a one man team?

[pies75]

After tonights performance, are newcastle a one man team? Or am I just asking the year's stupidest question ?

 

[Lidge]

The tossers on Fox Sports will gloss over Melbourne's win, and claim we beat a depleted Newcastle side.

But IMHO - Slater & Hill missing, is a bigger hole in your side than Johns (other than him, they were full strength)

But to answer your question, yes.

 

[Showbag]

Storm have been a bit better this year. The way they played, I would have been surprised if they lost to Knights with Joey in.

 

[YOTC]

Years stupidest questions. Of course it's yes.

Weren't they like 0-14 last year without Johns?

 

[Aucklander]

Newcastle were so bad, not even Johns would have saved them.

 

[Cleavy]

At least without Johns, they would be able to beat Souths. Time to send Souths back to exile or Jersey Flegg or whatever it is called.

 

[Sladest]

The tossers on Fox Sports will gloss over Melbourne's win, and claim we beat a depleted Newcastle side.

But IMHO - Slater & Hill missing, is a bigger hole in your side than Johns (other than him, they were full strength)

But to answer your question, yes.

To claim Slater and Hill mean more to their team than what Johns is to his, seriously, is about as deluded a comment as I have ever seen.

If anything, the Storm are better without Hill and Slater in the team.

 

[Lidge]

To claim Slater and Hill mean more to their team than what Johns is to his, seriously, is about as deluded a comment as I have ever seen.

If anything, the Storm are better without Hill and Slater in the team.

Admit that didn't read too well (after a gut full of bourbon). More of a slight on Newcastle that they can't play without Johns.

 

[Ed_Gein]

Newcastle are nothing without Johns. A totally different outfit with, or without him in the squad either side of the ledger. He is a good player, but it really does stuff me about how he can mean so much to them between getting smashed or having a solid win.

 

[bushranger]

losing hill for a few weeks is a gain

Slater is a big loss

anyway if the Great Overated like hell andrew johns played we would have won by 30 at least

Newcastle have no belief with out him. they just gotta train without him and forget they have him then the will win and finish in top 8

 

[Aucklander]

The Warriors are slowly coming to term with life without Jones, so I just can't understand why the Knights are so weak when he doesn't play.

They've had plenty of time and opportunities to adjust.