2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[stevebbb]

the decisions that'll twist me up right until lockout

[D1] Simpson vs Shaw vs Hibberd (banned??) vs Birchall (injured??)
[M5] Wines vs Swallow
[with Goldy] Jacobs vs Minson
[F2] Bartel vs Franklin

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Ibbo vs Pittard. This one is killing me.

Douche and Turd. Flip a coin, both rancid.

Pittard

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

the decisions that'll twist me up right until lockout

[D1] Simpson vs Shaw vs Hibberd (banned??) vs Birchall (injured??)
[M5] Wines vs Swallow
[with Goldy] Jacobs vs Minson
[F2] Bartel vs Franklin

Shaw, Simpson, Hibs, Birch
Wines
Minson
Bartel

 

[12Chill]

Pendles vs Fyfe at M1?

 

[Lums23]

Pendles vs Fyfe at M1?

Pendles. Outrageous footballer.

 

[New_Frrost11]

Pendles vs Fyfe at M1?

Let me better this question... I want two of:

Rocky/Pendles/Fyfe/Selwood. Then I'm going with:
M3 - Danger
M4 - MaCrae
M5 - Dusty
M6 - Cripps
M7/M8/EMG/EMG/EMG - Heeney/Boekhurst/Lambert/E-Yolman/Vandenberg

 

[New_Frrost11]

the decisions that'll twist me up right until lockout

[D1] Simpson vs Shaw vs Hibberd (banned??) vs Birchall (injured??)
[M5] Wines vs Swallow
[with Goldy] Jacobs vs Minson
[F2] Bartel vs Franklin

D1 - Simmo (His game will be no different to what it has been, no player inclusion at carlton will affect simmo's input either)
M5 - Ollie
R2 - WOW! Neither, don't waste your money there mate, just take goldy and find someone in the 400's
F2 - Jimmy B is my man!

 

[Geelong_Bisons_#36]

Pendles + Fyfe

 

[New_Frrost11]

Which 2 players as M4 & M5:

Fyfe & Wines/Griffen

V

JPK & Danger/Stevie J

? at M4 & M5 - WOW!!!

Fyfe & Griffin - JPK has too many guns around him that will be better after an extra year under the belt, Fyfe has the same boys running around him. Wines is a bit too young to be called up ahead of Griffin who is moving into a better midfield then he was playing in last few years, Means he will get more of the pill and effectiveness should be boosted.

 

[SnappyHappy]

JPK v Parker v Wines v Griffen - in order

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

JPK v Parker v Wines v Griffen - in order

The order you've listed from left being 1 to right being 4 for me is correct.

 

[Kk1ll]

JPK v Parker v Wines v Griffen - in order

Griffen, Wines, JPK, Parker for me.


EDIT (I considered price)

 

[Lums23]

JPK v Parker v Wines v Griffen - in order

Disregarding price I'd probably have them in the order you've got them.

 

[SnappyHappy]

The order you've listed from left being 1 to right being 4 for me is correct.

Disregarding price I'd probably have them in the order you've got them.

How would it change taking price into account?

 

[Lums23]

How would it change taking price into account?

If you needed 80k to upgrade a z smith to a nicnat or or a kk to a birchall or something like that then I'd take wines over jpk

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Sold! Do you work in real estate?

Haha not at all. Spend too much time on here to be one of them!

 

[Samples]

Beams v Dangerfield at M4?

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Beams v Dangerfield at M4?

I like Beams but plenty will say Danger. Danger has been notorious for slow starts in recent years and who knows how the contract saga will play out with him. Would rather have Sloane over Danger too FWIW

 

[rocker_oz33]

Beams v Dangerfield at M4?

Beams pending where the extra is spend.
Danger looks fit and ready tho.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Steven V Scooter.
Ibbo V henderson.
Bob Murph V MJ.

 

[Big Fozza]

Steven V Scooter.
Ibbo V henderson.
Bob Murph V MJ.

i think steven has potential to go 110 this year and scooter only 100. i think steven is a chance at being a keeper at m8 but Scooter is sure to need to be upgraded

gone with Ibbo as he has proven he has a higher ceiling

i had murph in my team for ages but recently switched him to MJ. i'm just starting to get worried that wiht bob's increased importance to his side with regards to attacking there is gonna be a defensive fwd paying him more and more attention. not sure if this has happened much before in the past??? this is a close one for me. MJ is also a couple of years younger...

 

[Big Fozza]

i'm tossing up Higgins (f5) and bonts (f4)

v

Goodes and franklin

(pending upgrade)
tia

 

[Young Gun #6]

the decisions that'll twist me up right until lockout

[D1] Simpson vs Shaw vs Hibberd (banned??) vs Birchall (injured??)
[M5] Wines vs Swallow
[with Goldy] Jacobs vs Minson
[F2] Bartel vs Franklin

Shaw
Wines
Jacobs
Bartel

Easy choices.

 

[SnappyHappy]

JPK v Parker

Danger v Wines

Christensen v Dahlhaus

 

[pulpdriver]

Danger & Bartel

vs

Selwood & Bennell