I’ve said this before, but Cumberland has had two good game at VFL level only.I'd take Cumberland over Ralphsmith from what I've seen, sounds a tad arrogant, that I know more than the entire Richmond selectors!! but there is something about his speed, agility and aggression that is pretty unique. Ralphsmith has the speed and athleticism, but not sure about the footy nous yet.
He looked well out of his depth before that, and the speed of the VFL game caught him out more often than not.
Ralphsmith has shown more flashes at AFL level than Cumberland has at VFL level. Let’s not get carried away.