goodolcollingwood
Draftee
- Dec 14, 2025
- 13
- 2
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Those two states are over half the population of the entire country. Like it or not Rugby League is just as important to the fabric of this country as footy is.Not really. AFL is popular throughout the country and is Australia's iconic indigenous game.
Rugby is popular in only two states but the British banned Australian Football a long time ago.
Australian football is rightfully regaining that ground.
The AFL is doing really well expanding into NSW/QLD. With participation and crowds, its doing better than what the NRL is doing into AFL states (although the NRL is also expanding into other areas such as NZ, PNG, and the Pacific).Only for fans of NRL.
The progress expansion of AFL depends solely on the AFL.
Now that the media cannot hide the popularity of AFL, AFL is going great guns.
My point was some people can't help but compare the expansion teams with what the NRL is doing instead of just focusing on its own race. For a lot of people it's bragging rights. For example there are discussions such as 'AFL taking over Queensland' on this very site.
I also think putting all their energy into the international game and neglecting the domestic game hurt them as well. A successful domestic competition is key which is why the AFL and NRL are doing so well.RU tried to expand too quickly AND it chose money over FTA. Big lesson there.
It's no secret the sport was badly damaged from the Super League war. We are still seeing the damage today with Balmain and Western Suburbs still having a go at each other.NRL fans keep reminding everybody how "super league killed us" and now they want to try it again.
Not sure what you're getting the want to try it again though? If you're referring to R360, that's a Rugby Union competition.
Absolutely agree. People like different things. With sports a lot of it is what you grow up with. The issue both Rugby Union and Soccer have is they don't have a strong domestic competition.There are reasons why people follow different sports just like people buy different cars because
because some sports offer more than other sports just like some cars are better than other cars.
Ever since the end of WWII people have been saying soccer will overtake Australian Football, not any other sport, and soccer id no closer to achieving that.
The NRL is failing against soccer? Can i ask how? From what I've seen Rugby League dominates in NSW and QLD. If you mean participation, then isnt soccer ahead of footy as well?The NRL is fixated with the AFL, but soccer is strongest in the strongest NRL state.
NRL is failing against soccer because it is fixated on the AFL.
They are run in opposite seasons. Both the AFL and NRL have nothing to fear from them.Meanwhile the NFL is becoming very popular in Australia. The NRL should keep an eye on that.
I grew up on footy but I'm beginning to enjoy the odd game of NRL. I thought the grand final this year was amazing. I don't think people should let what people say dictate what sports you want to watch.As I said before, RU is failing badly now and who is major recipient of that - not the NRL
You cannot expect RU or AFL people to indulge NRL after so many fans said they "hate" those codes.






Total (VIC+WA+SA+TAS): ~12.400m (~45.6% of Australia’s population)