Preview 2019 Draft General Discussion

[Pie 4 Life]

View attachment 554201

Accidentally tagged, not tagged make up your mind what you want

 

[HedgeFund]

Thanx finding information with these dead sites is impossible.

You could just click onto the AFL Vic Record link on the TAC website as they have the full club player lists with heights/weights/DOB in the Record every week.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Knightmare, Pie 4 Life - interested in giving proposed thoughts & positions for each team?

Hard to do given so many bottom-agers are played forward/back in their bottom-age year while some progress to the midfield in their top-age year. Likewise several players like Delahunty and Kemp can play either end.

Team Riewoldt:

B: Brock Smith - Charlie Dean - Lachlan Ash
HB: Trent Bianco - Brodie Kemp - Deven Robertson
C: Darcey Chirgwin - Dylan Stephens - Mitch O'Neill
HF: Connor Budarick - Liam Delahunty - Dylan Williams
F: Rhai Arn Cox - Sam Flanders - Josh Rayner
R: Luke Jackson - Tom Green - Noah Anderson
INT: Andrew Courtney - Jackson Mead - Jack Mahony - Malcolm Rosas - Kysaiah Pickett - Josh Worrell

Team Bartel:

B: Jeremy Sharp - Jack Buller - Karl Finlay
HB: Lachlan Potter - Will Gould - Ryan Gardner
C: Matt Rowell - Caleb Serong - Hugo Ralphsmith
HF: Darcy Cassar - Fisher McAsey - Cameron Taheny
F: Mitchell Georgiades - Emerson Jeka - Elijah Taylor
R: Bigoa Nyuon - Hayden Young - Cooper Stephens
INT: Hewago Paul Oea - Will Chandler - Trent Rivers - Jack Bell - Flynn Perez - Will Martyn

Just a guess...

 

[eDPS]

Hard to do given so many bottom-agers are played forward/back in their bottom-age year while some progress to the midfield in their top-age year. Likewise several players like Delahunty and Kemp can play either end.

Team Riewoldt:

B: Brock Smith - Charlie Dean - Lachlan Ash
HB: Trent Bianco - Brodie Kemp - Deven Robertson
C: Darcey Chirgwin - Dylan Stephens - Mitch O'Neill
HF: Connor Budarick - Liam Delahunty - Dylan Williams
F: Rhai Arn Cox - Sam Flanders - Josh Rayner
R: Luke Jackson - Tom Green - Noah Anderson
INT: Andrew Courtney - Jackson Mead - Jack Mahony - Malcolm Rosas - Kysaiah Pickett - Josh Worrell

Team Bartel:

B: Jeremy Sharp - Jack Buller - Karl Finlay
HB: Lachlan Potter - Will Gould - Ryan Gardner
C: Matt Rowell - Caleb Serong - Hugo Ralphsmith
HF: Darcy Cassar - Fisher McAsey - Cameron Taheny
F: Mitchell Georgiades - Emerson Jeka - Elijah Taylor
R: Bigoa Nyuon - Hayden Young - Cooper Stephens
INT: Hewago Paul Oea - Will Chandler - Trent Rivers - Jack Bell - Flynn Perez - Will Martyn

Just a guess...

And then prepare for the teams to be completely flipped after half time haha

 

[Muffasa]

Hard to do given so many bottom-agers are played forward/back in their bottom-age year while some progress to the midfield in their top-age year. Likewise several players like Delahunty and Kemp can play either end.

Team Riewoldt:

B: Brock Smith - Charlie Dean - Lachlan Ash
HB: Trent Bianco - Brodie Kemp - Deven Robertson
C: Darcey Chirgwin - Dylan Stephens - Mitch O'Neill
HF: Connor Budarick - Liam Delahunty - Dylan Williams
F: Rhai Arn Cox - Sam Flanders - Josh Rayner
R: Luke Jackson - Tom Green - Noah Anderson
INT: Andrew Courtney - Jackson Mead - Jack Mahony - Malcolm Rosas - Kysaiah Pickett - Josh Worrell

Team Bartel:

B: Jeremy Sharp - Jack Buller - Karl Finlay
HB: Lachlan Potter - Will Gould - Ryan Gardner
C: Matt Rowell - Caleb Serong - Hugo Ralphsmith
HF: Darcy Cassar - Fisher McAsey - Cameron Taheny
F: Mitchell Georgiades - Emerson Jeka - Elijah Taylor
R: Bigoa Nyuon - Hayden Young - Cooper Stephens
INT: Hewago Paul Oea - Will Chandler - Trent Rivers - Jack Bell - Flynn Perez - Will Martyn

Just a guess...

Well done! And with those line-ups who wins & by how much?

 

[PMBangers]

Well done! And with those line-ups who wins & by how much?

Team Riewoldt by about 5 goals I'd say, very strong Forward line and Midfield

 

[eDPS]

Team Riewoldt by about 5 goals I'd say, very strong Forward line and Midfield

Can even send the CHB in the middle of at full forward. Sharp in a BP is a nice luxury aswell since he could clean up on a wing

 

[PMBangers]

Looking forward to seeing how Worrell holds up and where they play him, genuine swingman as it stands.
Disappointed Byrnes and Watts weren't included as I thought both had good seasons, but maybe that's just a compliment to the talent Sandy have more than anything else

 

[Chris25]

Team Riewoldt by about 5 goals I'd say, very strong Forward line and Midfield

Team Bartel has the best forward of both teams. And the two best KPDs.

 

[PMBangers]

Team Bartel has the best forward of both teams. And the two best KPDs.

I'd take Team Riewoldt's forward line over Team Bartel, I agree with the KPD comment though. Guess we'll see who's more correct in a few weeks

 

[eDPS]

Those players wouldn’t happen to be from SA?

 

[Chris25]

Those players wouldn’t happen to be from SA?

Of course.

Cam Taheny is the best forward named from either side. Will Gould would be the best KPD in this year’s draft. And Karl Finlay is as good an intercept mark as anyone.

 

[eDPS]

Of course.

Cam Taheny is the best forward named from either side. Will Gould would be the best KPD in this year’s draft. And Karl Finlay is as good an intercept mark as anyone.

Dylan Williams and Sam Flanders say high

 

[Pie 4 Life]

I'm on Team Bartel too. Both have quality midfields, but KPPs are better for Bartel.

 

[Chris25]

Dylan Williams and Sam Flanders say high

And as Taheny leaves them in his wake, they’ll be saying bye.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Let's be honest some of those chosen are not in the best 50 players for their age group in the country but have a good backstory if they make it. Won't say anymore

No need to post in cryptic clues, just say if Team Bartel's ruck was named Bob Smith with the same traits he wouldn't be in the team. That's effectively what you're saying?

 

[Bicks]

No need to post in cryptic clues, just say if Team Bartel's ruck was named Bob Smith with the same traits he wouldn't be in the team. That's effectively what you're saying?

Big Patty a bit stiff?

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Big Patty a bit stiff?

Nah he's not up to that level yet, but Bigoa was in the AFL Academy so he was always going to make it. But yes I'm sure going through the teams there would be a couple more at least that pop out on top. In fairness to Bigoa he was always going to be limited this season with that ridiculous ruck talent at the Stingrays.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Is Daniel Sladojevic injured Chris25 ?

 

[Bicks]

Is Daniel Sladojevic injured Chris25 ?

I can answer that for you, kicked 3 goals for the Panthers on the weekend

http://cdn-sanfl.fluid5.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/03111313/U18_2018-SANFL-Week-1-Stats.pdf

 

[Pie 4 Life]

I can answer that for you, kicked 3 goals for the Panthers on the weekend

http://cdn-sanfl.fluid5.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/03111313/U18_2018-SANFL-Week-1-Stats.pdf

So... why isn't he playing on GF day?

 

[Bicks]

So... why isn't he playing on GF day?

Maybe ask Shifter?

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Maybe ask Shifter?

I dunno, for mine behind Taheny he was the next South Australian I was excited about for next year. Looked good at the U16s last year.

 

[Bicks]

I dunno, for mine behind Taheny he was the next South Australian I was excited about for next year. Looked good at the U16s last year.

I agree and being a former Croweater and an old Panther supporter from way back my old mates at the club think he's pretty special too, as a side note they're a big wrap for Hayden Sampson this year.

 

[Bicks]

I dunno, for mine behind Taheny he was the next South Australian I was excited about for next year. Looked good at the U16s last year.

You could try Zac Millbank, he's usually got the finger on the pulse over there.

https://twitter.com/zacmilbank?lang=en