All Time richmond side

[NQTIGER]

This is a bit different, name you all time best side from players you have seen

B K Sheedy F Swift R Dean
HB M Keane R McGhie J Bowden
C F Bourke B Barrot D Clay
HF J Northey R Hart B Richardson
FF D Weightman M Roach M Richardson
R M Green B Deledio K Bartlett

I/C M Rioli G Raines B Wood M Lee

apologies to plenty

 

[cardtrader]

Might slip Wiley or Monteith in before Northey.

Would have to go the extended bench and add Knights, Campbell, B Gale.

 

[nugget_12]

Jack Dyer is turning in his grave! how can you leave the great man out!

 

[tugga]

Jack Dyer is turning in his grave! how can you leave the great man out!

Maybe he is not that old to have seen him play.

 

[NQTIGER]

Maybe he is not that old to have seen him play.

I know im an old fart but not that old.......

 

[guruisatiger]

backs--- bulluss---manton---palme

halfbacks- daffy---- laffy--- chaffey

centers--- b.bower--- underwood--s,ryan

half4wds---powell---francis---menagola

foewrds--- hernaman---jurica--dundas

rucks---- lounder---banik---gilmour

inter--- odwyer-- oakley-nicholls--alister scott--danny meyer

 

[Tzatziki_Man]

NQ, great list, obviously you purposly didn't place guys you have never seen play in the yellow and black because Titus & Dyer would both be rolling in their graves.

I'll try and create a list based on past, present and future? What I hope after our next batch of success, our all time side would look like.

Coach: Damien Hardwick *after coaching us to five premiership wins, one by one against Collingwood & Carlton*.


B: K.Sheedy, V.Thorp, M.Green
HB: I.Stewart, M. Keane, J.Bowden
C: F.Bourke, T.Cotchin, B.Barrot
HF: M.Richardson, R.Hart, K.Bartlett
FF: M. Roach, J.Riewoldt, J.Titus
Foll: M.Lee, J.Dyer, D.Martin

I/C: M.Knights, M.Rioli, D.Clay, D.Weightman

EMG: B.Gale, W.Campbell, C.Newman

Waterboys: J.McMahon, J.Plapp, P.Hudson and his awesome game...

 

[Tzatziki_Man]

backs--- bulluss---manton---palme

halfbacks- daffy---- laffy--- chaffey

centers--- b.bower--- underwood--s,ryan

half4wds---powell---francis---menagola

foewrds--- hernaman---jurica--dundas

rucks---- lounder---banik---gilmour

inter--- odwyer-- oakley-nicholls--alister scott--danny meyer

We had a player named laffy Imagine Daffy, Laffy & Chaffy all in the same team...

BTW: I LOVED the duck, daffy was awesome at his best.

 

[NQTIGER]

CNB i did say only from players i have seen, and as much as i liked matty knights , barrot won a couple of flags for us, and i reckon if we can keep him for life lids will be one of our all time greats.

I also missed seeing banik and a couple of others as i was in the jungle for a few years otherwise him and richard lounder may have got a gig.

 

[NQTIGER]

backs--- bulluss---manton---palme

halfbacks- daffy---- laffy--- chaffey

centers--- b.bower--- underwood--s,ryan

half4wds---powell---francis---menagola

foewrds--- hernaman---jurica--dundas

rucks---- lounder---banik---gilmour

inter--- odwyer-- oakley-nicholls--alister scott--danny meyer

You missed Dan Foley

 

[guruisatiger]

proper team of all time based on what i have seen

backs ----d,kellaway--j,hogg,,d,gaspar

halfbaks---m,keane-- j,jess---f,bourke

midfiels--- b,wood---p,broderick---w,campbell

half4wds---m,richardson--r,heart--m,rioli

forwards--n,brown--- m,roach----d,weightman

rucks--- m,lee -----m,knights---k,bartlett

inter from-- b,gale--g,raines--j,bowden--a,kellaway--r,wiley--c,naish-

 

[NQTIGER]

backs--- bulluss---manton---palme

halfbacks- daffy---- laffy--- chaffey

centers--- b.bower--- underwood--s,ryan

half4wds---powell---francis---menagola

foewrds--- hernaman---jurica--dundas

rucks---- lounder---banik---gilmour

inter--- odwyer-- oakley-nicholls--alister scott--danny meyer

Is that David Palm?, I have a funny story when he came to the tigers ny mates said we were twins, anyway one nite down Frankston way i had gone to the pub and got lucky because the young lady thought i was david Palm........i didnt tell her till after the event of course......

 

[1980GFVideo]

This is a bit different, name you all time best side from players you have seen

B K Sheedy F Swift R Dean
HB M Keane R McGhie J Bowden
C F Bourke B Barrot D Clay
HF J Northey R Hart B Richardson
FF D Weightman M Roach M Richardson
R M Green B Deledio K Bartlett

I/C M Rioli G Raines B Wood M Lee

apologies to plenty

Taylor and Roach never worked. How are we going to make Richardson and Roach work.

Roycey might get up Richos gander a bit as he never passed. Always took a shot. As Rex Hunt said, Royce wouldnt die wondering if the goals were anywhere in sight.

I know we need some current representation but Wiley over Deledio for me.

Never saw enough of those boys in the seventies to claim I saw them. Only remember thier last years.

 

[guruisatiger]

You missed Dan Foley

was trying to think of the young guy no28 played under geischen was alittle forward cant remember his name though dan foley was a legend was also going to put in alister smith and bomber james loved watching the u-19s and ressies when they were playing

 

[NQTIGER]

Taylor and Roach never worked. How are we going to make Richardson and Roach work.

Roycey might get up Richos gander a bit as he never passed. Always took a shot. As Rex Hunt said, Royce wouldnt die wondering if the goals were anywhere in sight.

I know we need some current representation but Wiley over Deledio for me.

Never saw enough of those boys in the seventies to claim I saw them. Only remember thier last years.

Could have named a second team from the players i left out, as i said apologies to many.

 

[NQTIGER]

was trying to think of the young guy no28 played under geischen was alittle forward cant remember his name though dan foley was a legend was also going to put in alister smith and bomber james loved watching the u-19s and ressies when they were playing

Ben Moore?

 

[guruisatiger]

Ben Moore?

yeah thanks nq thats him

 

[NQTIGER]

Didnt get to see many u19 games as we used to get to the ground for the reserves, REmember that kid lane in the U19 who had teasdale and roach in front of him, IIRC he kicked 150 or something, and of course there was jacko as well

 

[THE THIN MAN]

How can you leave out Jim Jess?

The Ghost Who Walks was a legend has to be picked.

 

[NQTIGER]

How can you leave out Jim Jess?

The Ghost Who Walks was a legend has to be picked.

I know it was bloody hard, he was my Video supplier in California Gully

 

[Wallaby]

NQ, great list, obviously you purposly didn't place guys you have never seen play in the yellow and black because Titus & Dyer would both be rolling in their graves.

I'll try and create a list based on past, present and future? What I hope after our next batch of success, our all time side would look like.

Coach: Damien Hardwick *after coaching us to five premiership wins, one by one against Collingwood & Carlton*.


B: K.Sheedy, V.Thorp, M.Green
HB: I.Stewart, M. Keane, J.Bowden
C: F.Bourke, T.Cotchin, B.Barrot
HF: M.Richardson, R.Hart, K.Bartlett
FF: M. Roach, J.Riewoldt, J.Titus
Foll: M.Lee, J.Dyer, D.Martin

I/C: M.Knights, M.Rioli, D.Clay, D.Weightman

EMG: B.Gale, W.Campbell, C.Newman

Waterboys: J.McMahon, J.Plapp, P.Hudson and his awesome game...

You don't think that Roy Wright (2 brownlows) might not get the ruck nod over The General? And maybe Bill Morris over Benny Gale?

Or Ron Branton (3 consecutive B&Fs) over J Bowden (both played in eras when we were crap).

And if Martin turns out to be good enough to displace KB from first rover, I will be very pleased.

Just my 2c...

 

[rfctigerarmy]

B: D. Kellaway, S. Turner, A. Kellaway
HB: B. Deledio, J. Bowden, C. Newman
C: T. Free, M. Knights, N. Foley
HF: C. Naish, M. Richardson, N. Daffy
F: N. Brown, J. Riewoldt, M. Rogers
R: B. Gale, W. Campbell, P. Broderick

INT: T. Cotchin, K. Johnson, M. Coughlan, B. Ottens

The forward line was especially hard.