Remove this Banner Ad

Opinion 2023 AFL Draft Prospects

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dav1d
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

Who do you want for our first pick at the AFL Draft?


  • Total voters
    104
  • Poll closed .

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

AFL Academy coach Tarkyn Lockyer says likely No. 1 draft pick Harley Reid is “not a finished product” yet but has been handling the attention on him well in the early part of the year.

Recruiters believe Reid is a clear standout in this year’s draft pool and that any team wanting to trade for the No. 1 pick to secure him would potentially have to give up three other top-10 picks in return.

Reid has spent the past two weeks playing in the VFL with Carlton, where he has been particularly impressive across halfback.

However, the 18-year-old’s teammates will become his opponents on Saturday when he plays for the AFL Academy side in an exhibition match against Carlton’s VFL side at Marvel Stadium.

“Like every player that comes out of the out of the talent programs, he’s certainly not a finished product,” Lockyer said of Reid.

“He’s got opportunities to continue to grow in his game and we’ll support all of his other programs with that as well. He’s on a journey but he’s going pretty well. Half of the job is actually trying to stay out of his way a little bit. He’s a clear talent so you’ve got to let him do his thing.”

Lockyer said Reid had been largely unfazed by the attention he was receiving and was firmly focused on each of his football programs this year.
“He’s been terrific,” Lockyer said.

“The one really good thing about Harley and all of the programs that he’s associated with — Bendigo, Vic Country and the AFL Academy — is that we’re all in really good alignment on where he’s at.

“He’s got some great support around him and we feel like we’re setting him up pretty well.”

The AFL Academy side is playing a second exhibition match this year, having also taken on Port Adelaide’s SANFL side during Gather Round last month.
“One of the main philosophies around the Academy experience is learning,” Lockyer said.

“With the first one, everything that’s associated with the game is just a little bit different. There are opportunities to grow and put some strategies in place to better prepare the second time around.”

Saturday’s match kicks off at 4.10pm and will be played as a curtain-raiser to Carlton’s AFL match against the Western Bulldogs at Marvel Stadium that night.

WATSON TRIALLING NEW ROLE

The most exciting small forward in this year’s draft pool is set to again feature across halfback for the AFL Academy team on Saturday.

Eastern Ranges product Nick Watson played a half in defence for the AFL Academy team during its match against Port Adelaide’s SANFL team last month and impressed.

Watson spent much of his juniors playing as a midfielder, before settling as a crafty goalkicking small forward in recent years.

“The majority of our group are midfield-forwards,” Lockyer said.

“So we have to try and give players opportunity to experience something else. With Nick, we had a bit of a look at it through the Eastern Rangers in the Coates Talent League. He played a little bit of halfback there and I was keen to use him there. We saw his clean hands, decision making and ball use by foot.

I thought he looked pretty comfortable back there so I wouldn’t be surprised if he sits behind the ball again at some stage on Saturday.”

Watson kicked five goals across his first three games for the Ranges this season, after averaging 2.6 goals a game from seven matches in his bottom-age season last year.

Small forward Nick Watson has found himself in a new role across halfback at stages this year. Picture: Getty Images


Small forward Nick Watson has found himself in a new role across halfback at stages this year. Picture: Getty Images

ROGERS BOLTING UP DRAFT BOARDS

The Gold Coast Suns may have to match an earlier than expected bid on Jake Rogers in this year’s national draft after a hot start to the year from the midfielder.

The Suns Academy member – who is also part of the AFL Academy squad – has been one of the early-season bolters.

Across three Coates Talent League matches, he has averaged 26 disposals, 7 tackles, 6.7 clearances, 5.7 score involvements and 145 ranking points.

Rogers also impressed for the AFL Academy side in its first exhibition match against Port Adelaide’s SANFL side last month, racking up 12 disposals, seven tackles and a goal.

“Jake’s had a fantastic pre-season,” Lockyer said.

“Like all of the Gold Coast Academy players that are in the AFL Academy, he got the opportunity to pretty much do a full pre-season with the Suns. So the physical preparation and the learning and the training standards that Jake was exposed to have clearly set him up to be pretty successful so far this year.

He’s got speed and he values working both sides of the ball in offence and defence. He had some extraordinary numbers of tackles. He’s one that’s certainly pretty exciting for us.”


Gold Coast Academy prospect Jake Rogers has had a big start to the season. Picture: Getty Images


Gold Coast Academy prospect Jake Rogers has had a big start to the season. Picture: Getty Images


STEVENS LEADING FROM THE FRONT

He has played just a handful of games this year after returning from an ACL injury that sidelined him for almost 18 months, but highly-rated draft prospect George Stevens hasn’t missed a beat so far this season.

Stevens logged 16 disposals in his VFL debut for Geelong a fortnight ago, after producing some big games for the Greater Western Victoria Rebels in the first three rounds of the Coates Talent League season.

Viewed as an inside midfielder in the long-term, Stevens has been playing a new role across halfback in the early part of the season as he has returned to footy and built his match fitness back up.

He will again play for the AFL Academy side on Saturday, after racking up 19 disposals and six rebound 50s in the side’s first exhibition match against Port Adelaide’s SANFL side.

“He stepped back into the Coates League in the early rounds and performed pretty well and he’s feeling quite confident,” Lockyer said.

“Over the past couple of weeks he got an opportunity to go and play with Geelong’s VFL team, which was terrific. The other thing with George is his leadership and standing within the group developed really quickly. He’s got an ability to bring people together so his impact on the group has been quite significant.”

Stevens hails from South Warrnambool Football Club — the same country club that produced star Brisbane Lions midfielder Hugh McCluggage.
His brother, Archie Stevens, is playing VFL football with Carlton.


George Stevens has been leading from the front since returning from an ACL injury this year. Picture: Getty Images


George Stevens has been leading from the front since returning from an ACL injury this year. Picture: Getty Images

TASSIE MIDFIELDER EXCITING

A new Tasmanian AFL team is generating added interest in talent from the Apple Isle and one of the best this year is Colby McKercher.

The midfielder has made an impressive start to the season, having been likened by recruiters to being a quicker version of Essendon captain Zach Merrett.

In his first four games for the Tasmania Devils in the Coates Talent League, McKercher has averaged 31.3 disposals, 8 score involvements, 6 clearances and 0.8 goals for a total of 129 ranking points.

He was also one of the better players for the AFL Academy side in its first exhibition match against Port Adelaide’s SANFL team and will feature again against Carlton’s VFL side on Saturday.

“Colby is a really exciting talent,” Lockyer said.

“His season last year as a bottom-ager for the Tassie Devils was terrific. He got an opportunity to play for the Allies and then this year he’s taken it up another step again. He’s certainly one player that knows how to find the football and he’s got great speed and really good awareness as well. He’s certainly one to keep an eye on.”

https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/draft/afl-draft-harley-reid-to-feature-for-afl-academy-against-carlton-nick-watsons-positional-move-and-more/news-story/904444428ea83364e7e1b7a086267d7f
 
Mid season draft thoughts - Luke Teal was unlucky not to get drafted last year, he was ****ed by illness and injury. Played as a mid size defender who could play a good lockdown role. Has an excellent kick. Has now moved to the midfield and is looking good there.
Yep but likely will be gone by our pick though.
 
Shaun Mannagh has been thrown around by a mate with Werribee connections that the dogs have enquired about.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Mid season draft thoughts - Luke Teal was unlucky not to get drafted last year, he was ****ed by illness and injury. Played as a mid size defender who could play a good lockdown role. Has an excellent kick. Has now moved to the midfield and is looking good there.

Where’s he playing?
 
Definitely need to pick goodcop badcop 's brains over choosing a winger and a medium intercept defender with our firsts in the phantom draft. Definitely see it with Freijah, but no idea what we'd do with Evans that we're not already doing with Luke Cleary.
We do need a winger
 
Definitely need to pick goodcop badcop 's brains over choosing a winger and a medium intercept defender with our firsts in the phantom draft. Definitely see it with Freijah, but no idea what we'd do with Evans that we're not already doing with Luke Cleary.
What can you tell us about Freijah?
 
Definitely need to pick goodcop badcop 's brains over choosing a winger and a medium intercept defender with our firsts in the phantom draft. Definitely see it with Freijah, but no idea what we'd do with Evans that we're not already doing with Luke Cleary.

It's really more the fact I rate those guys higher then the current players on offer, I'm very much of the view to go best available in the first round unless we have a surplus of the same type. Admittedly I really haven't seen much of one the favourites on here in McAuliffe and what I have seen of him I haven't been overly impressed. I will be keenly watching him in the champs though. As for others Cooper Simpson does some really good things and would suit us as a defensively minded inside mid, but not sure he's a first rounder. Will Brown is another I've seen talked about, but I have big doubts about whether he's clean enough inside the contest to be a full time mid.

As for the ones I selected. Evans I thought would get some questions and I sort of get it. At the end of the day, he's just a better talent then Cleary and I do like Cleary. He has a better offensive and defensive game IMO. He can also play on a few different opponents, so they both could still fit into the same lineup.
As for Freijah, he has some scope to be an onballer in the future so may not be just a winger. He's already spending some time as an onballer, including on the weekend in young guns game he was used onball at times. His handball game is quite brilliant and he's clean enough.

At the end of the day, if we do miss out on an inside mid. There's always the option of trading in the future. Usually they are easier to find and there's more around in the trade period. I also think Williams could be an inside mid no problem, we just need more wing options if that happens. Ethan Stanley is another option for a mid season recruit. He was good in both of the young gun games.
 
eb8b54ec9601613db3d6ad92acb838dbb47506da.jpg

ALEX HOLT​

Club: Sturt FC/ Glenunga Rams FC
Height: 183 cm
Weight: 81 kg
DOB: 28/01/05
A composed defender with the ability to intercept as well as play close and negate a dangerous forward, Holt was South Australia’s best player in an under-18 representative game against NSW-ACT as a bottom-age player last year. He has started his 2023 season very well, moving from a dominant 26-disposal game in the under-18s to playing consistently in four reserves matches. He is now on the verge of senior selection for Sturt in the SANFL. Holt is a good decision maker who uses the ball effectively by hand and foot.


Small lockdown defender potential?
 
Not sure it’s relevant , but a relative of mine who’s best mate is a Bulldog recruiter tells me we watched a ruckman out of the Albury Wodonga area.

Doubt this would have anything to do with the mid season.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Controversial opinion. But I would be okay with passing on Croft, if it means strengthening other positions and general depth. I don't get caught up in the romance of surnames personally. He would be handy, but not a need. I remember being at NAB Final with Foster in it, and a Bulldogs member was telling me we better draft him, he is a very good player. Bumped into him the next season, was livid and pissed at the club we passed on him. Couple years later he was not even on a list.

I think this years draft should be MID MID MID. We have nothing outside of Smith in terms of talent midfielders coming through, that are a good size for the modern game. Those "inside fwd/mids" we have in the VFL are to small for the center at AFL level, and are not game aware and clean enough with the ball.

Also Gold Coast are apparently open to trading pick 8 (current) out for points, for their collection of academy players. So if by any chance we land more picks in the second round and later. I would be open to packaging all of our second to late round picks, to take a shot at their first round pick. Land ourselves three first round picks in a solid looking draft year.

If we could land all three of....

McAuliffe (188cm / 88kg)- Think one touch Dunks (tackling ability), and one pinch of Libba. Elite inside extractor who reads and feeds team mates well.
Freijah (192cm / 86kg) - Strong in contests, good at ground level, ball use, can kick goals. Find heaps of the ball. But importantly stays wide as a winger should.
McKercher (181cm / 72cm) - Very quick clearance player with an elite boot. We said we want a player to burst out of the blocks yes?

.... I reckon it will set the foundations for a midfield to develop and step up over the next couple of years. Libba and Adds will probably be gone, Macrae has lost a step, and we need a proper winger. With a good mix of skills, size and positions. Then we just need to find a Jones and Doc replacements. Then our team with be pretty balanced for the next generation. Throw Smith in the mix as well, and it could be a decent center bounce unit.

Of course it is only 1/3 of the way though both AFL and development league seasons. Plenty will change between now and then. Those three could easily rise in rankings and be out of reach of our likely picks in the teens.


COLBY McKERCHER​

Club: Tasmanian Devils/ Launceston FC / Launceston College
Height: 181 cm
Weight: 72 kg
DOB: 12/04/05
A left-footed midfielder with dazzling speed away from the centre of the ground, McKercher also has a penetrating foot. After a very promising season with the Devils and Allies in 2022 as a bottom-age player, he has taken another step this season. McKercher has been averaging 31.3 disposals for the Devils and was among the best for the Australian under-18 team in its match against Port Adelaide’s SANFL side in April. He also impressed in a second match with the AFL Academy side against Carlton’s VFL team in May, logging 20 disposals and three clearances through the midfield.


KANE McAULIFFE​

Club: North Adelaide FC/Central Augusta FC
Height: 188 cm
Weight: 88 kg
DOB: 1/3/2005
A big-bodied midfielder, McAuliffe wins his own ball and is a penetrating left-foot kick. He was held back by a groin injury in 2022, but has started this season strongly. Across his opening five matches in the under-18s, he averaged 26.2 disposals, 5.2 clearances and 5.8 tackles. He has also featured in the reserves for North Adelaide this season.


JOEL FREIJAH​

Club: GWV Rebels/ Horsham Saints/Ballarat Clarendon College
Height: 191 cm
Weight: 86 kg
DOB: 14/11/05
A wingman who has real composure with the ball, Freijah is clean below his knees and distributes the ball very well. He has been in outstanding form in recent weeks. He produced a best-on-ground performance for the Rebels in Round 4 of the Coates Talent League, kicking six goals from 26 disposals while predominantly playing on a wing. Freijah backed that up with 35 disposals in a Vic Country trial in his very next match. He holds his width when playing on the wing, providing his team with an outlet option with its ball movement. However, he can also play inside, where he uses his vision and footy smarts to set up the play. A strong all-round athlete, Freijah ran a time of 2.98 seconds in the 20 metre sprint during pre-season testing.
 
Last edited:
Are we really going to rule out drafting any Tasmanian through fear we can’t keep them? Guess we should rule out all the SA, WA and NSW kids too.

If a kids good and fits what we want back in our system to keep them. Otherwise stick to Victorian kids and limit ourselves
 
Joel Freijah is currently my favourite late first round level prospect. He would need 2 years to get the full fitness he needs to be a primary wing player. Playing wide and being a frequently used outlet is a good skill.

Playing with width is important at AFL level. I could see him playing early but without the fitness to be a top line option, it would be better to wait and build his fitness.

Originally I was hoping to trade this pick for Bergman. After the top 10 players, I usually see more value in trading picks 11-20 for younger ready made players. After watching both, I would rather draft Freijah. I know that means having to wait 2 years longer but the potential output I see as much higher with Freijah.
 
Last edited:
Not sure it’s relevant , but a relative of mine who’s best mate is a Bulldog recruiter tells me we watched a ruckman out of the Albury Wodonga area.

Doubt this would have anything to do with the mid season.

Not a ruckman but Connor O’Sullivan is from out that way. 198cm utility.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
Definitely need to pick goodcop badcop 's brains over choosing a winger and a medium intercept defender with our firsts in the phantom draft. Definitely see it with Freijah, but no idea what we'd do with Evans that we're not already doing with Luke Cleary.
I think a winger / outside mid is a need we should consider with one of our first two picks.
Wilson is the consensus top wing pick of the 'available' players, haven't seen Freijah
 
IF Luke Teal is gone, then Sam Gilbey would be who I would like us to look at drafting in the mid season draft. Intercept/rebounding defender who I expected to get drafted last year and he had a bad year lost to injuries and illness. He has recovered from his broken leg and looks set to be playing for Claremont soon.

With the modern game where turnovers cause most of the scoring, intercept defenders are valuable.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Controversial opinion. But I would be okay with passing on Croft, if it means strengthening other positions and general depth. I don't get caught up in the romance of surnames personally. He would be handy, but not a need. I remember being at NAB Final with Foster in it, and a Bulldogs member was telling me we better draft him, he is a very good player. Bumped into him the next season, was livid and pissed at the club we passed on him. Couple years later he was not even on a list.

I think this years draft should be MID MID MID. We have nothing outside of Smith in terms of talent midfielders coming through, that are a good size for the modern game. Those "inside fwd/mids" we have in the VFL are to small for the center at AFL level, and are not game aware and clean enough with the ball.

Also Gold Coast are apparently open to trading pick 8 (current) out for points, for their collection of academy players. So if by any chance we land more picks in the second round and later. I would be open to packaging all of our second to late round picks, to take a shot at their first round pick. Land ourselves three first round picks in a solid looking draft year.

If we could land all three of....

McAuliffe (188cm / 88kg)- Think one touch Dunks (tackling ability), and one pinch of Libba. Elite inside extractor who reads and feeds team mates well.
Freijah (192cm / 86kg) - Strong in contests, good at ground level, ball use, can kick goals. Find heaps of the ball. But importantly stays wide as a winger should.
McKercher (181cm / 72cm) - Very quick clearance player with an elite boot. We said we want a player to burst out of the blocks yes?

.... I reckon it will set the foundations for a midfield to develop and step up over the next couple of years. Libba and Adds will probably be gone, Macrae has lost a step, and we need a proper winger. With a good mix of skills, size and positions. Then we just need to find a Jones and Doc replacements. Then our team with be pretty balanced for the next generation. Throw Smith in the mix as well, and it could be a decent center bounce unit.

Of course it is only 1/3 of the way though both AFL and development league seasons. Plenty will change between now and then. Those three could easily rise in rankings and be out of reach of our likely picks in the teens.


COLBY McKERCHER​

Club: Tasmanian Devils/ Launceston FC / Launceston College
Height: 181 cm
Weight: 72 kg
DOB: 12/04/05
A left-footed midfielder with dazzling speed away from the centre of the ground, McKercher also has a penetrating foot. After a very promising season with the Devils and Allies in 2022 as a bottom-age player, he has taken another step this season. McKercher has been averaging 31.3 disposals for the Devils and was among the best for the Australian under-18 team in its match against Port Adelaide’s SANFL side in April. He also impressed in a second match with the AFL Academy side against Carlton’s VFL team in May, logging 20 disposals and three clearances through the midfield.


KANE McAULIFFE​

Club: North Adelaide FC/Central Augusta FC
Height: 188 cm
Weight: 88 kg
DOB: 1/3/2005
A big-bodied midfielder, McAuliffe wins his own ball and is a penetrating left-foot kick. He was held back by a groin injury in 2022, but has started this season strongly. Across his opening five matches in the under-18s, he averaged 26.2 disposals, 5.2 clearances and 5.8 tackles. He has also featured in the reserves for North Adelaide this season.


JOEL FREIJAH​

Club: GWV Rebels/ Horsham Saints/Ballarat Clarendon College
Height: 191 cm
Weight: 86 kg
DOB: 14/11/05
A wingman who has real composure with the ball, Freijah is clean below his knees and distributes the ball very well. He has been in outstanding form in recent weeks. He produced a best-on-ground performance for the Rebels in Round 4 of the Coates Talent League, kicking six goals from 26 disposals while predominantly playing on a wing. Freijah backed that up with 35 disposals in a Vic Country trial in his very next match. He holds his width when playing on the wing, providing his team with an outlet option with its ball movement. However, he can also play inside, where he uses his vision and footy smarts to set up the play. A strong all-round athlete, Freijah ran a time of 2.98 seconds in the 20 metre sprint during pre-season testing.
That is a fair point with Croft and we'll have to see how the season pans out, but if he is a genuine top 20 quality draftee and we can get him with a few picks in the 40s-60s, it's gonna be hard not to take that option.

The system is set up in such a way that a quality father-son candidate is almost impossible to pass up.
 
It wouldn’t surprised me if we didn’t, keep an extra spot open for the draft.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
I'd prefer we pass. There is no player that screams out AFL grader in a position of need for us. Only one player appeals to me really. Plus I rather see a whole years sample than just a handful of games. Makes list management at the end of the season a little easier as well.
 
Twomey reporting on the radio that some clubs won't use their mid season pick.
Prefer if we took a young ruckman

Sweet likely traded or delisted so need to start building that depth
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom