Vs essendon he was fine and i backed him in bit he was bad last night. Especially disappointing is the fact that ldu is playing vfl
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
He gets pushed out of the way too easily, isn't strong enough to lay a tackle that would actually stop someone and his ball use is just OK. Doesn't suit our style of play at all IMO. Perhaps some teams could afford to carry a player of his type, but I don't think we can.I thought he was alright the last two weeks. Some nice delivery inside forward 50. Almost Wells or Harvey like, actually.
Haven't checked the stats, maybe he didn't get enough of the pill, is that why people are complaining?
Wasnt really poor recruiting imo. Litterally cost us nothing. Has a fair crack but just really hasnt came on much. Was well worth a look. He is a poor mans daniel/lonie. Reasonable depth player. I doubt hes on the kings ransom either.The question is who do you take out of the midfield to give him a go?
Of our current midfielders, who do you think he would be better than?
We have players in Ahern and LDU who also are potential midfielders.
I just can see where he is in the pecking order.
Unfortunately for him, he isn’t equipped to be a small forward and he isn’t high on the list for midfield minutes.
Poor recruitment and poor player management.
LOL. You backed him in after one "ok" game in 2 years? How do you go on the punt?Vs essendon he was fine and i backed him in bit he was bad last night. Especially disappointing is the fact that ldu is playing vfl
I hate this "cost us nothing" argument. I'd play for NM for free but that doesn't mean it's a good idea to have me on our list. He's too slow for a guy his size. We moved Boomer Harvey on and gave Hrovat a spot. Who would've provided better value???Wasnt really poor recruiting imo. Litterally cost us nothing. Has a fair crack but just really hasnt came on much. Was well worth a look. He is a poor mans daniel/lonie. Reasonable depth player. I doubt hes on the kings ransom either.
Wasn't backing him in to stay on the list but after that game he deserved to keep his spot. This week however noLOL. You backed him in after one "ok" game in 2 years? How do you go on the punt?
i would say the rat last weekend as boomer is 41 now, and its not like there are a plethoura of talented players available to just pluck out of the air. you have to pad the list with someone. until we recruit better players to oust him from the list he is a reasonable depth player.I hate this "cost us nothing" argument. I'd play for NM for free but that doesn't mean it's a good idea to have me on our list. He's too slow for a guy his size. We moved Boomer Harvey on and gave Hrovat a spot. Who would've provided better value???
Agree. Also think it is important for Shaw to demonstrate VFL form counts, and AFL form is temporary. Standards should be set.Weight of numbers is too compelling. Deserves a final lunge to save his North Melbourne list spot - in the senior midfield.
Yeah, probably will be. I think his papers are stamped. But if Shaw hasn't stamped them yet, he plays this week.He’s got to be delisted
Probably. But he also serves a purpose in the meantime. Part of the overall picture of how Scamper's match committee is going to operate. Are they going to reward form and uphold standards?He’s got to be delisted
Ok who does he replace?
Garner, Atley or Simpkin.
Garner, Atley or Simpkin.