Remove this Banner Ad

Armitage to the Demons

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

TJCH

Rookie
Sep 25, 2008
36
0
melbourne
AFL Club
Melbourne
David Armitage to the dees for pick 19 is the mail going around at the moment
both parties are winners i feel.
armitage doesn't suit the saints game plan, i think bailey will get more out of armitage- new environment. and saints will get someone very good at 19.

That also said, here are some more trades

Ray to dockers/demons
warnock to carlton
o'keefe to collingwood/carlton/essendon
lovett to sydney
cousins in draft
prismall in psd to dees
adam thomson to bombers
greg bentley to dees
 
Saw the Armitage trade on demonland, didn't take much notice though.
What makes you think this will happen? seen anything in the news?
Just curious as i think Armitage is a gun and would love him at the dees but hopefully for our 3rd rounder and a Bartram type player. don't really wanna part with picks 1,17,19.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

David Armitage to the dees for pick 19 is the mail going around at the moment
both parties are winners i feel.
armitage doesn't suit the saints game plan, i think bailey will get more out of armitage- new environment. and saints will get someone very good at 19.

That also said, here are some more trades

Ray to dockers/demons
warnock to carlton
o'keefe to collingwood/carlton/essendon
lovett to sydney
cousins in draft
prismall in psd to dees
adam thomson to bombers
greg bentley to dees

Ray to dockers/demons - demons need to improve their list not make it worse
warnock to carlton - pick 24 only
o'keefe to collingwood/carlton/essendon - collingwood dont need him... Carlton will struggle to satisfy Sydney + Roos hates Carlton - Essendon & Hawthorn in the box seat
lovett to sydney - almost done
cousins in draft - collingwood done deal
prismall in psd to dees - will be/ has been offered a 2 year contract by the cats
adam thomson to bombers - nothing to get excited about
greg bentley to dees - who???
 
David Armitage to the dees for pick 19 is the mail going around at the moment
both parties are winners i feel.
armitage doesn't suit the saints game plan, i think bailey will get more out of armitage- new environment. and saints will get someone very good at 19.

That also said, here are some more trades

Ray to dockers/demons
warnock to carlton
o'keefe to collingwood/carlton/essendon
lovett to sydney
cousins in draft
prismall in psd to dees
adam thomson to bombers
greg bentley to dees

I fail to see the reason for you listing a bunch of other trades whch are already strong rumours, unless it was an attempt to add credibility to your own rumour:confused:
 
there will. its called trading mate, if those happen, players will be traded, perhaps with picks. we have a lot of open spots atm. neitz, holland, white, yze, bode, weetra- more delistings to come probably.
 
I fail to see the reason for you listing a bunch of other trades whch are already strong rumours, unless it was an attempt to add credibility to your own rumour:confused:
alot of deals that are talked about/negotiiated behind closed doors don't get heard about from public like yourself...but i work in the media, and all i'm saying are these are the one's i've heard floating around
another is a for way deal including 4 clubs. Adelaide one of them, brent reilly up for grabs for draft picks, dees to give adeliade bell...diff rumours about that one
 
Saw the Armitage trade on demonland, didn't take much notice though.
What makes you think this will happen? seen anything in the news?
Just curious as i think Armitage is a gun and would love him at the dees but hopefully for our 3rd rounder and a Bartram type player. don't really wanna part with picks 1,17,19.

Mate, to get quality you need to give quality. Armitage was pick 9 in his draft, and has had 2 years in the system. The signs are that next year will be his breakout year. Saints would NEVER trade him...
 
there will. its called trading mate, if those happen, players will be traded, perhaps with picks. we have a lot of open spots atm. neitz, holland, white, yze, bode, weetra- more delistings to come probably.

but no room for armitage.

if the dees think pick 19 for armo will be done, then they are heavily deluded.

Armitage will not be traded.
 
I can't see the Saints being happy to give up our only true developing midfielder who was pick 9 two years back for Pick 19.

The kid has obvious talent & has had two years of development (and plenty of dollars) put into him.

Armitage is our future & we need to support him by adding 2-3 other young mids in this draft/rookie draft. If that means that other players are moved on & more picks are added then that's sweet with me.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Where did you hear that from?
 
alot of deals that are talked about/negotiiated behind closed doors don't get heard about from public like yourself...but i work in the media, and all i'm saying are these are the one's i've heard floating around
another is a for way deal including 4 clubs. Adelaide one of them, brent reilly up for grabs for draft picks, dees to give adeliade bell...diff rumours about that one

what - you mean adelaide is offering him for draft picks or draft picks have been offered for him

I just can't see the Crows pissing him off
 
David Armitage to the dees for pick 19 is the mail going around at the moment
both parties are winners i feel.
armitage doesn't suit the saints game plan, i think bailey will get more out of armitage- new environment. and saints will get someone very good at 19.

That also said, here are some more trades

Ray to dockers/demons
warnock to carlton
o'keefe to collingwood/carlton/essendon
lovett to sydney
cousins in draft
prismall in psd to dees
adam thomson to bombers
greg bentley to dees
Can I see this mail ?
 
alot of deals that are talked about/negotiiated behind closed doors don't get heard about from public like yourself...but i work in the media, and all i'm saying are these are the one's i've heard floating around
another is a for way deal including 4 clubs. Adelaide one of them, brent reilly up for grabs for draft picks, dees to give adeliade bell...diff rumours about that one


  1. I've heard every single one of those deals before.
  2. Why would clubs attempting to work "behind close doors" tell someone in the media whose job it is to inform the public the clubs are hiding the deals from.
In other words, you're trying to add credibility, and failing.
 
alot of deals that are talked about/negotiiated behind closed doors don't get heard about from public like yourself...but i work in the media, and all i'm saying are these are the one's i've heard floating around
another is a for way deal including 4 clubs. Adelaide one of them, brent reilly up for grabs for draft picks, dees to give adeliade bell...diff rumours about that one

I'm an average schmoe, and I have heard every single one of those rumours except the Prismall one, and I can't see a kid with a busted knee shaft his club like that.
 
Better bloody not!

Why would he want to go to Melbourne? Can't see what they would offer that we can't. If anything he'll head up the coast back home?

And as W2L said, we got him with pick 9 2 years ago, why would we want to trade him for a pick 10 less than that? Makes no sense. He's shown promising signs that he'll become a great player for us.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

what - you mean adelaide is offering him for draft picks or draft picks have been offered for him

I just can't see the Crows pissing him off


crows want him (Reilly) they think he shows a lot of promise but a bit injury prone. however he is adament he wants to return to home to Victoria, im pretty sure theyr workin their butts off to talk him out of it
 
I fail to see the reason for you listing a bunch of other trades whch are already strong rumours, unless it was an attempt to add credibility to your own rumour:confused:

Exactly.

I've seen him post in a number of trade threads, so had a look at his posts.

The bloke previously had St kilda picking up Cousins or Kerr, Cousins definitely not going to Collingwood, Kerr at Collingwood, Ray to melbourne, Prismall to the Demons, Prismall to stay at Geelong, Brad Green to Essendon.

Simply by virtue of the numbers he has to be right eventually...maybe.
 
David Armitage to the dees for pick 19 is the mail going around at the moment
both parties are winners i feel.
armitage doesn't suit the saints game plan, i think bailey will get more out of armitage- new environment. and saints will get someone very good at 19.

That also said, here are some more trades

Ray to dockers/demons
warnock to carlton
o'keefe to collingwood/carlton/essendon
lovett to sydney
cousins in draft
prismall in psd to dees
adam thomson to bombers
greg bentley to dees


Melbourne supporters are deluded if they think 19 is good enough for Armitage.
It would have too be pick 17 period this guy is all class.
The only way I could see that trade happening was for the draft pick to
offer West Coast for Kerr.
And only then if they think they would lose him to Gold Coast in two years time.
17 probaly isn't enough but the threat of Gold Coast, may make them susceptible to that trade although I highly doubt it.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top