macrae and T.Mitchell
or
Lewis and Bontempelli
or
Lewis and T.Mitchell

Which combo out of these?

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Maric + H.Taylor vs NicNat + Gibson

Not sure if Taylor can keep up his scores from the NAB. NicNat remains a risk all round. Leaning towards option 1 but not sure.

NN + Gibson easy for me.

NN will take a few games to get going after a tough few years without pre-seasons, but he and Gibbo with Frawley now taking a key post should have a much higher ceiling.

 

[Geelong_Bisons_#36]

Gibson vs MJ ?

 

[No.19]

Maric or Minson?

 

[Mercuri Rising]

Maric or Minson?

Maric. Was on fire after he warmed up last year. There's apparently a decent chance of Campbell/Cordy pushing Minson out for games at some point this year.

 

[Mercuri Rising]

Gray + KK
vs
James Kelly + Bennell

 

[stevebbb]

Okay guys, trying to decide between various combinations to finalise my team, both a midfield and a forward spot

Macrae and Swan
or
Macrae and Bontempelli
or
Macrae and T.Mitchell
or
Lewis and Bontempelli
or
Lewis and T.Mitchell

Which combo out of these?

Lewis and Bonty
Swan will struggle to average 90, TMitch unknown, Lewis is a star in the best team

Gibson vs MJ ?

MJ

Maric or Minson?

hard, probably Minson, save the extra 35k, they'll average very similar for me

Gray + KK
vs
James Kelly + Bennell

Gray will get close to 120 average, I'm not sold on KK, but first option anyway

 

[SnappyHappy]

My last decision to make to finalize my team:

JPK v Beams