No Oppo Supporters 2020 General AFL Discussion

[mikey_san]

Brisbane v Cats GF for me.
Cats will be hungrier than Tigers or WC who aren't as good away from home anyways.

Be funny to see Rohan get a Norm Smith.

 

[bedford]

Brisbane v Cats GF for me.
Cats will be hungrier than Tigers or WC who aren't as good away from home anyways.

Be funny to see Rohan get a Norm Smith.

Hilarious

 

[Dubai Quacker]

Hilarious

Nearly as funny as Zac Jones winning the Norm Smith & Membrey kicking 5 if St Kilda snag the flag.

 

[bedford]

Nearly as funny as Zac Jones winning the Norm Smith & Membrey kicking 5 if St Kilda snag the flag.

They don't win flags

 

[bedford]

I reckon Butters is stiff to get 2

 

[kelpie_X]

Brisbane v Cats GF for me.
Cats will be hungrier than Tigers or WC who aren't as good away from home anyways.

Be funny to see Rohan get a Norm Smith.

about as funny as cancer

 

[RobbieK]

I reckon Butters is stiff to get 2

He isn't. He intentionally bumped, he hit the guy's head, concussed him and he couldn't take further part in the game.

 

[bedford]

He isn't. He intentionally bumped, he hit the guy's head, concussed him and he couldn't take further part in the game.

That's fair , but what about rats like the Silk at Hawthorn that's much worse

 

[The King!]

 

[dosser]

Loving watching Clarkson's petulance damaging the Hawthorn 'brand'

 

[bedford]

Loving watching Clarkson's petulance damaging the Hawthorn 'brand'

Now there's an angry man. He has turned like his President in to the biggest sooks in Victoria

 

[The King!]

Now there's an angry man. He has turned like his President in to the biggest sooks in Victoria

Jeff is a star

 

[bedford]

Jeff is a star

He's president of scum

 

[The King!]

He's president of scum

yeah thats a shame, but the odd ok person is at hawthorn

 

[The King!]

Off topic but the podcast with Steve Bracks and Jeff Kennett was fantastic on the 99 vic election


I think at beyond blue he did good things that’s where I got to meet him

 

[bedford]

Should we take a risk with Kreuzer for 1 year as a back up

 

[Kapers]

Should we take a risk with Kreuzer for 1 year as a back up

imo, look at how jacobs worked out for GWS.

I would prefer Stefan Martin personally, but you never know what will and won't work.

 

[bedford]

imo, look at how jacobs worked out for GWS.

I would prefer Stefan Martin personally, but you never know what will and won't work.

Martin has a contract , Kruezer will be delisted with Betts

 

[S120]

Should we take a risk with Kreuzer for 1 year as a back up

If we were a finals side and looking to bolster the list to get closer to a flag, I'd be all for it. But given where our list is, I don't see much point in getting him in when we've already got Sinclair who's older/experienced and would be most reliable as a back-up - he's played years of first ruck for us and is still up to seniors but we need a more solid first ruck for next year (we've needed it for years in fact). I'd be after a younger ruck who can come in and take the first ruck mantle so Sinclair can become slot into his more natural 2nd ruck/forward role.

 

[bedford]

If we were a finals side and looking to bolster the list to get closer to a flag, I'd be all for it. But given where our list is, I don't see much point in getting him in when we've already got Sinclair who's older/experienced and would be most reliable as a back-up - he's played years of first ruck for us and is still up to seniors but we need a more solid first ruck for next year (we've needed it for years in fact). I'd be after a younger ruck who can come in and take the first ruck mantle so Sinclair can become slot into his more natural 2nd ruck/forward role.

He hasn't really played years. It's a back up as Knoll is untried and who knows with Gunnadah gun.

 

[bedford]

Last round v Geelong Sunday 20th Sep at 3 35 at Metricon

 

[bedford]

Key dates.
Free agency Oct 30- Nov 6
Trade Nov 4-12
Draft and Rookie Draft . TBA but maybe Dec 7

 

[Swansujelly]

lol GWS, love to see it

 

[dazedjosh]

Should we take a risk with Kreuzer for 1 year as a back up

I'd say no, Sinclair is still physically capable of rucking and getting around the ground while Kreuzer will just get injured after a couple of games. I'd rather we get a young ruck to use as a backup. I'm also assuming we're delisting Knoll and probably Amartey at the end of the season. If we do bring in a ruck, then it should be a number 1 ruck to challenge Sinclair.

 

[bedford]

I'd say no, Sinclair is still physically capable of rucking and getting around the ground while Kreuzer will just get injured after a couple of games. I'd rather we get a young ruck to use as a backup. I'm also assuming we're delisting Knoll and probably Amartey at the end of the season. If we do bring in a ruck, then it should be a number 1 ruck to challenge Sinclair.

Sinclair is not a number 1 ruck , he's a 2nd ruck that can go forward. Amartey is a tad the same , but will be still on the list . We had a number 1 ruck in Nankervis , but f 'd up with that . All i'm saying is have a back up and probably get him for nothing.