List Mgmt. 2025 List Management II 📃

[Aphrodite]

 

[ctwenty1]

Can he do that now? Don’t we have the ability to match.

Not suggesting we would or should match but isn’t there a process to follow?

 

[SurreyBlue]

Richmond supporters seem to be enjoying themselves more than StKilda with this and other news ...... interesting.

 

[JTTheKing]

If the club loses TDK, JSOS and Charlie in one offseason you have to question what the club is actually trying to do

Because it sure as shit won’t be winning games anytime soon

 

[DirtyLeeds]

I'm for the wrecking ball approach, Crippa and Charlie traded out, dealing with Port and Sydney. Would be one of the biggest trades of all time, verging on a Navy Andrew scenario but....

Based on the Crippa go home for family reasons factor, and Charlie wants 'outa town' to surf, and throwing everything at the Butters/Reid Premiership reset

Carlton in- Reid
Butters
Dean
Ison
Sydney 2nd Round pick, used for Dean
Eagles 2nd Round pick, sent to Port

Carlton Out Crippa (Eagles, and Swans F1 '25, and Warner) would give Eagles three top ten picks
Charlie and future 1st (Swans)
TDK (Aints)
JSOS (Dogs)
TDK & JSOS Compo picks (both to Port, with McGov and the Eagles 2nd)

Based on the premise that we don't need the two big forwards, that HOK/Pitto/Reidy take the ruck, Kemp returns to Def to sort JSOS' position, that Butters and Reid combined with Walsh, Jagga, George, Cera, Lord et al is bona fide A Grade Midfield with serious Premiership credentials.

It's affordable

Dare to dream Andrew

 

[Stig O'Hara]

Does it say how much they’re paying him?

Around 22.5 cents for every dollar.

 

[YeoShuey]

With what money do St Kilda now have to pull off a deal for Silvagni?

 

[Revenant1995]

15mil. 1.875mill per season.

That sounds like win every game, BNF winner, play finals, etc type number. But he'd have to be on at least 75% that, so it's still a lot of money. Add in the NWM money, and that's a lot of money in 2 players...

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

I'm for the wrecking ball approach, Crippa and Charlie traded out, dealing with Port and Sydney. Would be one of the biggest trades of all time, verging on a Navy Andrew scenario but....

Based on the Crippa go home for family reasons factor, and Charlie wants 'outa town' to surf, and throwing everything at the Butters/Reid Premiership reset

Carlton in- Reid
Butters
Dean
Ison
Sydney 2nd Round pick, used for Dean
Eagles 2nd Round pick, sent to Port

Carlton Out Crippa (Eagles, and Swans F1 '25, and Warner) would give Eagles three top ten picks
Charlie and future 1st (Swans)
TDK (Aints)
JSOS (Dogs)
TDK & JSOS Compo picks (both to Port, with McGov and the Eagles 2nd)

Based on the premise that we don't need the two big forwards, that HOK/Pitto/Reidy take the ruck, Kemp returns to Def to sort JSOS' position, that Butters and Reid combined with Walsh, Jagga, George, Cera, Lord et al is bona fide A Grade Midfield with serious Premiership credentials.

It's affordable

Dare to dream Andrew

 

[Gointocarlton]

FC claiming Aints have got their main in TDK. Will tell Carlton on Wed.

 

[NavySteel]

If the club loses TDK, JSOS and Charlie in one offseason you have to question what the club is actually trying to do

Because it sure as shit won’t be winning games anytime soon

Disagree.

The club could be working on something big in the background. You don’t lose quality without getting quality back. JSOS and TDK free agents and compo will come. With Charlie, any potential suitor will have to pay through the nose for him - contracted until 2029 and regardless of “players generally get to go where they want to” won’t play into it unless we get handsomely compensated. Expect GW to be pretty hard-nosed about that.

 

[chickendippas]

If the club loses TDK, JSOS and Charlie in one offseason you have to question what the club is actually trying to do

Because it sure as shit won’t be winning games anytime soon

If they are traded out, would need to consider the list changes on balance.

I don’t think we would be stockpiling draft picks, especially if Charlie is traded. Can’t see it happening though.

 

[Wickzki]

Thank you Tom. All.the best.

Don't blame you for taking the money.

 

[yibbida]

8 years at $1.7 million.

Wonder how much is guaranteed before actually playing a game.

 

[dragonsblues]

St Kilda have offered above overs for every free agents for the past 5 years.

TDK the only one gullible enough to take it. See ya

 

[AndyLucimitis]

FC claiming Aints have got their main in TDK. Will tell Carlton on Wed.

Thank God - so over it. This has hung over the club all season.

Good luck to Tom - godfather offer so good for him but time for the Blues to move on.

 

[SolGoodman]

Yeah, we were never going to be able to compete with that sort of a deal, good luck, Tom.

 

[Meddy43]

Can he actually sign a deal outside of the FA window?

 

[JTTheKing]

Disagree.

The club could be working on something big in the background. You don’t lose quality without getting quality back. JSOS and TDK free agents and compo will come. With Charlie, any potential suitor will have to pay through the nose for him - contracted until 2029 and regardless of “players generally get to go where they want to” won’t play into it unless we get handsomely compensated. Expect GW to be pretty hard-nosed about that.

Yeah nah.

This isn’t a PlayStation game

Even if by some chance you manage to bring back a talent, that’s one player.

Losing Curnow in particular would be a gigantic blow to the club.

 

[Wickzki]

8 years at $1.7 million.

Wonder how much is guaranteed before actually playing a game.

If rumours from quality sources are accurate $1.5m to $1.6m per year of that so most of it.

 

[The Defender]

Sos with a trifecta, TDK, Jsos & bid on Dean

 

[SurreyBlue]

$1.875m for 8 years - Can't possibly blame Tom. This is life changing.
Won't get any success but will be setup.

 

[HavUEvaSeenTheRain]

I just want to win flags.
Don’t care who we have to trade to get there.
Surprised 100% of supporters don’t feel the same!!

Obviously they do, people just rate players and draft picks differently.
For instance I would’ve preferred a pick in the 20’s last year than Sydney’s pick ~11 this year.

 

[NavySteel]

Sos with a trifecta, TDK, Jsos & bid on Dean

Has a fascination with his own picks… Stocker, Dow, TDK, JSOS (kind of), wanted Kemp. It’s like he’s getting high off his own recruiting fumes.

 

[Sam The Doc]

Has a fascination with his own picks… Stocker, Dow, TDK, JSOS (kind of), wanted Kemp. It’s like he’s getting high off his own recruiting fumes.

Took Jack Carroll after we delisted

 

[Stig O'Hara]

Has a fascination with his own picks… Stocker, Dow, TDK, JSOS (kind of), wanted Kemp. It’s like he’s getting high off his own recruiting fumes.

Don’t forget the 27 discards he brought over to us from GWS.