2018 Rate My Team (Post JLT)

[JRyan23]

First year playing SC, and I've been scoping the threads in here.
Got $75,300 in the bank for a little bit of movement.
View attachment 469135

I like it. Very different to other teams, not sure on Lids, Dunkley and Wilson. I like the Wines pick, not sure if Brodie will play round 1, if he does he will be the best rookie IMO

 

[Shermy]

I like it. Very different to other teams, not sure on Lids, Dunkley and Wilson. I like the Wines pick, not sure if Brodie will play round 1, if he does he will be the best rookie IMO

Cheers. As usual, rookies are subject to change based on selection. I'm happy picking Lids and Wilson, not sold on Dunkley but i trust him more than Bundy.

 

[JRyan23]

Is it okay having 3 players from the same team in the one line, as I have Fyfe, Banfield and Brayshaw. Should I only pick 2 or is lots of people picking these 3

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Is it okay having 3 players from the same team in the one line, as I have Fyfe, Banfield and Brayshaw. Should I only pick 2 or is lots of people picking these 3

i have 4

 

[JRyan23]

i have 4

Okay looks like i'll keep the 3. Thanks!

 

[Jcpdragonx]

I really like the look of Fiorini, looks like extended midfield time, gets the ball (not the best user) but loves a tackle (11 on the weekend). He is an awkward price at 390k but I may look at him as a POD

Just pay another 60k for cogs

 

[JRyan23]

Just pay another 60k for cogs

Already have him lol

 

[Jcpdragonx]

Already have him lol

At 390k you select him as a keeper and hell he aint a top 10 mid or even top 30. Big waste of money.

 

[JRyan23]

At 390k you select him as a keeper and hell he aint a top 10 mid or even top 30. Big waste of money.

Yeah that's what i am thinking but I feel he can consistently score 90+, might look at as an upgrade option

 

[atlas1]

36k left.

Defensive premos should all be top 10 unless something goes wrong.

Holding Danger until he's definitely ruled out, and will hold if he misses Rd 1. Plenty of time before Easter Monday. Value in the mids with Parker and Cripps. Rewarding Libba's JLT form - got a good look at him against the Hawks and he was in ripping nick. No high priced rookies, although coaches who go with Brayshaw/Brodie won't be disappointed.

Stef currently R1 but could be Goldy, depending on teams.

Happy with Greene and Billings but there are concerns over Sicily and Bell. I'm willing to take the punt on these two as IMO their potential is worth the risk. Plus seeing Sicily and Greene together adds a real campaigner nature to the lineup. Sic's def/fwd swing with Keeffey will be handy.

Fritzy gives me the most confidence as a forward rookie, followed by Ryan. Reckon Ryan will get a lot of game time despite being a flashy type of player.

 

[JyeDye]

View attachment 469146

36k left.

Defensive premos should all be top 10 unless something goes wrong.

Holding Danger until he's definitely ruled out, and will hold if he misses Rd 1. Plenty of time before Easter Monday. Value in the mids with Parker and Cripps. Rewarding Libba's JLT form - got a good look at him against the Hawks and he was in ripping nick. No high priced rookies, although coaches who go with Brayshaw/Brodie won't be disappointed.

Stef currently R1 but could be Goldy, depending on teams.

Happy with Greene and Billings but there are concerns over Sicily and Bell. I'm willing to take the punt on these two as IMO their potential is worth the risk. Plus seeing Sicily and Greene together adds a real campaigner nature to the lineup. Sic's def/fwd swing with Keeffey will be handy.

Fritzy gives me the most confidence as a forward rookie, followed by Ryan. Reckon Ryan will get a lot of game time despite being a flashy type of player.

**** me with how garbage the forward rookies you've got massive balls to be going thin on that line. I would rather spend my money on Smith or Petracca forward rather than down back.

 

[pincrusher]

Yeah that's what i am thinking but I feel he can consistently score 90+, might look at as an upgrade option

If u are paying that much for someone then you should be anticipating or hoping they'll be a keeper, otherwise you are better off going with a rookie and using the extra $200k elsewhere.
Nothing in their two JLT games suggests to me he'll break into the top 20 mids in the comp. A year too early IMO.

 

[JRyan23]

200k in the bank. Want to use say about 150k at max of it if i can, but I don't know where (Lyons and Cogs are locks, so don't suggest them)

 

[JRyan23]

If u are paying that much for someone then you should be anticipating or hoping they'll be a keeper, otherwise you are better off going with a rookie and using the extra $200k elsewhere.
Nothing in their two JLT games suggests to me he'll break into the top 20 mids in the comp. A year too early IMO.

Thanks i have taken him out.

 

[JRyan23]

View attachment 469146

36k left.

Defensive premos should all be top 10 unless something goes wrong.

Holding Danger until he's definitely ruled out, and will hold if he misses Rd 1. Plenty of time before Easter Monday. Value in the mids with Parker and Cripps. Rewarding Libba's JLT form - got a good look at him against the Hawks and he was in ripping nick. No high priced rookies, although coaches who go with Brayshaw/Brodie won't be disappointed.

Stef currently R1 but could be Goldy, depending on teams.

Happy with Greene and Billings but there are concerns over Sicily and Bell. I'm willing to take the punt on these two as IMO their potential is worth the risk. Plus seeing Sicily and Greene together adds a real campaigner nature to the lineup. Sic's def/fwd swing with Keeffey will be handy.

Fritzy gives me the most confidence as a forward rookie, followed by Ryan. Reckon Ryan will get a lot of game time despite being a flashy type of player.

POD central with that team. I like it but that forward line is very thin and Tom Bell would struggle to play best 22 i'd say and not the best scorer

 

[birdistheword]

thoughts? 40k in the bank

 

[Golden_6]

Reasonable comfortable running with this for now.

 

[atlas1]

POD central with that team. I like it but that forward line is very thin and Tom Bell would struggle to play best 22 i'd say and not the best scorer

Just going off JLT form. Bell has gone 89 in the past and I reckon he can go close to that again if he has a decent run at it.

 

[RedBulls]

All but done. Got some juicy PODs in McGovern, Walters and McLean who can all change a tad to generate some cash for rookies if they're picked or not. Or if there is some rucking miracle Cameron will go in as my R2.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Ryder misses one so he's an upgrade target for me. I just need Sandi to go beast mode for nine rounds!

Sent from my F8331 using Tapatalk

Had Sandi in my side yesterday .....took him out for Martin, who i've had since R1 .....may go Sandi again, but thinking Martin could be set & forget, whereas Sandi, we know we'll be upgrading & wasting a trade

 

[WaynesWorld19]

today

We'll be lied to though, as to severity & timeframe

 

[Better Loosen Up]

View attachment 469156thoughts? 40k in the bank

Lots of midpricers... maybe too many. How many of your starting forwards will be ranked in the top6 at the end of the year? Same goes for the other lines. I can see you needing a lot of trades to get to a super premo team by the end of the year.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Unless Danger plays round 1 I am going Dangerless and with no money in the bank. I'm playing a very dangerous game this year.

 

[JyeDye]

View attachment 469156thoughts? 40k in the bank

Way to many risks plus I'm pretty sure I got an injury just looking at your midfield.

 

[birdistheword]

Lots of midpricers... maybe too many. How many of your starting forwards will be ranked in the top6 at the end of the year? Same goes for the other lines. I can see you needing a lot of trades to get to a super premo team by the end of the year.

Smith McLean and Walters should be top 6 by the end of the year caddy ofcourse is a risk but that’s why you have 30 trades no point taking no risk and having the same team as everybody else