Remove this Banner Ad

AFL top 20 phantom draft

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Is it wrong if I want to have a go at Twomey on Twitter because Dunstan & Sheed are too low, McCarthy & Acres are too high, and Kennedy-Harris shouldn't be picked until at least the third round?
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Is it wrong if I want to have a go at Twomey on Twitter because Dunstan & Sheed are too low, McCarthy & Acres are too high, and Kennedy-Harris shouldn't be picked until at least the third round?
I thought that to ^
I believe I read that he has already said to someone that it is just his personal top 20 and it will change closer to the draft/
 
I love people having a go at these lists.

Conca went with pick 6 and Heppell dropped a heap...

Darling went in the second round...

Grundy did not go top 5....

There are plenty of examples of the draft falling different to BF hype.
All true. And guess what, in hindsight Darling should have gone much earlier, Grundy should have gone earlier, and Heppell should have gone ahead of Conca.
 
F
All true. And guess what, in hindsight Darling should have gone much earlier, Grundy should have gone earlier, and Heppell should have gone ahead of Conca.

Do you want me to give you examples of BF hype players that should not and did not go high?

There are some amazing BF hyped players.
 
F

Do you want me to give you examples of BF hype players that should not and did not go high?

There are some amazing BF hyped players.
Yes, I know there are plenty. But I think my personal favourite was Tyler Chalwell who was talked up as being the next best key position player that anyone had ever seen, despite achieving around 3/5ths of stuff all here in WA.
 
Yes, I know there are plenty. But I think my personal favourite was Tyler Chalwell who was talked up as being the next best key position player that anyone had ever seen, despite achieving around 3/5ths of stuff all here in WA.
Gourdis? Sp

Is still my favourite, top 5 pick from memory.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Is it wrong if I want to have a go at Twomey on Twitter because Dunstan & Sheed are too low, McCarthy & Acres are too high, and Kennedy-Harris shouldn't be picked until at least the third round?
Dunstan and Sheed are too low, but I disagree on Acres and Kennedy-Harris. Acres has lots of talent and before his shoulder injury he had to be considered a top 20 pick. Kennedy-Harris has heaps of X-Factor and he has to be super unlucky to miss out on the U18 side. He should be a second round pick, possibly in the first round if he gets back to the form he had in the TAC Cup at the start of the year.
 
My favourite was Manson. Top 10 pick and most talented player the game has ever seen apparently.


Admittedly already had the question marks there. Matthew Panos was one that I chuckle at, as well as Dylan McNeill (went early 20's in every phantom iirc)
 
Would've thought that Matt Crouch is another example of going much later than he should.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom