List Mgmt. 2025 List Management II 📃

[Aphrodite]

 

[Blue Heart]

In other words TDK had to come up with reasons for joining on the spot that didn't start with $$$

As if ... no $1.7 Mill K a year offer and he is still with us !!!

 

[The Bighouse]

The year is 2027... We've lost Curnow, JSOS and TDK leaving a war chest of cash to spend... We trade up to nab Sullivan Robey with the picks left behind as well as matching a bid on Dean + Ison whilst also bringing in the experienced bodies of Florent and Hayward.

Zac Bailey or Zak Butters as a free agent in 2026 with all the spare cash... Would not mind the look of this team whatsoever.


Nic Newman - Jacob Weitering - Harry Dean
Ollie Florent - Harry O'Farrell - Lachie Cowan

Sam Walsh - Patrick Cripps - Campbell Chesser
Liam Reidy - Jagga Smith - Sullivan Robey

Zac Bailey - Hudson O'Keefe - Zac Williams
Ashton Moir - Harry McKay - Will Hayward

Adam Cerra - Cody Walker - Matthew Carroll - Jack Ison - Frank the Tank

Now bring in both ZB’s…please.

 

[Aphrodite]

St Kilda spin. Only reason anyone would mention the 'bayside lifestyle' is because they're trying to reinvent themselves as the South East suburbs version of Geelong.

One is totally unlike the other!





#Baysiderepresent

 

[sweethoney]

Also, I assume his dad Scott isn't a complete tosser like another father-son combo I can think of.

I think he might be.. I can’t recall him having a whinge because Rhylee wasn’t get a game a few years ago

 

[azlou]

Sounds about right but interesting that Hayward was quoted today saying he would be happy to be part of a trade. That's no coincidence.

So swap Florent for Hayward in that deal.

I also hope EH gets another chance somehow... by all reports he's already been given the boot though I think??

And I still think it's more likely Curnow remains at Carlton. Not against him leaving as his knee is looking like it's going to limit him for the rest of his career - just a matter of by how much. Took about 50% off him this year.

In regard to EH I love him skill hardness had a huge smile when he signed my 7 year olds jersey but people change small amounts over a long period.

 

[The Bighouse]

In other words TDK had to come up with reasons for joining on the spot that didn't start with $$$

The most overpaid player in the history of the game.
Don’t succumb to the pressure, Tom.

 

[ctwenty1]

I live in Bayside, ain't no way anybody is talking up the $28 avocado on toast prices for a regulation cafe in Brighton

But if you were on $1.8m a year would be ok…

 

[Blue_Fusion]

I don't see it happening. Teams will be holding on to those picks as strongly as they have in years. I also can't see Swans F1 being close to 8-12 if they have Curnow.

Well, you don't see it happening doesn't make it impossible now does it?

Essendon will need an additional 1st for Bewick, fair chance they'd want to do business... how else are they getting that additional pick?

North and Melbourne don't have a pick in the first round this year... two picks back to back in that range would be appealing...

It's far from impossible mate... just gotta be willing to make it happen, I'd even add our F2 in one of those deals to nudge it over the line...

 

[Blue_Fusion]

Melbourne would feast on that offer, and Essendon wouldn't do the other deal. Your projections are nonsense. What are the players moving in these scenarios alongside? Are we getting anyone in other than the draftees?

You're cashing out of not one, but 3 first rounds in pursuit of Dean and Walker. Go outside and get some air please.

It's not nonsense... you just need to use your brain to understand it.

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

Don’t think Rylee would leave especially if his brother Levi probably getting drafted next year I think

Probably but with Darcy expecting BF a big pay rise the $ would be getting pretty thin at the Kennell

 

[ItsAllAboutMe]

The most overpaid player in the history of the game.
Don’t succumb to the pressure, Tom.

Israel Falou says

 

[Stamos]

I think you are ignoring the problem though. It’s better for everyone if GC have to match Uwland with say pick 6 and 13 than 5 picks in the mid second round. It takes two top end picks out of the draft. It means West Coast for example have two higher quality players to pick from at pick 15 and again at 21. This is the whole reason for the changes not about the team matching bids. I think you are only looking at it from the team who has the FS or academy player, which should really be the least important player in the whole thing considering they can actually make the choice to match or not.

It’s pretty simple though. If you can’t trade down very close to the pick a bid is made at then you aren’t paying market value.

If you can’t trade down then that means another club can’t trade up.

As a system, you don’t want intervention to restrict trade, or to skew the market. It will work much better if you set the market (with DVI), and then let clubs work it out amongst themselves.

Gold Coast won’t be able to match Uwland with 5 picks in the mid second round. There won’t be enough points (or trades) for them.

 

[Andypooh23]

When we play St.Kilda next year, I want one of out players to go up to Vossy and ask him.... would you be OK with me giving away a free kick before the siren sounds?

 

[macky99]

TDK has got to sell the sunny side.

Hardly going to say "These blokes offered me stupid coin"

Doesn't make any sense how tight knit the Saints are when they just knifed the captain

On the back of TDK's comments today, Marshall has officially requested a trade to Geelong & they have pretty much told Steele to look elsewhere.

This pretty much rules out Geelong from the Curnow hunt.

 

[Blue and Silver]

On the back of TDK's comments today, Marshall has officially requested a trade to Geelong & they have pretty much told Steele to look elsewhere.

This pretty much rules out Geelong from the Curnow hunt.

Happy club it seems

 

[macky99]

Happy club it seems

Yes to be expected paying so much for one player who is not a elite player by any stretch.
Such a poor decision by SOS.

 

[HavUEvaSeenTheRain]

If you can’t trade down then that means another club can’t trade up.

As a system, you don’t want intervention to restrict trade, or to skew the market. It will work much better if you set the market (with DVI), and then let clubs work it out amongst themselves.

Gold Coast won’t be able to match Uwland with 5 picks in the mid second round. There won’t be enough points (or trades) for them.

Why do we want teams trading up? That benefits one side, it achieves absolutely nothing. It doesn’t help the worst teams get the best talent.

Skew the market? That is what they are trying to fix. Trading up so you can match with two picks is the most accurate way to determine the market.

It was a hyberpole but that’s how it works. Clubs trading down and out of the first round creates extra picks at the top end which a two pick matching system eliminates

 

[The Bighouse]

Israel Falou says

TDK aka Issy II now…or IF2

 

[NavySteel]

Listening to TDK on the afl website sounds like he’s taking a swipe at us.I suppose can’t blame him.

If he played like a $1.8m ruck we’d have offered it.

Massive pressure on him now to perform. Can see this being st kilda’s version of Tom Boyd though

 

[ITCHY EYEBALLS]

They’re both dead to me.
Wish them nothing but ill fortune for the rest of their careers

 

[choo]

If
Petracca +melb F1 >GC
Humphrey +Flanders >Melb
Florent +Syd F1 >GC
Melb F1 >Syd
Charlie>Syd
Hayward +MelbF1 >Carlton

Trade out tdk pick or package with sos pick to go higher
Cody secured with Melb F1 + cfc F1
I would love Humphrey though

 

[le dominateur]

Pick 9 and 19 for 2 ok footballers is a massive win for Carlton.

 

[No1Suspect]

What parallel universe are you living in where the AFL does anything to be fair to Carlton? After the best part of a decade in the bottom 4 our additional assistance was A) ridiculously late and B) completely inadequate.

Free agency compensation for Jarrad Waite was what? Zero. 120+ goals for North over 4 years.

We get our first top 3 father son on the horizon and immediately the AFL starts looking at scrapping the rule for 1st round for the first time ever... must be a coincidence right?

We live in a world where if we aren't getting completely reamed by the AFL we have to be grateful.

We also live in a world where our recruitment staff have a strike rate as good as Ray Charles would have playing baseball.

 

[Revenant1995]

Listening to TDK on the afl website sounds like he’s taking a swipe at us.I suppose can’t blame him.

TDK already suffering from Stockholm StuckwithRoss Syndrome...

 

[lukep_86]

When we play St.Kilda next year, I want one of out players to go up to Vossy and ask him.... would you be OK with me giving away a free kick before the siren sounds?

Voss as a player, or any of his team mates would have 110% done it. Voss as a coach letting one of our boys do it, I'm not sure but I'd like to see it