Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 8 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
The next captain after the Bont will be Freijah!!! Mark my wordsLeadership qualities will be good. Can take over Bont when he decides to hand over the captaincy.
I don’t think we need a key defender with JOD (21), Buss (20) and Croft (19) already on the list, plus Jones and Lobb going around again, and Gardy contracted to 2026.Priorities for me:
- Inside/outside mid with line-breaking capabilities, either through speed or skill
- Small-medium shutdown defender
- High half forward
- Developing key defender
The problem here is that Gardner and Keath are taking up development slots for little AFL reward, not that we've got too many developing key defenders.I don’t think we need a key defender with JOD (21), Buss (20) and Croft (19) already on the list, plus Jones and Lobb going around again, and Gardy contracted to 2026.
Already this year we’ve had Gardy playing VFL football as a KPF/Ruck and have been playing Croft up forward despite there being no path to the AFL team in that position.
I’d like a speculative KPF deep in the draft just to straighten us up at VFL level with the opportunity to learn from Naughton and Jamarra (Darcy can’t really teach how to be an enormous unicorn).
Agree on Gardner and Keath. How many developing KPD do you need though? Adding 1 more might make sense if we don’t see Croft in that position.The problem here is that Gardner and Keath are taking up development slots for little AFL reward, not that we've got too many developing key defenders.
Croft keeps being brought up in these discussions but we've seen no indication that the club sees him as a key defender long-term, let alone that he will be a good one.
There is little point drafting a KPF who has no path into the AFL side. You're better off signing a state leaguer to the VFL side.
I'm not spending big on a developing KPD but I do think we could use one more. I'd be tapping Keath on the shoulder and playing Gardner forward for the 5-10 games he's actually fit for. Jones, Lobb (if he can back it up) and JOD in the AFL side, with Buss, draftee and Khamis in the VFL is a fine mix.
I'm all in on Barrat if we go for a tall defender.O’Farrell would be my pick of the KPD’s but he’ll probably go earlier than we are prepared to go tall. However he’d be exciting to add to the list, can play forward as well.
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
It's always easy to get excited but looks a great draft yearThis is the Herald Sun's Top 50 (Chris Cavanagh and Dan Batten)
- Jagga Smith
- Levi Ashcroft
- Finn O’Sullivan
- Josh Smillie
- Sid Draper
- Sam Lalor
- Luke Trainor
- Murphy Reid
- Harry Armstrong
- Harvey Langford
- Leo Lombard
- Bo Allan
- Issac Kako
- Tobie Travaglia
- Taj Hotton
- Matt Whitlock
- Xavier Lindsay
- Christian Moraes
- Joe Berry
- Jack Whitlock
- Jobe Shanahan
- Alex Dodson
- Sam Marshall
- Cooper Hynes
- Tom Gross
- Jonty Faull
- Logan Smith
- Harrison Oliver
- Noah Mraz
- Alixzander Tauru
- Jesse Dattoli
- Tom Sims
- Harry O’Farrell
- Ben Camporeale
- Angus Clarke
- Adrian Cole
- Archer Day-Wicks
- Charlie Nicholls
- Xavier Ivisic
- Lachie Jacques
- Josh Dolan
- Jasper Alger
- Joel Cochran
- Clancy Dennis
- Lucas Camporeale
- James Barrat
- Ollie Warburton
- Jaxon Artemis
- Malakai Champion
- Tyler Welsh
I'm think Langford is a late bolter, perhaps into the top 3 or 4. His late season form was outstanding.
Tom Gross - has anyone seen him play? He really needs to 'run' the ball more than stop and prop. Kid needs a lot of coaching.
Tyler Welsh already looks like he's in his mid-20s. Crows get a bargain.
Travaglia is Ed Richards mk 2.
Harrison Oliver is underrated. I think he's the type who probably won't be a star but will be absolutely loved by his teammates and coaches.
I'd take Luke Urquhart as a late pick.
I'm think Langford is a late bolter, perhaps into the top 3 or 4. His late season form was outstanding.
Tom Gross - has anyone seen him play? He really needs to 'run' the ball more than stop and prop. Kid needs a lot of coaching.
Tyler Welsh already looks like he's in his mid-20s. Crows get a bargain.
Travaglia is Ed Richardsmk 2.PLAYERCARDSTART20Ed Richards
- Age
- 25
- Ht
- 188cm
- Wt
- 89kg
- Pos.
- D/M
CareerSeasonLast 5
- D
- 12.4
- 3star
- K
- 7.2
- 3star
- HB
- 5.2
- 4star
- M
- 2.5
- 3star
- T
- 2.4
- 4star
- MG
- 201.4
- 3star
- D
- 11.3
- 3star
- K
- 6.0
- 2star
- HB
- 5.3
- 3star
- M
- 1.5
- 2star
- T
- 2.5
- 3star
- MG
- 198.3
- 3star
- D
- 14.6
- 4star
- K
- 9.8
- 4star
- HB
- 4.8
- 4star
- M
- 4.8
- 5star
- T
- 2.6
- 4star
- MG
- 232.4
- 4star
PLAYERCARDEND
Harrison Oliver is underrated. I think he's the type who probably won't be a star but will be absolutely loved by his teammates and coaches.
I'd take Luke Urquhart as a late pick.
I actually think this draft isn't as cut and dry as some suggest and plenty of kids will "split" the recruiters. I think this will be a good draft for late picks tooNot sure why they have Langford at 10, think Twomey has him at 3 or 4. I'd certainly pick him above Smillie who I'm not sure comes as advertised as that Tom Green or Cripps type of player. Highly talented, but think he has some Tim English levels of aggression and can get pushed off the ball too easily for such a big body at times.
I tend to agree on Gross, I'm not as excited by him as I am many others now. Would much prefer someone like Oliver over him.
As for Urquhart, if we think we can improve his kicking, I don't mind this. There's a few decent small forwards and backs I like too. Hopefully we still cut 4 or 5 off the list, you may even find a few gems in the rookie draft this year.
I actually think this draft isn't as cut and dry as some suggest and plenty of kids will "split" the recruiters. I think this will be a good draft for late picks too
IIRC it was Nick Austin from 2018 - 2019, then Milesi took over at the start of 2020.Can someone outline who our head recruiter has been year to year since Dalrymple left? I've lost track of who and when
Agree Travaglia is the one that I have liked the look of the most don't know if we'll have a pick high enough to get him though.Agree on Travaglia. Think he is the one I want the most. Can see him being an immediate star off half back that can move into the midfield in a few years time in the mould of Richards / Day / Young.
Which will be perfect timing with Treloar / Libba having a few years left.
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
Phoenix Hargrave is another inside type I wouldn't mind late, looks like he has a real physical presence from what I've seen.Not sure why they have Langford at 10, think Twomey has him at 3 or 4. I'd certainly pick him above Smillie who I'm not sure comes as advertised as that Tom Green or Cripps type of player. Highly talented, but think he has some Tim English levels of aggression and can get pushed off the ball too easily for such a big body at times.
I tend to agree on Gross, I'm not as excited by him as I am many others now. Would much prefer someone like Oliver over him.
As for Urquhart, if we think we can improve his kicking, I don't mind this. There's a few decent small forwards and backs I like too. Hopefully we still cut 4 or 5 off the list, you may even find a few gems in the rookie draft this year.
I think you’re right. Shame it’ll be pushed back to 15 with Ashcroft and Lombard bids. Kako may even get bid on in the early teensIf geelong goes out in straight sets, we could get pick 13 for Smith?
I think you’re right. Shame it’ll be pushed back to 15 with Ashcroft and Lombard bids. Kako may even get bid on in the early teens
He is another on my short list. Love the way he goes about it.Phoenix Hargrave is another inside type I wouldn't mind late, looks like he has a real physical presence from what I've seen.
PHOENIX HARGRAVE (South Adelaide/Reynella East High School) Midfielder, 17, 182cm
“Phoenix is a strong inside midfielder whose contested work is very good. He also makes good decisions with ball in hand and can go forward and impact the scoreboard. Phoenix did all the pre-season training with the State under-18 talent hub and the feedback I got was that he was the most professional player with pre-training craft and that his workrate at training was very good. And at the testing day, he improved the areas that some people had concerns over, which shows how hard he has worked.’’ – South talent manager and under-18s coach Mark Clayton
Love to hear stuff like this about a kids workrate too