2018 Rookies

[Chaisa]

Hmmm, now that Coffield isn't gonna get a game I need someone else, Cole seemed to have pretty good JS, Here2tellyouwhy Hai_Newman Dark Sharks Double the Fist Suma Magic nameless do you reckon he'll be a walk up start round 2?
I guess he probably could still play round one but I'd doubt he will given the circumstances.

I'd probs go with Naughton, unless you already have him.

 

[Seymour Skinner]

I'd probs go with Naughton, unless you already have him.

Already have him.

Naughton, Murray, Doodee, Finlayson.
Need a 5th.

 

[cbrendan]

Already have him.

Naughton, Murray, Doodee, Finlayson.
Need a 5th.

Payne? Mihocek?

 

[Flandersss]

Already have him.

Naughton, Murray, Doodee, Finlayson.
Need a 5th.

Stoddart

 

[Seymour Skinner]

Payne? Mihocek?

No idea who Payne is.

If Mihocek was playing they would of announced it when they announced Murray and Stephenson.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Stoddart

JS is very shaky, but we thought that with Hayward last year and Papley the year before

 

[Chaisa]

Already have him.

Naughton, Murray, Doodee, Finlayson.
Need a 5th.

Right now I'm taking a mountain-sized punt on Lachlan Murphy. Mihocek could be an option but I don't think he starts R1.

Failing that...back to the drawing board and seeing who's named, or a change in strategy.

 

[atlas1]

Already have him.

Naughton, Murray, Doodee, Finlayson.
Need a 5th.

I have those 4 and Keeffe as the 5th

 

[Jcpdragonx]

2-0-6 is still fine i think, say bonner is a rookie.

prem - prem - Bonner - Naughton - Doedee - Murray - Finlayson - Cole (hoping he's named round 2)

Sicily up front in case of emergency

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Right now I'm taking a mountain-sized punt on Lachlan Murphy. Mihocek could be an option but I don't think he starts R1.

Failing that...back to the drawing board and seeing who's named, or a change in strategy.

Murphy isn't playing, Crows have already announced debutants

 

[Seymour Skinner]

Stoddart

Read that McVeigh could be back round 1.
Makes him seem pretty shaky.
But if named he'll probably be the one.

 

[majortinkle]

Maybe teams are only announcing debutants in their 1st 18s and there’s still a chance for more on the bench....

 

[nameless]

Hmmm, now that Coffield isn't gonna get a game I need someone else, Cole seemed to have pretty good JS, Here2tellyouwhy Hai_Newman Dark Sharks Double the Fist Suma Magic nameless do you reckon he'll be a walk up start round 2?
I guess he probably could still play round one but I'd doubt he will given the circumstances.

I've never considered Cole, he's a lockdown defender
We'll be using Jetta, Hurn, Gov, Dugg, Yeo as rebound.

I would say he'll miss a bit of time to deal with the loss of his father.

Can't believe Coffield won't play - team is in shambles now...

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Maybe teams are only announcing debutants in their 1st 18s and there’s still a chance for more on the bench....

nah, they wouldnt do that.

a little bit of wishful thinking

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

If Coffield is named emergency, people still gonna punt on him coming into the team in the next couple of rounds? he is obviously close?

 

[Moustachio]

If Coffield is named emergency, people still gonna punt on him coming into the team in the next couple of rounds? he is obviously close?

Nope, green dot or GTFO.

 

[KardiniaPark]

There's too many rookies now

 

[Seymour Skinner]

I've never considered Cole, he's a lockdown defender
We'll be using Jetta, Hurn, Gov, Dugg, Yeo as rebound.

I would say he'll miss a bit of time to deal with the loss of his father.

Can't believe Coffield won't play - team is in shambles now...

Scored ok in the JLT.
He'd be a benchwarmer most weeks, he'll probably be the last resort.

 

[Chaisa]

Read that McVeigh could be back round 1.
Makes him seem pretty shaky.
But if named he'll probably be the one.

FTR Fox Sports has Stoddart named in a prospective 22 despite McVeigh being fit.

I can't see McVeigh getting up for Rd 1 so his Rd 1 hopes look pretty decent. JS seems iffy though.

 

[Didstar]

If Coffield is named emergency, people still gonna punt on him coming into the team in the next couple of rounds? he is obviously close?

Will leave as a downgrade option if he scores well in two playing games if not picked. 170k is a lot to pay for uncertainty imo.

 

[Flandersss]

Mirra any chance?

I reckon Clarko will play him to release Burton/Sicily.

 

[stevebbb]

Wow no Coffield... this is some cruel joke!!!!

Sicily to defence
Venables in

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Mirra any chance?

I reckon Clarko will play him to release Burton/Sicily.

hmm maybe, did have 26 in the VFL trial.

wouldnt bank on him though

 

[WaynesWorld19]

No Coffield ?

 

[Mofra]

Wow no Coffield... this is some cruel joke!!!!

Sicily to defence
Venables in

That's a conundrum - I expect Coffield to play and play early, but he is one of the more expensive rookies. Too expensive to have on the bench too long.
I too have Sicily forward as I don't like to rookie forwards (only have two on the bench, Fritsch and Ryan) but may need to roll the dice on a third.