Analysis of our list.

[Falkon]

Sibosado 1st yr. > 2nd 21 > 22 Forward D grader
Faulks 1st yr. > 2nd 23 > 24 Defender C grader
Mellington 1st yr. > 2nd 19 > 20 Forward/ midfield C grader​

Bollenhagen 2nd yr. >3rd 20 > 21 Midfield D grader
Pitt 1st yr. >2nd 19 > 21 Midfield C grader
Walters 3rd yr. >4th 20 > 21 Forward C grader
Mzungu 1st yr. >2nd 25 > 26 Midfield/forward C grader

Crichton 2rd yr >3rd 20 > 21 Midfield D grader
Clarke 3rd yr. >4th 21 > 22 Ruck C grader
Barlow 2nd yr. >3rd 24 > 25 Midfield B grader
Morabito 2nd yr. >3rd 20 > 21 Midfield C grader
Silvagni 2nd yr >3rd 24 > 25 Defender B grader
Pearce 3rd yr. >4th 21 > 22 Midfield D grader
Roberton 2nd yr. >3rd 20 > 21 Midfield D grader

Vanberlo 3rd yr. >4th 23 > 24 Midfield D grader
Fyfe 2nd yr. >3rd 20 > 21 Midfield B grader
Lower 6th yr. >7th 24 > 25 Midfield C grader
Ballantyne 3rd yr. >4th 24 > 25 Forward B grader
Anthony 4th yr. >5th 23 > 24 Defender/ Forward D grader
Griffin 5th yr. >6th 25 > 26 Ruck B grader
Suban 3rd yr. >4th 21 > 22 Midfield/ defender C grader

De Boer 3rd yr. >4th 21 > 22 Midfield B grader
Broughton 3rd yr. >4th 25 > 26 Midfield B grader
Mayne 4th yr. >5th 23 > 24 Forward C grader
Hill 3rd yr. >4th 21 > 22 Midfield C grader
Ibbotson 5th yr. >6th 23 > 24 Defender B grader
Duffield 6th yr. >7th 26 > 27 Defender C grader
Bradely 8th yr. >9th 26 > 27 Forward C grader

Crowely 7th yr. >8th 27 > 28 Midfield C grader
Johnson 7th yr. >8th 27 > 28 Defender/ Forward B grader
Mundy 7th yr. >8th 26 > 27 Midfield A grader
Sandilands 9th yr. >10th 29 > 30 Ruck A Grader
MCpharlin 11th yr.>12th 30 > 31 Defender A Grader
Grover 12th yr.>13th 31 > 32 Defender B grader
Mcphee 10th yr.>11th 29 > 30 Utility B grader
Pavlich 11th yr. >12th 30 > 31 Forward A Grader
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Viv Mitchie - yet to debut 1st yr>2nd yr 19 > 21 Forward
Gavin Roberts - Unknown

7 spots to fill atm.

Thoughts?

 

[Nothing]

Tough marker on some (Fyfe, Barlow, Silvagni)

I'll let others launch into a tirade on others (hint: one of your 7th year players)

EDIT: but mostly spot on

 

[im_a_lazy_sod]

Don't point it out to him lol

Decent analysis and reps for actually doing it (not many have the time/can't be bothered but will be more than happy to rip other peoples lists/predictions to shreds)

 

[Pegasaur]

It's pretty accurate but I don't see Mcphee and Fyfe on the same level.

 

[The Night Shift]

Do you grade uni essay's Falkon?

 

[Alfonz]

Thoughts?

Too high:
Ibbotson 5th yr. >6th 23 > 24 Defender B grader
Crowely 7th yr. >8th 27 > 28 Midfield C grader
Johnson 7th yr. >8th 27 > 28 Defender/ Forward B grader
Mcphee 10th yr.>11th 29 > 30 Utility B grader

Too low:
Barlow 2nd yr. >3rd 24 > 25 Midfield B grader
Fyfe 2nd yr. >3rd 20 > 21 Midfield B grader

Rest I'd have about the same, although Morabito, Hill and Silvagni will hopefully become A graders.

 

[dominguez]

Our list went backwards over the last 6 months which would have had a big impact on Harvey getting the axe.

Johnson was shithouse.
Duffield signed a 4 year deal after playing really well in 2010 then played like Josh Head.
Palmer didn't get out of first gear.
Walters didn't fire a shot after round one.
Pavlich had his worst season in close to a decade.
Hill went backwards, Mayne too.
Ibbotson certainly didn't improve.
Broughton tapered off.
Crowley gave nothing.

The only players who improved that spring to mind were Fyfe and Clarke.

 

[kp junior]

Hill is One of the first couple of our players tagged, and he's a C ? On a par with Faulks? Somewhat harsh

And just noticed Johnson gets a B? He's an E and you know it, drug pun intended

 

[apuchar]

Our list went backwards over the last 6 months which would have had a big impact on Harvey getting the axe.

Johnson was shithouse.
Duffield signed a 4 year deal after playing really well in 2010 then played like Josh Head.
Palmer didn't get out of first gear.
Walters didn't fire a shot after round one.
Pavlich had his worst season in close to a decade.
Hill went backwards, Mayne too.
Ibbotson certainly didn't improve.
Broughton tapered off.
Crowley gave nothing.

The only players who improved that spring to mind were Fyfe and Clarke.

Yep. And I would add Crichton and Roberton to that, who went backwards this year.

I think Freo should ask Duffield if he would like his working holiday in Brisbane next season instead of WA.

 

[Falkon]

to me Hill, is on the verge of becoming a b grader. He just needs to bring consistency to his game. yes i know he gets tagged, but that shouldnt curve his ability, IE against collingwood he had 30 possesions (because they dont tag), his best for the yr. 12 of which were contested, also his highest for the yr. I think with the likes of Mundy, Morabito in there nxt yr he will go to the next level.

As for Morabito, hes been out for a yr, and seeing as though Palmer never returned to his previous level after the reco i just gave him an average grade.

Mcphee brings a lot of experience to the group, and plays a pivotal role in protecting our players and intimidating the opposition. I dont think the FFC would have brought him over from the dons if they thought he was a c grader.

 

[tacopavlich]

looks pretty good, though fyfe was stiff not to make AA, so should be an A grader.

 

[tacopavlich]

to me Hill, is on the verge of becoming a b grader. He just needs to bring consistency to his game. yes i know he gets tagged, but that shouldnt curve his ability, IE against collingwood he had 30 possesions (because they dont tag), his best for the yr. 12 of which were contested, also his highest for the yr. I think with the likes of Mundy, Morabito in there nxt yr he will go to the next level.

As for Morabito, hes been out for a yr, and seeing as though Palmer never returned to his previous level after the reco i just gave him an average grade.

Mcphee brings a lot of experience to the group, and plays a pivotal role in protecting our players and intimidating the opposition. I dont think the FFC would have brought him over from the dons if they thought he was a c grader.

i think that's the whole point of tagging.

 

[Falkon]

Yes i understand that, but it shouldnt curve his ability to that extent. 30 > 18.

 

[Proud Bogan]

Yes i understand that, but it shouldnt curve his ability to that extent. 30 > 18.

Ok, that's twice.

The word your are looking for for is Curb!

 

[dominguez]

Gee it's a stiff learning curb around here.....

 

[Proud Bogan]

How very droll.

 

[IAMJUNGLEMUFFIN]

Looking at OP, and I still have NFI what all this >2nd >25 shit is supposed ot be.

I'm assuming he's made it simple for those of us who don't understand 1st year players soon become 2nd year players, and 22 year olds then become 23 year olds? If that's the case, I take it Pitt was born on Groundhog day?

The ratings are interesting. Walters can't get a game ahead of Crichton, Pearce, Roberton, but is ranked a level above?

De Boer ahead of Hill?
MJ?
Grover?
McPhee?
Fyfe a bit rough.

A couple of ballsy calls, i.e. Iboo, Griffin, wouldn't say I disagree.

B grade for Ballas is probably fair based on his injuries, but I think he's probably an A grade player when fully fit, especially in the pocket.

 

[23cmonShane!]

Looking at OP, and I still have NFI what all this >2nd >25 shit is supposed ot be.

Agree. I'm a scientist and have no flipping idea!