Amon the great

[big_bazza]

do all you other swannies rate Amon Buchanan as highly as i do... hes definitley in our top 5 players he can be so damaging in the midfield and is a little terrier in and under the packs! what a gun amon keep up the good work

get on him for brownlow at $1001

 

[Jeffers]

AMEN
AMON

Bucky is top shelf, just needs one more season like last year then we'll be shouting out elite.

 

[CharlieG]

Top five?

Which six of Hall, Davis, O'Keefe, C Bolton, Kennelly, O'Loughlin, Barry, J Bolton, Kirk and Goodes do you rate Buchanan ahead of?

 

[dougk]

Top five?

Which six of Hall, Davis, O'Keefe, C Bolton, Kennelly, O'Loughlin, Barry, J Bolton, Kirk and Goodes do you rate Buchanan ahead of?

I would rate him better than Davis and O'Loughlin mainly because Bucs played great in every game last season compared to 75% great games from micky O and Davis. I would also rate him higher than Bolton at the moment. But that is somthing really hard to say.

 

[liz]

I would rate him better than Davis and O'Loughlin mainly because Bucs played great in every game last season compared to 75% great games from micky O and Davis. I would also rate him higher than Bolton at the moment. But that is somthing really hard to say.

His second half of the season was very very good but he wasn't that flash for the first half.

He needs to put together another season like 2005 before he can be counted in the top rung of players, and he's probably never going to be as important as the likes of O'Loughlin, Davis or O'Keefe because there are more players in the squad physically capable of playing the kind of role he does.

 

[ROK of Gibraltar]

AMEN
AMON

Bucky is top shelf, just needs one more season like last year then we'll be shouting out elite.

Top shelf? Do you remember how top shelf he was in front of goal this year? He is a good honest toiler who would find a place in any 22 in the AFL but would not be top 10 on any list.