Buddy is a good footballer but is definitely no physical specimen. Plays well below his size.
Ben Simmons - if he had grown up playing footy
- Thread starter crocsta
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Buddy is a good footballer but is definitely no physical specimen. Plays well below his size.
Was/is he a gifted footballer though? It’s one thing to say he’s got skills and athleticism, but it’s those players who seemingly slow the world down when they have the ball and seem to have space in frantic contests, that are really set apart from the pack. He could very well have that, but a few junior seasons can’t tell you that. If he doesn’t have that, his physical attributes cover it up heaps at a junior level (it’s pretty easy to find time if you’re too big to tackle). Did anyone see him play?
Tyler Hodges
Club Legend
- Jun 28, 2013
- 2,155
- 3,125
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Philadelphia 76'ers
http://www.smh.com.au/sport/basketb...riend-christian-petracca-20160618-gpmaut.html
Probably as close as anyone will get unfortunately.
- Jul 13, 2012
- 43,603
- 21,025
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Charlotte Hornets, Chelsea, Striker
Basketball? Baseball?
Pykie
Cancelled
10k Posts
A Star Wars Fan
Pokemon is Life
North Melbourne - North 2007 Player Sponsor
North Melbourne - 2013 Daw, Black and Gibson Player Sponsorship
Simmons makes Buddy look like Lance Whitnell in the athletic stakes.
He's only like an 1" shorter than Sandilands and is definately faster over 20m than Franklin. Speed wise, he's already being labled as one of the bigger freaks athletically in recent times in the NBA
Building into his frame, will end up around the 110kg mark.
The only bloke comparable to him would be Naitanui, even then, Ben would absolutely maul him as he's over 3" taller than him and even more athletic.
He's only like an 1" shorter than Sandilands and is definately faster over 20m than Franklin. Speed wise, he's already being labled as one of the bigger freaks athletically in recent times in the NBA
Building into his frame, will end up around the 110kg mark.
The only bloke comparable to him would be Naitanui, even then, Ben would absolutely maul him as he's over 3" taller than him and even more athletic.
Bogut said last week that he thinks Simmons is taller than 6'10".
Xhoquelin
Club Legend
- Dec 4, 2016
- 1,099
- 1,120
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Charlotte Hornets
Giannis does to and if he keeps his current level up he could win the MVP.
Ben shoots the 18 footer when he's confident, eventually that could definitely become a 3 pointer.
His vision is already elite which isn't something you can teach
- May 16, 2014
- 12,163
- 15,984
- AFL Club
- Carlton
320 million odd Americans v 25 million odd Australians.
Only our very very best are ever going to have even a slight chance of making it over there.
Simmons is a freak. Considering his freak athleticism and build, his work-ethic, his composure, his mental game, and his hand-eye coordination, the only possible question mark on him would be would he relish the physicality of AFL enough? Even then, you'd think by the time he reached his late teens he'd be very much used to it had he continued playing, and basketball isn't immune from hits (although it is still quite a few steps below AFL in terms of physicality). Had he chosen AFL - his basketball ability tells me he would have ended up with decent skills, the endurance required to play, the ability to do ridiculous Cyril-like s**t vision and hand-eye coordination wise, but as a 208cm player, all while jumping over opponents and burning them off.
Only our very very best are ever going to have even a slight chance of making it over there.
Simmons is a freak. Considering his freak athleticism and build, his work-ethic, his composure, his mental game, and his hand-eye coordination, the only possible question mark on him would be would he relish the physicality of AFL enough? Even then, you'd think by the time he reached his late teens he'd be very much used to it had he continued playing, and basketball isn't immune from hits (although it is still quite a few steps below AFL in terms of physicality). Had he chosen AFL - his basketball ability tells me he would have ended up with decent skills, the endurance required to play, the ability to do ridiculous Cyril-like s**t vision and hand-eye coordination wise, but as a 208cm player, all while jumping over opponents and burning them off.
- Apr 20, 2006
- 9,161
- 12,222
- AFL Club
- Carlton
I'm huge basketball fan but I think the standard of NBA talent (Australian rules also) is extremely overrated compared to a sport like soccer. An American born 7ft is something like a 1 in 10 chance of playing NBA and if you are born over 6'6 you are something like a 1 in 100 chance of playing NBA. Considering most players are of that height that's a bloody tiny talent pool and it is pretty much just a sport revolving on height.
Also Simmons is closer to 205cm not 208cn because they measure the players in shoes
Also Simmons is closer to 205cm not 208cn because they measure the players in shoes
I played footy against him in u13s. He was a gun. Had won a best and fairest in u12s or something too.
Doubt he ever really properly considered footy over basketball though. His old man was setting him up for basketball success from day one.
Doubt he ever really properly considered footy over basketball though. His old man was setting him up for basketball success from day one.
Last edited:
NBA players aren't built for endurance though so its not exactly comparing apples with apples and NBA players are all on gear.
You bulk up Naitanui as more of a power athelete and let him take gear (or more gear depending on how sceptical you're on the AFL being clean) the gap between he and Simmons wouldn't be as wide as you make out.
That being said Simmons was no where near ever choosing AFL. His father was American and had him moving around different representative basketball teams making sure he played the majority of his basketball as a guard despite being the biggest kid on the court.
Wouldn't say that Giannis lacks a jump shot. It's not a strength of his sure, but at this stage his J is way, way, way more developed and consistent than Simmons'.
They train for a specific athletic requirement lets see how much power and speed drops off when they have to meet an AFL players endurance level. I think they would fall inline with Franklin. Oh and a lot harder to get on the roids in our sport compared to the NFL and NBA.
Get them off the gear and have them running 16km+ every week and lets see how they fair "athletically", they will certainly have some freaks given a population of 360 mil but it would be a lot closer then you think.
- Moderator
- #67
Simmons would be a star in any physical sport he chose to play as a kid. The kid is an athletic freak.
And that is ignoring his touch/feel with the ball. I cant wait till 2020 and the Boomers.
And that is ignoring his touch/feel with the ball. I cant wait till 2020 and the Boomers.
Last edited:
If Dean Brogan - who is nowhere near the athlete that top NBA players are - can make the switch and have a successful 14 year career, I’m fairly sure there’d be s**t tons of NBA players who would be successes.
Bojan KantKick
Man United Legacy Supporter
- Sep 5, 2014
- 30,116
- 28,705
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Manchester United, Stevenage FC
No it really wouldn't. Buddy is average and has taken more gear than the players I mentioned.
Bojan KantKick
Man United Legacy Supporter
- Sep 5, 2014
- 30,116
- 28,705
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Manchester United, Stevenage FC
he's also a rookie. Lebron had no J when he entered the league.
Relative to Simmons he does. Also I must have missed where jumpshots only count from behind the 3. Heard of mid-range before?
- Jul 14, 2005
- 18,723
- 29,561
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Chelsea FC
- Banned
- #75
Already made in sponsorships what any A-grade player AFL player will make over a career.
Scary how good he's going to be, and one of those guys that'll drag part-time NBA watchers into the sport.
Scary how good he's going to be, and one of those guys that'll drag part-time NBA watchers into the sport.
Last edited:
