Best Pick no. 4

[Runandhyde]

Who is the best no. 4 pick of reccent drafts?

 

[Blacky]

Luke Livingston > Richard Tambling

 

[Blacky]

Comparing drafts is pretty silly, because each years crop of players is vastly different, and you aren't taking into account what a specific teams needs were at the time...

 

[james Dean]

Leunberger hasn't debuted yet so can't vote for him, Polak is a headcase, Tambling is a hack, Walsh... Has he even played a game yet? Kennedy is all that's left so.. JK FTW

 

[betterthanu]

out of JK and Ray...hmmm

 

[wce4premiership]

sure isn't polak.

 

[bus24]

The last couple of number 4 picks seem to have reversed the trend.

 

[FlamingDon]

Well there all a disgrace Graham Polak wins hands down

Timothy Walsh - who the hell is that?
Matthew Leuenburger - Yet to debut
Farren Ray - Hasn't a played a great game for doggies yet!
Richard Tambling - Certainly better then Ray & Walsh, he will produce the goods in years to come dont you worry bout that.
Joshua Kennedy - Hasn't done anything special but would probably be the best of the bunch in the future.
Graham Polak - none of em can be compared to him he's clearly the best out of em strong contested mark had a great year for Freo in 03 or 04 then was shocking the next and now a Tiger he will have a good year this year IMO.

 

[Scruba]

Well there all a disgrace Graham Polak wins hands down

Timothy Walsh - who the hell is that?
Matthew Leuenburger - Yet to debut
Farren Ray - Hasn't a played a great game for doggies yet!
Richard Tambling - Certainly better then Ray & Walsh, he will produce the goods in years to come dont you worry bout that.
Joshua Kennedy - Hasn't done anything special but would probably be the best of the bunch in the future.
Graham Polak - none of em can be compared to him he's clearly the best out of em strong contested mark had a great year for Freo in 03 or 04 then was shocking the next and now a Tiger he will have a good year this year IMO.

I suggest you go and watch a replay of the 2006 Elimination Final vs Pies. Young Farren carved up the Pies with 27 touches and 3 goals. As for the poll, Ray by an absolute mile. It isn't even close

 

[HBK619]

Luenburger on Potential, but Polak on what I have seen.

 

[Dj Chriss]

Whos walsh? and where did he go to?

 

[BedlamHawk]

Whos walsh? and where did he go to?

I have to agree, who the hell is Tim Walsh ?

 

[KnockOut]

Ray by a street.

 

[rgauci]

1999: Matthew Pavlich

 

[Smell The Glove]

Out of those who have debuted, probably Kennedy, with only Ray for any real competition. Leuenberger on talent though, if he uses it will probably end up the best player from that group.

 

[lids2004roar]

Why would Leuenberger be any better than the others?

Polak was meant to be the greatest KPP coming out of the greatest draft in history, where has potential got him?

Most of you have never even seen Leuenberger so how can you tell if he is the best?

Polak so far is the best performer - 2nd in Rising Star, and has single handedly won matches against the premiers in their premier year. With fitness and consistency he'll prove his worth.

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Leuenberger, comfortably.

Had no business whatsoever being available at #4. Just shows how strong the pointy end of the 2006 draft was.

 

[DapperDon]

Leuenberger, comfortably.

Had no business whatsoever being available at #4. Just shows how strong the pointy end of the 2006 draft was.

yep he's tearing up the comp

 

[sarah.13]

Voted for Leuenberger, the rest are duds.

 

[dales.girl38]

Farren Ray, only because I'm yet to see Leuenberger, surely you can't pick him when he hasn't played an AFL match yet.

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

yep he's tearing up the comp

Hasn't done it in the AFL yet, but I've seen him play - He's a bloody talent, that's for sure.

 

[Silvagnis]

The Berger.

the rest are duds.

Kennedy is a gun kid and talent, but I guess Farren Ray and Tambling aren't as good as Varcoe, Byrnes, Stokes and Tenace in your eyes.

 

[Silvagnis]

Why would Leuenberger be any better than the others?

Polak was meant to be the greatest KPP coming out of the greatest draft in history, where has potential got him?

Most of you have never even seen Leuenberger so how can you tell if he is the best?

Polak so far is the best performer - 2nd in Rising Star, and has single handedly won matches against the premiers in their premier year. With fitness and consistency he'll prove his worth.

Perhaps you should change your name to ben(tleigh)ny_Furs?

 

[Kaiser Powser]

Mark Bolton

Daniel McAllistar

 

[one_twelve112]

Ray or Kennedy i'd say