2018 Rate My Team (Post JLT)

[Keg on legs]

View attachment 460374

Not a bad list

Hurley worries me, especially at the price with a dodgy wrist and likely role change

I wouldn't think O'Shae will score much, but I'm keen to hear from peeps who hace seen more of him than I have

I like Brodie. I have him ahead of others as well.

Gray is interesting after his health concerns and rocky's arrival. Will he be more fwd this year and will that effect him? Let's wait and see

 

[GT619]

Is rayner a must rookie this year

 

[Mitchell54]

Rate my team:

Made one change since last posting my team to one of these threads.

Out: Birchall & Franklin
In: Sicily & D.Smith

Keeping two eyes on Birchalls progress. Not sure if he’ll make it or not

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

Is rayner a must rookie this year

I didn't think McGrath was last year but in the end, I wish I had of taken him. That being said, there's plenty of midfield rookies for a lot less with just as much cash and point generation capacity.

 

[Keg on legs]

I didn't think McGrath was last year but in the end, I wish I had of taken him. That being said, there's plenty of midfield rookies for a lot less with just as much cash and point generation capacity.

Yep. True

 

[Keg on legs]

Rate my team:

Made one change since last posting my team to one of these threads.

Out: Birchall & Franklin
In: Sicily & D.Smith

Keeping two eyes on Birchalls progress. Not sure if he’ll make it or not
View attachment 460445
View attachment 460446

Heater? Have you lost your freaking mind?????????????

I am watching Sicily very closely. Love him at his price and dpp but he is an a grade tool and might get sucked in by being targeted

Mids are tasty except for break down back jom (I wish him well but don't have him so I hope he pulls up lame)

Lice head a nice option to free up cash. I'e had him in my side about 20 times so far

Gray see my previous post.

Good team

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

Rate my team:

Made one change since last posting my team to one of these threads.

Out: Birchall & Franklin
In: Sicily & D.Smith

Keeping two eyes on Birchalls progress. Not sure if he’ll make it or not
View attachment 460445
View attachment 460446

Lots of risks in the fwd line. I'd only pick one of the 4 you have. Strong midfield but it means your rolling the dice everywhere else.

Gray, Walters, Smith, Christensen, Lycett, Simpson, Shaw & Sicily. All a shot into the near dark.....

 

[Waspy79]

Why would Christensen be a better option than Rioli? $40k cheaper yes, but has barely played a game for two years, and when he has, his scoring doesn’t compare to Champion Data’s favourite “pressure act” man.

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

Why would Christensen be a better option than Rioli? $40k cheaper yes, but has barely played a game for two years, and when he has, his scoring doesn’t compare to Champion Data’s favourite “pressure act” man.

Funny that “pressure act” man is still better than anyone running around in a Port jumper

 

[Mitchell54]

Lots of risks in the fwd line. I'd only pick one of the 4 you have. Strong midfield but it means your rolling the dice everywhere else.

Gray, Walters, Smith, Christensen, Lycett, Simpson, Shaw & Sicily. All a shot into the near dark.....

Gray is interesting. Port have brought in 2 forwards(Watts & Motlop) and Rockliff who is a ball magnet.

Don’t like Billings as an option too

Keeping a watchful eye on all others.
Good to have them in the team as it reminds me who I need to keep a watch on.


If Birchall gets up then I can afford to upgrade the forwardline

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Don't like Brayshaw. Just don't think he's a great SC pick and very, very awkwardly priced. Hurley might be injured but who knows. You'd like to see a few preseason games before putting all that money out there. Have a look what happened to all the swans players last year.

Midfield looks strong. But GAJ is a campaigner so I hope he does a knee.

Fwds look strong but for mine, I'd only take one of them.

wishing for a player to do a serious injury is a real dick thing to wish for

just saying

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Is rayner a must rookie this year

no

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Why would Christensen be a better option than Rioli? $40k cheaper yes, but has barely played a game for two years, and when he has, his scoring doesn’t compare to Champion Data’s favourite “pressure act” man.

because Hawks have publicly said they aren't sure when Rioli will come back to competitive football. Christensen has had a full summer and is in better match condition then Rioli.

 

[Mitchell54]

Why would Christensen be a better option than Rioli? $40k cheaper yes, but has barely played a game for two years, and when he has, his scoring doesn’t compare to Champion Data’s favourite “pressure act” man.

50K cheaper

because Hawks have publicly said they aren't sure when Rioli will come back to competitive football. Christensen has had a full summer and is in better match condition then Rioli.

He is one to keep an eye on though. Right now Christensen looks the better option but keep an eye on Rioli.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

50K cheaper

He is one to keep an eye on though. Right now Christensen looks the better option but keep an eye on Rioli.

not denying that, but right now, from what the club has said Christensen is the one youd be starting out of the two

 

[Mitchell54]

I don't get Sicily hype but we will see.

If he can produce what he did at the end of last year then he’s worth it.

 

[Waspy79]

Funny that “pressure act” man is still better than anyone running around in a Port jumper

Wingard > Rioli (by some distance)

 

[Waspy79]

because Hawks have publicly said they aren't sure when Rioli will come back to competitive football. Christensen has had a full summer and is in better match condition then Rioli.

Ha you again. Not sure why you love Christensen so much. I heard Rioli was flying through pre season.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Ha you again. Not sure why you love Christensen so much. I heard Rioli was flying through pre season.

nah, Cyril returned to training like 3 weeks ago

 

[Mitchell54]

nah, Cyril returned to training like 3 weeks ago

The club was positively surprised though at the shape he was in when he came back.

 

[Hawkboy62]

Why would Christensen be a better option than Rioli? $40k cheaper yes, but has barely played a game for two years, and when he has, his scoring doesn’t compare to Champion Data’s favourite “pressure act” man.

Rioli has been back at the club for a few weeks, but only running laps, albeit looking fit. According to the Hun the club has put no timeline on when he will engage in full training. Need to wait a few weeks on him.

 

[Turly]

Sex me

View attachment 460377

Nice team

Any cash left over?

 

[Hai_Newman]

If he can produce what he did at the end of last year then he’s worth it.
View attachment 460476

Wow that is terrible.
No way I'm running with that.
Would rather JOM.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Hi c campaigners hows campaignerville .

First crack and its .

 

[Hai_Newman]

Hi c campaigners hows campaignerville .

First crack and its .

View attachment 460542
View attachment 460543

Hai Rocker champ...looks like a starter team without the craziness and group think that has penetrated us all...nice start.
Birchall is not in full training so that's the first for ya...
You're welcome kenty...