Recommitted Adam Tomlinson

[SABlue]

Are we getting pick 8 back?

I would think the pick 8 is more important to us than Tomlinson. Pick 20 or 21 should do it.

 

[coniglio_number1]

I would think the pick 8 is more important to us than Tomlinson. Pick 20 or 21 should do it.

Nah

 

[pinot]

I would think the pick 8 is more important to us than Tomlinson. Pick 20 or 21 should do it.

That wont get done.

Pick 20 this year and early third round pick 2016 (pick 37-38 - 450 points) should do it. That's 1350 points equivalent to pick 11.

 

[BM123]

Nah

Reckon we may on-trade Richmond's first if they fold and pick 20 for Tomlinson.

 

[SABlue]

Reckon we may on-trade Richmond's first if they fold and pick 20 for Tomlinson.

Way to much. We are not trying to get McCarthy. Tomlinson is a good player but has no outstanding qualities to make him worth that much. To me he is a lead up forward, not a massive goal kicker but a real work horse. He hasn't held his draft value but only slipped a bit making him worth a pick 20ish. Let's not get carried away.

 

[pinot]

Gillo came up with a good one and think it will come really close unless SOS remains stubborn on pick 12 or 2016 first rounder as he should.

Tomlinson to Carlton
Yarran to Richmond
GWS Pick 19 + pick 20

 

[Madness101]

Wait so you guys would be willing to lose pick 20 and Yarran for Tomlinson but not accept pick 19 for a straight swap for Yarran ? That doesn't make sense, richmond lose the same ( Pick 19) but you guys pay more..? I must be reading your post wrong.

 

[pinot]

Wait so you guys would be willing to lose pick 20 and Yarran for Tomlinson but not accept pick 19 for a straight swap for Yarran ? That doesn't make sense, richmond lose the same ( Pick 19) but you guys pay more..? I must be reading your post wrong.

Tomlinson would be far more valuable to us than pick 19.

Pick 12 is more valuable to you than Yarran

Pick 19+ pick 20 is more valuable to GWS than Tomlinson with academy kid picks.

It can work.

 

[rusman]

Carlton stop taking all GWS bargain players, leave some for the rest of us

 

[El Topo]

Wait so you guys would be willing to lose pick 20 and Yarran for Tomlinson but not accept pick 19 for a straight swap for Yarran ? That doesn't make sense, richmond lose the same ( Pick 19) but you guys pay more..? I must be reading your post wrong.

There's a line of thought that the Yarran deal is only dragging out because SOS needs something from Richmond to satisfy GWS. Doesn't matter what it is, as long at it ends up as Tomlinson.

 

[FyfeToAdelaide]

Carlton stop taking all GWS bargain players, leave some for the rest of us

They're just getting them ready for us.

 

[james Dean]

They're just getting them ready for us.

We have a juicy young key position player who is ready to explode.. You know we wouldn't screw you guys over



his name is Liam Jones

 

[iGNITER]

Apparently Bombers asking the question

 

[daffo]

I would LOVE him at Essendon but I don't know what we could give to get the deal done. 24 + 25 isn't enough.

 

[Carlo]

I would LOVE him at Essendon but I don't know what we could give to get the deal done. 24 + 25 isn't enough.

He's not worth 2 2nd rounders IMO.

 

[eth-dog]

He's not worth 2 2nd rounders IMO.

Disagree.

I'd give up our first next year. I rate him that highly.

 

[Carlo]

Disagree.

I'd give up our first next year. I rate him that highly.

53 games for 17 goals.

 

[eth-dog]

53 games for 17 goals.

Played about 30 of those games in defence and 7-8 on a wing.

 

[Carlo]

Played about 30 of those games in defence and 7-8 on a wing.

Really, I always seem to watch him forward.

1st next year you reckon, Hmm even if that pick ended up being Pick 5-7

 

[eth-dog]

Really, I always seem to watch him forward.

1st next year you reckon, Hmm even if that pick ended up being Pick 5-7

He's regularly played in defence. 1st next year without hesitation, have confidence with an easier fixture and a better game plan that we'll be on the cusp of the 8 at least, possibly inside it.

 

[Bulldogs_6]

Really, I always seem to watch him forward.

1st next year you reckon, Hmm even if that pick ended up being Pick 5-7

Probably be pick 1-3 I would imagine.

 

[Colonial]

Am not liking this. Hurry up clock.

 

[Ichabod Noodle]

Played about 30 of those games in defence and 7-8 on a wing.

Other way around. Most have been the linking role on the outer wing. Also does the 2nd ruck-chop out as well.

Very versatile, very handy, and not going anywhere.

 

[grimlock]

He just followed the Carlton Twitter account!

 

[Carlo]

Probably be pick 1-3 I would imagine.

Wanna bet?