Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2025 List Management

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Rob said:
It's a bizarre one, more so given the long term deal.
Let's be honest, come grand final day is there anyone you'd have less faith in to get the job done?
Click to expand...

Tom Sheridan, Brandon Walker, Jack Anthony … we’ve had plenty worse performances.
 
ilikepotatoes said:
There's no point trading for Nic Martin - he probably plays 5 games max if any coming off an ACL.

It is weird and I'd honestly say a bit refreshing we aren't hearing strong noise of players leaving or coming to the club this offseason.

I don't count Brodie or Reidy in that as realistically if we kept them on another season they probably play max 5 games between them next season before being delisted.
Click to expand...
he did it in July, and players have been recovering quicker than 12 months. Maybe he would only play 5 games for Essendon because they won't make finals...

besides you missed the key word from my post: delusional. I can do waaay worse if you want, like the club is working on landing ZB - either one will do.

(honestly & more boringly, I agree with you. especially with the latest group of extensions. it's a good group to keep together + positive signs)
 
Wouldn’t mind a crack at Sam Butler.
He did play last week v GWS though. Maybe he’s going to be pushed ahead now that Bruest is retiring
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Four senior lists, two rookie spots, two Category B rookie spots if anyone was wondering.

I've upgraded Draper as it has to happen under AFL rules. Reckon Sharp will be upgraded as well but nothing officially stating he has been yet.

BTW this assumes Brodie and Reidy are traded.
 
Last edited:
rgauci said:
Tom Sheridan, Brandon Walker, Jack Anthony … we’ve had plenty worse performances.
Click to expand...
??

Sheridan made one noticeable howler- but we were still over 2 kicks from the lead (could argue Freddy’s goal line miss did costs us in a 1 point game)
Jack Anthony- didn’t play finals for us so moot
Walkers the only comparison and he at least had youth in his side and at the G in front of 90k pies fans

Freddys is the worst for mine as it included cat 10 errors AND most concerning plenty of squib/soft efforts- in fact a continuation from the r24 game too

Agree Freddy’s not going anywhere but fmd he’d have to have lost some serious trust amongst playing group and coaches after his last 2 games.

Not all players are brayshaw/serong for courage but even as an exclusively outside player he just HAS to go when it’s his turn .
No player should get a pass there.

Bit like with the coach now, only come finals and some big improvement in intensity and effort can Freddy redeem himself AFAIC
 
Aside from his form falling off a cliff and becoming a B26 player what did Sharp do again to get 2 years?
 
rgauci said:
Tom Sheridan, Brandon Walker, Jack Anthony … we’ve had plenty worse performances.
Click to expand...
Those 3 plus Frederick are the same level.

Just can’t trust ‘em in the big games and finals.

I do not care how well you perform on a quiet Sunday afternoon game against St. Kilda in May.

Can you do it in a big final at the MCG against Collingwood in September? And the answer for Frederick is a resounding no.
 
Great news wit the Freddy sign, was worried as hawks were all over him

Sharp signing on, good to have that confirmed

Doesn't look like we are delisting and relisting omac then



Who does that leave for next year?

Sturt likely done
So just Johnson to get signed up? Before the big one of serong the year after
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Given Freddy was already contracted for next year you'd have to assume there some salary cap thing happening too. Maybe his previous deal was back ended and it's being spread out
 
King Tenz said:
Those 3 plus Frederick are the same level.

Just can’t trust ‘em in the big games and finals.

I do not care how well you perform on a quiet Sunday afternoon game against St. Kilda in May.

Can you do it in a big final at the MCG against Collingwood in September? And the answer for Frederick is a resounding no.
Click to expand...
Sure but we need to win the games on a quiet Sunday afternoon game against St Kilda in May. Freddy was a good contributor this year and is probably the only player on our team who has kicked 20+ goals 4 years in a row.

He played a horrible, truly horrible final but you don’t make list management decisions based on one game.
 
freo_leo29 said:
Great news wit the Freddy sign, was worried as hawks were all over him

Sharp signing on, good to have that confirmed

Doesn't look like we are delisting and relisting omac then



Who does that leave for next year?

Sturt likely done
So just Johnson to get signed up? Before the big one of serong the year after
Click to expand...
Switta and Wagner the most important short-term names to tick off, Johnno, Voss and maybe NOD the most important long-term. Think someone posted something about Ryan Daniels saying Voss was almost done?
Screenshot 2025-09-11 at 12.48.53 pm.png
 
The Lobbster said:
We have absolutely no wing depth. We don’t want to rely on draftees to fill so you get a guy that you know well to hang around.
Click to expand...

So nothing of his own doing then. Good for him, he must be over the moon.
 
Deathly said:
Aside from his form falling off a cliff and becoming a B26 player what did Sharp do again to get 2 years?
Click to expand...

He was hampered this year by a lower leg injury, remains an important member of the team, few have his endurance and long (often inaccurate) kick. If he can kick to leads, was working on that in the WAFL, he’ll be a long term player for us. If both JOM and Sharp were out of contract? Which would you prefer getting 2 years.
 
Last edited:

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

King Tenz said:
Those 3 plus Frederick are the same level.

Just can’t trust ‘em in the big games and finals.

I do not care how well you perform on a quiet Sunday afternoon game against St. Kilda in May.

Can you do it in a big final at the MCG against Collingwood in September? And the answer for Frederick is a resounding no.
Click to expand...
Did so in 2022. Half the team was overawed.

The pressure should be on OMeara, who at his age, was probably the worst on ground given how ineffective his time on ground and useless his disposal was. Same to NOD. Amiss was poor and has been underwhelming all year.
 
The Lobbster said:
Sure but we need to win the games on a quiet Sunday afternoon game against St Kilda in May. Freddy was a good contributor this year and is probably the only player on our team who has kicked 20+ goals 4 years in a row.
Click to expand...
True. But I think we could find a hundred other guys who can perform just as well on a casual Sunday against St. Kilda.

Finals is what matters and he broke my trust in him.

He’s just not that guy, time to move on from him.
 
King Tenz said:
True. But I think we could find a hundred other guys who can perform just as well on a casual Sunday against St. Kilda.

Finals is what matters and he broke my trust in him.

He’s just not that guy, time to move on from him.
Click to expand...
Same goes for JOM, NOD, Amiss, Worner. All had moments.
Like I said, let’s make finals consistently. Make top 4. Get double chances, and build the culture. See where these players belong.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top