Remove this Banner Ad

Player Watch #44 Seth Campbell

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Rolled up to a few stoppages today and showed another string to his bow.

Honestly could be a Smokey to poll very well in the JD Medal
IMG_4007.png

secret smell GIF
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Just on a side note

I remember in 2022 when we had no 1st round pick after trading for TT & Hopps
I was speaking with a friend of mine a Carlton supporter on draft night and he was saying Richmond have no 1st round draft picks and i said doesn't matter we got Seth Campbell who will be better than most of the 1st rounders selected

Not far wrong as he would easily be in the top 10 if the draft was redone
 

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Is that different to the official Player ratings? 🤔

Any system that has seth campbell top 20 in the league probably isn't worth paying much attention to.

CD ratings are the official player ratings.

I didn't see the Lewis statement but was surely saying Campbell is one of the top 20 rated forwards in the comp this season. He is the 12th highest rated forward and the 6th highest rated general forward(excluding mid-forwards and key forwards.)

Very impressive stuff for a 20yo rookie pick.
 
CD ratings are the official player ratings.

I didn't see the Lewis statement but was surely saying Campbell is one of the top 20 rated forwards in the comp this season. He is the 12th highest rated forward and the 6th highest rated general forward(excluding mid-forwards and key forwards.)

Very impressive stuff for a 20yo rookie pick.
I saw it before. He said top 20 player but clearly had NFI
 
CD ratings are the official player ratings.

I didn't see the Lewis statement but was surely saying Campbell is one of the top 20 rated forwards in the comp this season. He is the 12th highest rated forward and the 6th highest rated general forward(excluding mid-forwards and key forwards.)

Very impressive stuff for a 20yo rookie pick.
Do player ratings currently include data from previous years?

Think this was purely 2025 he was 19th overall
 
Do player ratings currently include data from previous years?

Think this was purely 2025 he was 19th overall

The only way Seth might be 19th overall that I can see is what CD calls their 100 rating. This is your rating compared to the expected rating per position. Number 1 is the guy who is rated furthest ahead of expected rating for his position, number 2 is the second furthest ahead of expected rating per position and so on. We are not privy to these ratings bar when Hoyney reports on them.

I can't get Seth 19th in the AFL by any search I can think of, ie restricting the search to just forwards, or just young players in a certain age range. It would be interesting to know what Lewis actually meant.
 
Last edited:

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom