List Mgmt. 2019 Trade Thread

[MOLTEN GANGLANDS]

Bing with the nice mark and goal

 

[Sab22]

Anyone know who no 4 is for vic country he looks a star. Red boots lad...

Might be Sam Flanders not too sure

 

[Hayes4PM]

We need to clear out some rucks, bring in some rucks and grab another mid and a full back. Brown is nearing the end of his career and I don't really rate Clav from what I've seen this year.

 

[gringo2011]

We need to clear out some rucks, bring in some rucks and grab another mid and a full back. Brown is nearing the end of his career and I don't really rate Clav from what I've seen this year.

Clavarino and Joyce both look like they are potential KPBs. Wilkie, Battle and Carlisle also take a spot. Battle probs moves forward but still a lot to fit in. White took over from Clavrino once he went down in the intra club and was playing on Pierce who he contained easily, knew when to go and wen to sit tight on him. Reminded me of Sicily.

 

[Hayes4PM]

Clavarino and Joyce both look like they are potential KPBs. Wilkie, Battle and Carlisle also take a spot. Battle probs moves forward but still a lot to fit in. White took over from Clavrino once he went down in the intra club and was playing on Pierce who he contained easily, knew when to go and wen to sit tight on him. Reminded me of Sicily.

I'm not sure either of Clav or Joyce have the size to play on big FF's. And I just flat out don't rate either highly from what I've seen, Joyce looks more like Roberton; third tall intercepting defender. We need another big-bodied key position back, not just blokes who can play on some KPF's sometimes.

Also, while I can see White doing okay on medium sized forwards I don't think he'd be any good dealing with Tom Lynch, Josh Kennedy, Mason Cox or those types. Not sure playing on Lewie Pierce counts for heaps honestly, doesn't really look AFL standard unfortunately. Is probably when of the slowest moving, least agile rucks the game has seen.

 

[LeonardHayes87]

Newnes is a FA

Yep, which still holds value as we get compensation for him if he doesn’t put pend to paper.

 

[Mikka84]

Coniglio just putting his hand up as one of the premier mids of the comp.. most disposals to go with most tackles.. complete all rounder.

Pipe dream, but let me dream.

 

[Strahany]

Coniglio just putting his hand up as one of the premier mids of the comp.. most disposals to go with most tackles.. complete all rounder.

Pipe dream, but let me dream.

36D, 10CP, 8T, and 3.0 to boot.

Filthy.

 

[Hayes4PM]

36D, 10CP, 8T, and 3.0 to boot.

Filthy.

He’d be getting similar offers to Kelly last year.

 

[sunny3193]

Might be Sam Flanders not too sure

Left footer so probably his cousin Ned.

 

[sunny3193]

Clavarino and Joyce both look like they are potential KPBs. Wilkie, Battle and Carlisle also take a spot. Battle probs moves forward but still a lot to fit in. White took over from Clavrino once he went down in the intra club and was playing on Pierce who he contained easily, knew when to go and wen to sit tight on him. Reminded me of Sicily.

Given Lewie’s record, maybe not such a noteworthy achievement.

 

[St Pauls]

I hope we try do what Melbourne did with Oliver a few years ago and trade up to grab Anderson or Rowell.

 

[triggering bro]

I hope we try do what Melbourne did with Oliver a few years ago and trade up to grab Anderson or Rowell.

Would need pick 1
Or 2. Unless we trade Gresh or Max King then it ain’t happening!

 

[St Pauls]

Would need pick 1
Or 2. Unless we trade Gresh or Max King then it ain’t happening!

I was thinking of packaging up two first rounders for 1 or 2 and change.

 

[triggering bro]

I was thinking of packaging up two first rounders for 1 or 2 and change.

Prob would need a top 5 pick this year along with next year’s first for 1 or 2

 

[bird_man]

Everyone team would love pick 1 or 2 this year but no one would give up the ridiculous price it would cost.

Looks to be some pretty good prospects around pick 8 so if you don't want to get your hopes up start checking those kids out.

 

[VDS66]

I reckon he does. Who would you have currently playing that's better? I have our best as Stuv, Gresh, Billings, Ross, Carlisle, Webster/ Members, Geary, Newnes maybe. It's pretty hard to make a case for any to be above others after around 7. Parker is looking very good to me and our most dangerous player in the forward half now.

Savage, Lonie, Bruce, Steele, Marshall...

 

[plugger66]

Didn't hear him, it seems to be a common thought from people outside the club. Dal seemed to be a big advocate for the idea of sending RoMa forward.

Many more say he is a very promising ruck. Hardly common that 2 think he should play forward

 

[plugger66]

Yep, which still holds value as we get compensation for him if he doesn’t put pend to paper.

Probably a third rounder at best. Got to be honest and doubt anyone would really be chasing him

 

[SaintsSeptember]

Clavarino and Joyce both look like they are potential KPBs. Wilkie, Battle and Carlisle also take a spot. Battle probs moves forward but still a lot to fit in. White took over from Clavrino once he went down in the intra club and was playing on Pierce who he contained easily, knew when to go and wen to sit tight on him. Reminded me of Sicily.

Some of them get better as they get older too.
Gilbert was hopeless in a lock down role when he was young. But he can play full back if called on now.
Same with Jason Blake.

 

[goodie23]

Prob would need a top 5 pick this year along with next year’s first for 1 or 2

Depends how the relevant teams rate us looking ahead. If they see others overtaking us they might be tempted by a 5-10 pick. Adelaide chose Carlton's offer over ours for that infamous live trade last year for this reason.

 

[ScrappyDo]

Prob would need a top 5 pick this year along with next year’s first for 1 or 2

Depends the SA kids. The crows obviously prefer local boys so if they can get who they want with our pick/s then it's game on.
Maybe we get a pick for Stuv, maybe a 2nd rounder comes in from another trade. All things are possible..

 

[Sheeza69]

Lewis Taylor would fit right in to our best 18 & give us some much needed speed on the outside..
Out of contract this year from memory..

 

[Mowman]

Highly doubt anyone giving up pick 1 or 2 not going to let these two mids go

 

[SaintsSeptember]

Probably a third rounder at best. Got to be honest and doubt anyone would really be chasing him

If he's a free agent and no-one is chasing him, he'll stay at the Saints.
If he goes they'll pay him accordingly. He won't leave for a pay cut. You think he's unhappy at the Saints?
So he gets a payrise and we get 2nd round minimum.