All in brawl

[Casey]

do u think that any of the bombrs will be rubbed out as a result of the round 11 brawl. Mark Johnson will be rubbed out for striking i think. lets hope no though, we've got Brisbane next week.

 

[Bartholin Juice]

Murphy for his headbutt was the only one I saw for our players...

I've heard that McPhee, Welsh, and MJ will get looked at but I didn't see anything.

Shame on you Hawthorn.

 

[dannyboy]

Ive watched it twice now....murph is gone for headbutting....Mark Johnson might be in some trouble too....had a decent swing at one of the hawk players when they were both on the ground....didnt really connect well tho, so that may favour him.

 

[Casey]

Originally posted by dannyboy
....murph is gone for headbutting....

i saw the so called headbutt several times from a few different angles and i have drawn the conclusion that there was not that much in it

youve gotta admire James Hird though... when the hawthorn ****tas started on him he meerly grabbed onto one of their legs.

 

[tomatoes]

Originally posted by Casey
i saw the so called headbutt several times from a few different angles and i have drawn the conclusion that there was not that much in it

looked like he was just chesting up almost, or shoulder. who represented licuria?

 

[pfinn]

Originally posted by dannyboy
Ive watched it twice now....murph is gone for headbutting....Mark Johnson might be in some trouble too....had a decent swing at one of the hawk players when they were both on the ground....didnt really connect well tho, so that may favour him.

Are you sure it was MJ? i thought it was mcphee at first, but i think it was winderlich.

 

[Bomaz_Magic]

If Murph and MJ get rubbed out it just shows how much the AFL has it in for us. Murph chested up to Beaumont, whilst MJ changed his mind about taking a swing (deciding to push instead) unlike a certain R. Vandenberg. If someone from Essendon gets rubbed out, have no doubt it has something to do with us playing the AFL's former lovechild, Brisbane. BTW how many weeks do you think Vandenberg will receive, 8.

 

[waspy]

I doubt Vandy will get more than 2 because it was part of the melee, but the AFL has been unbelievably inconsistent this year at the tribunal so its anyones guess. Could really be anything between 0 and 6.

 

[matts_girl]

Originally posted by waspy
I doubt Vandy will get more than 2

I think he'll get 6-8.

 

[Darealrath]

Didn't see Murph's 'headbutt' but he took a swing and connected, very light on though, and his fist wasn't clenched. I think he'll get a week though.

 

[M29]

We've tried what they did a few times in the past (well not to that extent!) and it's backfired.

Good to see that we concentrated on the footy after that and hammered through 7 straight.

 

[BomberGal]

Saw the McPhee incident again last night - what else was he supposed to do?

The Murphy 'headbutt' looks pretty soft, too, but I only saw it from one angle. It may look very different from another angle or in slow motion (which I'm guessing will be the case). Don't think I saw the MJ one?

Brown will have a nice little holiday anyway. Prick.