Game Day Around The Grounds - Week 1 - Elimination & Qualifying Finals 2022

[Mondyboy]

Anyone else notice they started to play the Richmond song at the end and then stopped and jumped it to the Brisbane one?!?!

Priceless! Just made the whole thing more amusing.

Yep. AFL really is amateur hour.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[TheCoach16]

Of course Ralph having a big sook.

He’s another flog!

 

[carlton_99]

Not sure about that ARC decision...

After seeing the replay a few more times Im starting to shift more to the "it being a point" side.

 

[Juice030103]

I mean yes the umpire said it was a goal but Lynch didn’t seem at all convinced. To me he looked like he thought he missed

 

[tarczonandjane]

The goal review system is a joke. And yes, I’m happy Richmond lost. But if it was Carlton losing a game to that, I’d be apoplectic. There is no way on this earth that the reviewer could be definitive on that. No way known. I’m over watching video review umpires watching things and then definitively declare there was a touch after watching a replay 100 times and apparently seeing a fingernail brush back. If the goal umpire and field umpires can’t see it, then there’s nothing doing and it should just be a goal.

 

[agro]

I have enormous respect for Richmond, enormous respect.

 

[I bleed Blue]

That was like watching us blow a lead with a minute to go

 

[Stamos]

After seeing the replay a few more times Im starting to shift more to the "it being a point" side.

I thought it was a point.
But there is no way that there was definitive proof that it missed the goals, which is what is required to over-rule.

 

[Aphrodite]

Anyone else notice they started to play the Richmond song at the end and then stopped and jumped it to the Brisbane one?!?!

Priceless! Just made the whole thing more amusing.

Sure did I mentioned it before

 

[Baggers]

Very poorly coached.

Why go to Brisbane to play a shoot out and not tag neale?

Dummy spit Dimma had enough?

Spot on.
Goal review was a joke, but not sending anyone to Neale was a bigger joke.
Zero sympathy after the 5h!t they've been giving us recently.
It's good to smile after a game again

 

[BlueGum]

Dimma off to *?

 

[Accidental genius]

Reckon filth will lose to cats but they will probably make it to GF

 

[Aphrodite]

Reckon filth will lose to cats but they will probably make it to GF

Oh no you don’t

 

[TheCoach16]

The goal review system is a joke. And yes, I’m happy Richmond lost. But if it was Carlton losing a game to that, I’d be apoplectic. There is no way on this earth that the reviewer could be definitive on that. No way known. I’m over watching video review umpires watching things and then definitively declare there was a touch after watching a replay 100 times and apparently seeing a fingernail brush back. If the goal umpire and field umpires can’t see it, then there’s nothing doing and it should just be a goal.

The review system giveth and the review system taketh away.
Richmond beat us because of a shit review earlier in the year. Tonight they copped their right whack.

Lynch missed anyway. If he kicked that he would’ve been carrying on like the ****en peanut he is. He knew he missed it.

 

[8Special K]

The goal review system is a joke. And yes, I’m happy Richmond lost. But if it was Carlton losing a game to that, I’d be apoplectic. There is no way on this earth that the reviewer could be definitive on that. No way known. I’m over watching video review umpires watching things and then definitively declare there was a touch after watching a replay 100 times and apparently seeing a fingernail brush back. If the goal umpire and field umpires can’t see it, then there’s nothing doing and it should just be a goal.

Oh well, karma for the newnes goal that was over turned. Suffer

 

[Juice030103]

Neale Boy oh boy wowee

 

[Aphrodite]

 

[agro]

I have enormous respect for Richmond, enormous respect.

 

[DirtyLeeds]

HaHaHa, that the tiggers will spew for six months about a dodgy score review is pure karma. This game was not determined by that decision, there were so many more contentious calls, as there are in every game, that's the game we all love it's not a round ball, it is up to individuals interpretation, there are blind spots.....
No pity here hate the * anyway

 

[TheCoach16]

I thought it was a point.
But there is no way that there was definitive proof that it missed the goals, which is what is required to over-rule.

The review was correct. It’s the goal umpire that had no definitive proof. He made an awful call.

 

[footyfan1978]

That was like watching us blow a lead with a minute to go

The mistake of four of their defenders all in similar spot and leave Daniher behind them would be torture.
We done three or four mistakes as bad as that in some close ones.
I could not believe their luck when Lynch missed and goal umpire thought it was a goal.
Thankfully reviewed but I feared above the post they would find some way to **** it up.
All I could think about was the Warren Ralph moment where he was given a point when it was a goal and we drew a match.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Lynch missed. Umpire call was tentative and wrong. The review got the right result even if the umpire got it wrong initially.

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

The review was correct. It’s the goal umpire that had no definitive proof. He made an awful call.

Goal umpire doesn't need definitive evidence. He makes his call and we are to trust the call, like any other decision over the 120 minutes!

Two mistakes. Should never have been called a goal. Should never have been overturned.

 

[TheCoach16]

The review was correct. It’s the goal umpire that had no definitive proof. He made an awful call.

Lynch missed. Umpire call was tentative and wrong. The review got the right result even if the umpire got it wrong initially.

Great minds.

 

[TheCoach16]

Goal umpire doesn't need definitive evidence. He makes his call and we are to trust the call, like any other decision over the 120 minutes!

Two mistakes. Should never have been called a goal. Should never have been overturned.

Maybe two wrongs DO make a right.
The imposters are GONE, so I’m very comfortable with the review system.