List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion

[Premium]

I agree with this. I have no idea if NWM wants to stay or wants to go but if his manager is giving him any advice other than sit and hold, he needs a new manager. Right now it is an auction and the longer he waits the more the teams will bid each other up.
The fact we have said we will match any bid means he doesn't need to make a decision until someone blinks. If he wants to stay or if wants to go he should wait until Port and Adelaide have made their final highest offers.

Just hope the pressure of being the highest paid player doesn't effect him if his form drops , the expectations when they are on mega bucks puts the kid under immense pressure.
If I was him I'd come up with the price he wants and get it over with.

 

[Squirtles]

I think a positive thing to consider with Nas is the lack of noise since the bye which I feel works in our favour if you compare to TDK who is likely to leave and all the articles about him leaving and Carlton preparing for life without him I’d say we are pretty good

 

[stfan]

Just hope the pressure of being the highest paid player doesn't effect him if his form drops , the expectations when they are on mega bucks puts the kid under immense pressure.
If I was him I'd come up with the price he wants and get it over with.

Well if TDK does join us, and Nas stays, Nas will be the second highest paid

 

[Sully111]

I shitcan this club more than anyone but thinking we’ve only said “we’ll match any offer” is lunacy.

We would have made a financial and contract term offer, there is not doubt about that. I would suggest we’ve also said “if you get other offers in excess tell us because we will match money and terms”.

I think we’re often poorly run but no one is dumb enough to just say “we’ll match whatever someone else give you”

That was kinda my point.

That narrative makes no sense to me at all.

 

[Mowman]

I shitcan this club more than anyone but thinking we’ve only said “we’ll match any offer” is lunacy.

We would have made a financial and contract term offer, there is not doubt about that. I would suggest we’ve also said “if you get other offers in excess tell us because we will match money and terms”.

I think we’re often poorly run but no one is dumb enough to just say “we’ll match whatever someone else give you”

Yep, but offer TDK 12 mill for 7 years

 

[Remboy]

I think a positive thing to consider with Nas is the lack of noise since the bye which I feel works in our favour if you compare to TDK who is likely to leave and all the articles about him leaving and Carlton preparing for life without him I’d say we are pretty good

I had a quick look at the Carlton-North game last week and times I thought TDK couldn’t have looked less interested. Compare that to NAS and he’s busting a gut each week.

 

[billings2paddy]

Adelaide have pick 15 right now, Port don't have a first rounder. We can demand it all we like, but if the two teams don't have those picks...

Don't see how a trade is completed with the draft capital of Adelaide and Port
Bergman ports pick 34 and a future 1st would be the most likely compensation

 

[The Punter]

Don't see how a trade is completed with the draft capital of Adelaide and Port
Bergman ports pick 34 and a future 1st would be the most likely compensation

For a 22 year old All-Australian squad (he will be in the squad this year) member with his best footy still ahead of him?

This is why it'd be a disaster for us and the league. Kind of tempting to suggest St Kilda should just re-draft him in the PSD (assuming we finish below PA) to make a point.

 

[MOLTEN GANGLANDS]

It seems you're not understanding me at all.

bigfooty in a nutshell

 

[MOLTEN GANGLANDS]

For a 22 year old All-Australian squad (he will be in the squad this year) member with his best footy still ahead of him?

This is why it'd be a disaster for us and the league. Kind of tempting to suggest St Kilda should just re-draft him in the PSD (assuming we finish below PA) to make a point.

in the squad? he's gonna be named captain coach

 

[PJays]

That guy who does the Richmond drafting videos has us taking Rory Wright at 6. Looks like Jack Steele to me. Only thing going for him is he's not running home.

This isn't your best take Gringo

Steele was BOG at least 6 or 7 times in a shortened season where we won our first final in a decade. 2* AA. Greatest Saints midfielder since the last Lyon era. If we get another Steele we would be rapt!

 

[LennyHayes77]

For a 22 year old All-Australian squad (he will be in the squad this year) member with his best footy still ahead of him?

This is why it'd be a disaster for us and the league. Kind of tempting to suggest St Kilda should just re-draft him in the PSD (assuming we finish below PA) to make a point.

Yeah I'm sure would Nas would love playing for us if we drafted him back here if he wants to go home. We'd get a terrible version of him that would once again request to be traded at the end of next season.

 

[Tasmanian saint]

It’s a awkward trade to make for a club in our position, his worth more than a second rounder but no where near were our first pick will be , fair value for him is probably 12-15 range . Only way he can realistically get to us if his part of a nwm trade, we’re we would be effectively taking him instead of a second first round pick from port

 

[phantom13]

It’s a awkward trade to make for a club in our position, his worth more than a second rounder but no where near were our first pick will be , fair value for him is probably 12-15 range . Only way he can realistically get to us if his part of a nwm trade, we’re we would be effectively taking him instead of a second first round pick from port

Who are you talking about?

 

[Mowman]

Who are you talking about?

Bergman I think

 

[heynow85]

Caro said on Agenda Setters that Saints are confident to sign NWM and theirs a meeting to take place in the next week.

TDK 90% on his way to in her view.

 

[stavro#4]

 

[Mowman]

Caro said on Agenda Setters that Saints are confident to sign NWM and theirs a meeting to take place in the next week.

TDK 90% on his way to in her view.

Crap that doesn't sound good

When was the last time Caro was right LOL

 

[stavro#4]

Crap that doesn't sound good

When was the last time Caro was right LOL

Was she not the person who broke the story on the club repaying its past players?

 

[Holy Hunter Clark]

Caro said on Agenda Setters that Saints are confident to sign NWM and theirs a meeting to take place in the next week.

TDK 90% on his way to in her view.

Mowman told me that weeks ago

 

[Ads734]

Hawks re-signed Noah Mraz to 2028

Hopefully we go after one of their other depth key defenders; Blanck, Serong, Frost even as backup

They've even got Scrimshaw playing in the 2s right now

Scrimshaw would be a great cheap get imo. I think if Naz leaves he or florent are cheapish solid HB options in the short terms.

 

[Ads734]

Mowman told me that weeks ago

Anyone have a link to this ?

 

[phantom13]

Anyone have a link to this ?

Super secret pm I believe

 

[Diehard Saint]

Caro said on Agenda Setters that Saints are confident to sign NWM and theirs a meeting to take place in the next week.

TDK 90% on his way to in her view.

Well, she said they haven’t met with his manager but he’s coming over from SA soon. If he starts talking money and contract length it’s very promising.

Tbh not sure why he’d even request a meeting if NAS was going. What would be the point?

Looks to me like while we’ve been getting ulcers and tearing our our hair out, the manager has just been sitting back and biding his time until we become more desperate as NAS just plays better and better. Holding out for the big bucks and a nice fat % for himself.

 

[Mowman]

Was she not the person who broke the story on the club repaying its past players?

Also said NAS had a problem with the crows and Walker LOL