Preview AFL 2018 - 1st Elimination Final - Melbourne v Geelong, Friday, 7.50pm, MCG

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Jul 2, 2010
38,061
36,328
Adelaide
AFL Club
Carlton
Match Information
Preview

The MCG will be buzzing for Melbourne's first final in 12 years, with the Demons going into September in strong form after consecutive wins over fellow finals combatants West Coast (17 points) and Greater Western Sydney (45 points). Geelong has had a more cushy run into finals with back-to-back hammerings of Fremantle (133 points) and Gold Coast (102 points), giving the Cats important momentum going into their third consecutive finals campaign. If their home and away season battles are any guide, you can expect another close tussle between the two oldest sides in the competition in a do-or-die elimination final on Friday night.

WHAT HAPPENED THIS YEAR?

Round one: Geelong 14.13 (97) d Melbourne 13.16 (94)

A Patrick Dangerfield-less Cats side led by 27 points at half-time, only to see Melbourne come charging back into the contest with a four goals to one third term. Demons ruckman Max Gawn had the chance to claim victory with a shot in the dying stages of the game but his kick missed to the left.

Round 18: Geelong 16.4 (100) d Melbourne 14.14 (98)

Geelong cut into a 23-point three-quarter time deficit with an inspired final term from forward Tom Hawkins, who kicked four of his seven goals in the last quarter. Melbourne was denied victory by Zach Tuohy, who kicked a clutch set-shot after the siren to deliver the Cats a pulsating win.

LAST FIVE TIMES
  • R18, 2018, Geelong 16.4 (100) d Melbourne 14.14 (98) at GMHBA Stadium
  • R1, 2018, Geelong 14.13 (97) d Melbourne 13.16 (94) at the MCG
  • R3, 2017, Geelong 20.6 (126) d Melbourne 13.19 (97) at Etihad Stadium
  • R23, 2016, Geelong 24.11 (155) d Melbourne 6.8 (44) at GMHBA Stadium
  • R12, 2015, Melbourne 18.5 (113) d Geelong Cats 13.11 (89) at GMHBA Stadium
 
While I’d love to see it hit 90k, I just can’t see it happening. But if it did, would be amazing considering we will have a majority of the fans more likely. If it hits 90k, I reckon 60-30 our way. Considering the MCC holds around 22,000 seats, you’d think around 21,000 would at least be Melbourne.

Can’t ******* wait!
 
While I’d love to see it hit 90k, I just can’t see it happening. But if it did, would be amazing considering we will have a majority of the fans more likely. If it hits 90k, I reckon 60-30 our way. Considering the MCC holds around 22,000 seats, you’d think around 21,000 would at least be Melbourne.

Can’t ******* wait!

MCG usually very accurate with crowd predictions. If the weather holds up and the MCC fills up, no reason why 90k won’t be achieved.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

While I’d love to see it hit 90k, I just can’t see it happening. But if it did, would be amazing considering we will have a majority of the fans more likely. If it hits 90k, I reckon 60-30 our way. Considering the MCC holds around 22,000 seats, you’d think around 21,000 would at least be Melbourne.

Can’t ******* wait!
Friday night in Melbourne, of course the Demons will have the majority of fans. I know plenty who can't travel up the freeway to watch the Cats play because of the time.
 
While I’d love to see it hit 90k, I just can’t see it happening. But if it did, would be amazing considering we will have a majority of the fans more likely. If it hits 90k, I reckon 60-30 our way. Considering the MCC holds around 22,000 seats, you’d think around 21,000 would at least be Melbourne.

Can’t ******* wait!
Gil said on On The Couch there are only 1000 tickets left
 
Dunno if the Cat's easy two last rounds necessarily give the right kind of momentum to be going into finals. Not that there's anything wrong with it, as long as the Cats are prepared for a tough contest.
 
Friday night in Melbourne, of course the Demons will have the majority of fans. I know plenty who can't travel up the freeway to watch the Cats play because of the time.

Should have finished higher so you could host it then.
 
Obviously lots of discussion re this already, but it really comes down to Melbourne being able to capitalise on their inside 50 count and continuing the dominant form around stoppages. We’ve got a great spread of goal kickers and midfield / half forward types, we now need to really carry on that end of season form.

The midfield battle will be huge. Dangerfield, Selwood, Menegola, Duncan and Ablett on any given day can prove to be match winning, so it’ll take a massive from our midfield to counter that and also exert their influence.

Our defence gets the ultimate test with Hawkins having a pretty intimidating record against us. I think Frost plays a big part this week, a guy who was dropped earlier in the year for poor disposal and decision making, but who now has worked his way into good form using his natural instincts as a player. If he and Oscar McDonald can contain Hawkins then we go a long way to winning.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

What gives you confidence?
Two victories over the Dees so far this year. Quality players throughout the Geelong team. Melbourne untested in finals.
 
Fair points. Tend to agree to be frank but hoping we can overcome that somehow.
The two wins were by less than a kick and we have quality too...
 
Two victories over the Dees so far this year. Quality players throughout the Geelong team. Melbourne untested in finals.
I would argue that Melbourne have a more even spread of quality players.

The argument that Melbourne will be exposed because of a lack of finals has no credibility considering the Dogs and Richmond have won the last two flags.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top