2017 trade hypothetical thread

[F_therest]

I reckon our pick 3 and 2018 2nd rounder is pretty fair for Kelly...consider what Dangerfield and Beams cost we'd be giving up more for Kelly.

Treloar cost more but that's only because Collingwood were desperate..plus they thought their future 1st would be more like pick 14, not pick 7.

Pick 3 is a super premium pick.

 

[adammania9]

I don't think he will leave because he's settling in very nicely, but what would Matt Kennedy cost? Big, big fan as he's a lovely kick, hits the scoreboard and is a lively character to have in a team. I think he'll be better than Hopper in the long run.

 

[eth-dog]

Please tell me it is petracca to saints (where we should have picked him in the first instance). Or jayden hunt would do nicely also!

No word in regards to anything St. Kilda. Petracca is going nowhere, as is Hunt

 

[Two Planks]

Carlisle's @ St Kilda - 1
Carlisle's @ Carlton - 0

Surely getting a better coach would be more attractive to Carlisle?
And Bolton/SOS wouldn't turn away a free KPD as good as Carlisle...

Carlton withdrew their 5 year $700k offer after Brisbane stupidly won in the last round of the season handing the blues another centre half back in Weitering. They then offered Carlisle a 3 year deal @500k. St Kilda matched the original offer and the rest is history.

 

[Guy Threepwood]

Pick 2 is there's if Kelly wants to come to Carlton.

Yep, doubt many clubs would have an issue paying that pick for him. Whether GWS would accept it on it's own though is another question. What I can't fathom them accepting is overpaying for an injury prone ruckman to then take a lesser pick for him.

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

Unfortunately for Adelaide, gov is out of contract this year so you guys don't hold any bargaining power, especially considering fremantle don't have a 2nd rounder this year and they won't be trading out a top 10 pick for a 3rd tall.

I'm sorry, but how does fremantle not having a second change anything? It hasn't stopped them from chasing him, and they would know that their third wouldn't even come close, fremantle would be planning on trading first pick for him, probably with something else going back there way.
It's also pretty irrelevant to west coast anyway, if Mitch decides to leave then his choice want be based on who has the right picks for a trade.
Anyway you'd have to be pretty silly to think you trade a pick in the 30's for him.

 

[eth-dog]

Carlton withdrew their 5 year $700k offer after Brisbane stupidly won in the last round of the season handing the blues another centre half back in Weitering. They then offered Carlisle a 3 year deal @500k. St Kilda matched the original offer and the rest is history.

Just keep digging.

 

[Two Planks]

Just keep digging.

Why dont you actually tell us what you know instead of saying that you know all this big news but can't tell anybody yet.

 

[harro92]

Anyone interested in a trade game

https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/harros-trade-game.1168377/

Message me if you need


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[eth-dog]

Why dont you actually tell us what you know instead of saying that you know all this big news but can't tell anybody yet.

I've covered quite a bit in their specific player threads. Melbourne have serious interest in Zak Jones, Daniel McStay is another player that they're chasing. There are preliminary interests in a couple of fringe players from other clubs that aren't really worth mentioning yet, as they'll make decisions on them once they find out whether they can get their main objectives.

 

[Yippy Yi Yeo]

I'm sorry, but how does fremantle not having a second change anything? It hasn't stopped them from chasing him, and they would know that their third wouldn't even come close, fremantle would planning on trading first pick for him, probably with something else going back there way.
It's also pretty irrelevant to west coast anyway, if Mitch decides to leave then his choice want be based on who has the right picks for a trade.
Anyway you'd after to be pretty silly to think you trade a pick in the 30's for him.

It would mean Fremantle would have to trade a top 10 pick for him, which they won't do without something significant coming back. Where did you get the idea that we'd trade a 3rd round pick for him?

 

[briztoon]

Are the Parish rumors true or just wishful thinking on Bristoon Side would be a great get for the Lions if true

Definitely made up. Just a wind up.

 

[Mr MysteryGuest]

It would mean Fremantle would have to trade a top 10 pick for him, which they won't do without something significant coming back. Where did you get the idea that we'd trade a 3rd round pick for him?

I didn't, I said fremantle's third won't cut it, and west coast's second which likely be in the 30's or at best late 20's won't cut it either.
He's easily worth a first on his own, uncontracted or not. If fremantle's first pick falls between 7-10, then Adelaide could throw back there future second.

 

[briztoon]

What would it cost for Brisbane to acquire Charlie Cameron from Adelaide?

 

[dazbroncos]

We want to get back into the first round this year, norths first pick would do. They can have any two of vickery, schoenmakers, duryea, willsmore, miles, heatherley, Gibson or brand. Who do they pick?

Youd want to offer 4... but it wont matter...

sum total does not get a Rd1 pick..

Go Catters

 

[JG22]

I reckon our pick 3 and 2018 2nd rounder is pretty fair for Kelly...consider what Dangerfield and Beams cost we'd be giving up more for Kelly.

Treloar cost more but that's only because Collingwood were desperate..plus they thought their future 1st would be more like pick 14, not pick 7.

Pick 3 is a super premium pick.

Danger and Beams both much older and one a FA, both also leaving for family reasons.

Both firsts is too much but the 2nd not quite enough.

Can't see him going there anyway

 

[CasuallyDressed]

We want to get back into the first round this year, norths first pick would do. They can have any two of vickery, schoenmakers, duryea, willsmore, miles, heatherley, Gibson or brand. Who do they pick?

Yep. Collingwood should look at bringing Josh Kelly in. GWS can pick 2 of Greenwood, Langdon, Keeffe, Mayne, Blair and Ramsey.

Would also offer this deal to Gold Coast for Tom Lynch.

 

[JG22]

We want to get back into the first round this year, norths first pick would do. They can have any two of vickery, schoenmakers, duryea, willsmore, miles, heatherley, Gibson or brand. Who do they pick?

Vickery and Gibson. Then make both of them retire immediately

 

[Dez!]

I've covered quite a bit in their specific player threads. Melbourne have serious interest in Zak Jones, Daniel McStay is another player that they're chasing. There are preliminary interests in a couple of fringe players from other clubs that aren't really worth mentioning yet, as they'll make decisions on them once they find out whether they can get their main objectives.

As if we'd get McStay, he can't defy his name.

 

[Nuggs Bunny]

As if we'd get McStay, he can't defy his name.

Might get Daniel McLeave instead.

 

[Dez!]

Might get Daniel McLeave instead.

See that's more believable.

 

[dazzledavey36]

Andrew Mackie is headed to the Giants in a playing or coaching capacity to be decided.

Was that you who just rang SEN and said this exact trade proposal??

 

[Two Planks]

Was that you who just rang SEN and said this exact trade proposal??

Dont listen to the radio at work.

 

[HalAlaric]

4–WAY TRADE (based on current ladder position)
Carlton trade Gibbs to Adelaide for pick #18
Carlton trade pick #18 & 2018 2nd round pick to NMFC for Ben McKay & 2018 1st round pick
NMFC trade pick #4 & #18 to GWS for Josh Kelly

VERDICT:
Carlton: Gain Ben McKay & NMFC 2018 1st round pick. Lose Gibbs & 2018 2nd round pick.
NMFC: Gain Josh Kelly & Carltons 2018 2nd round pick. Lose #4, 2018 1st round pick & Ben McKay.
GWS: Gain #4 & #18. Lose Josh Kelly.
Adelaide: Gain Gibbs. Lose pick #18.

Thoughts?

 

[Beer n Skittles]

4–WAY TRADE (based on current ladder position)
Carlton trade Gibbs to Adelaide for pick #18
Carlton trade pick #18 & 2018 2nd round pick to NMFC for Ben McKay & 2018 1st round pick
NMFC trade pick #4 & #18 to GWS for Josh Kelly

VERDICT:
Carlton: Gain Ben McKay & NMFC 2018 1st round pick. Lose Gibbs & 2018 2nd round pick.
NMFC: Gain Josh Kelly & Carltons 2018 2nd round pick. Lose #4, 2018 1st round pick & Ben McKay.
GWS: Gain #4 & #18. Lose Josh Kelly.
Adelaide: Gain Gibbs. Lose pick #18.

Thoughts?

North are giving up Ben McKay for absolutely no reason in that trade