BF v AFC 2003 Voting

[Kane McGoodwin]

BF (AFC) BOG voting

Round 1 v Freo
1 Edwards (=1)
2 McLeod (=1)
3 Torney (=1)
4 Bode (4)
5 Carey (=5)

Round 2 v Saints
1 McLeod (1)
2 Torney (=3)
3 Edwards (=3)
4 Goodwin (10)
5 Johncock (=7)
(Bickley BF 1st BTM, AFC 2nd)

Round 3 v Sydney
1 Stevens (=3)
2 Edwards (=8)
3 Bassett (=3)
4 Ricciuto (12)
5 Bode (1)
(Stenglein BF 2nd BTM, AFC 2nd)

Round 4 v Weagles
1 McLeod (1)
2 Ricciuto (2)
3 Bode (=3)
4 Stenglein (=3)
5 Bickley (11)
(Biglands BF 3rd BTM, AFC 3rd)

Round 5 v Port
1 Johncock (1)
2 Burns (2)
3 Bode (5)
=4 Bickley (=3)
=4 Hart (=10)
(Stenglein BF 2nd BTM, AFC =3rd)

Round 6 v Roos
1 Ricciuto (1)
2 Johncock (=2)
3 McLeod (4)
4 Bickley (=2) (1st BF BTM)
5 Bode (=6)

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Round 7 v Pies
1 Ricciuto (1)
2 Burns (2)
3 Carey (3)
4 Stenglein (6)
5 Torney (=8)

Round 8 v Lions
1 Gallagher (4)
2 Perrie (=1)
3 Edwards (=1)
4 Bickley (3)
5 Begley (8)

Round 9 v Bullies
1 McLeod (1)
2 Clarke (=2)
3 Begley (4)
4 Goodwin (=2)
5 Massie (5)

Round 10 v Cats
1 Perrie (1)
2 Edwards (=2)
3 Bickley (=2)
4 Torney (=6)
5 Welsh (=4)

Round 11 v Hawks
1 Massie (=2)
2 McGregor (=2)
3 Hart (=2)
4 Bassett (5)
5 Ladhams (=8)
(Roo best for AFC)

Round 12 v Dees
1 Ricciuto (n/a)
2 Perrie (2)
3 Burton (1)
4 Johncock (6)
5 Massie (=3)
(Biglands 1st BTM, =3rd AFC)

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Round 13 v Blues
1 Burton (=1)
2 Johncock (=1)
3 McLeod (=5)
4 Shirley (=5)
5 Massie (=1) (2nd BTM)

Round 14 v Tigers
1 Bassett (1)
2 Ricciuto (=3)
3 Ladhams (=3)
4 Massie (2)
5 McGegor (=7)

Round 15 v Dons
1 Ricciuto (=1)
2 Welsh (=1)
3 Burton (=1)
4 Bickley (6)
5 Smart (=7)

Round 16 v Freo
1 Ricciuto (1)
2 McLeod (=9)
3 Burton (2)
4 Ladhams (4)
5 Burns (3)

Round 17 v Saints
1 Burton (=1)
2 Ricciuto (=1)
3 Johncock (=1)
4 Ladhams (5)
5 Hart (=14)
(Torney 1st BTM, 4th AFC)

Round 18 v Swans
1 Carey (1)
2 Edwards (=2)
3 Ladhams (=2)
4 Burton (=7)
5 Torney (=11)

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Round 19 v Weagles
1 Carey (=7)
2 Johncock (1)
3 Ricciuto (=3)
4 Smart (=3)
5 McGregor (=7)
(Shirley 1st BTM, 2nd AFC)

Round 20 v Pies
1 Smart (1)
2 Torney (2)
3 Edwards (3)
4 McLeod (=4)
5 Burton (=4)

Round 21 v Roos
1 Ricciuto (1)
2 Shirley (=5)
3 Burton (=3)
4 Carey (2)
5 McGregor (=5)

Round 22 v Port
1 Bode (=3)
2 Ricciuto (=7)
3 Edwards (2)
4 Carey (1) (2nd BTM)
5 Smart (=3) (1st BTM)

QF v Weagles
=1 Edwards (1)
=1 Hart (2)
3 Shirley (3)
4 Carey (=4)
5 Ricciuto (=10)

SF v Lions
1 Burton (1)
2 Biglands (=4)
3 Shirley (6)
4 Ricciuto (=4)
5 McGregor (=7)

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

We picked the same BOG as AFC for 18/24 games (75%) & were pretty accurate with our assessments the majority of times.

Notable exceptions:
- Round 11 v Hawks, AFC ranked Roo #1, but we didn't have him in our top-5.
- Round 12 v Dees, we ranked Roo #1, but AFC didn't even have him in their best players.

 

[-WWJD-]

Originally posted by Kane McGoodwin
- Round 12 v Dees, we ranked Roo #1, but AFC didn't even have him in their best players.

Didn't Roo get 3 Brownlow votes for that game?

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Originally posted by acg_204*
Didn't Roo get 3 Brownlow votes for that game?

Yes, he certainly did (& got none in the Hawks game).

 

[Stiffy_18]

Originally posted by Kane McGoodwin
- Round 12 v Dees, we ranked Roo #1, but AFC didn't even have him in their best players.

AFC ****ed up I reckon cos if he wasn't in our best players I'll eat my shorts.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Originally posted by Kane McGoodwin
Notable exceptions:
- Round 11 v Hawks, AFC ranked Roo #1, but we didn't have him in our top-5.
- Round 12 v Dees, we ranked Roo #1, but AFC didn't even have him in their best players.

In the Dees game Roo had 24 possessions & kicked 4 goals, yet couldn't get in AFC's top 17 players according to today's paper. Perhaps the tiser mixed up Roo's R11 & R12??? Either that or he had words with Ayres...

BTW, in the Hawks game, he got 19 possessions & gave away 4 frees.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Originally posted by Kane McGoodwin
In the Dees game Roo had 24 possessions & kicked 4 goals, yet couldn't get in AFC's top 17 players according to today's paper. Perhaps the tiser mixed up Roo's R11 & R12??? Either that or he had words with Ayres...

BTW, in the Hawks game, he got 19 possessions & gave away 4 frees.

Does anyone have the AFC Club Champion on tape?

Surely the Tiser made a misprint with the Dees game.

 

[Scotty's_Girl]

Originally posted by Kane McGoodwin
Does anyone have the AFC Club Champion on tape?

Surely the Tiser made a misprint with the Dees game.

Yep.

Roo got 12 votes for round 12. None in round 11.

 

[macca23]

You gotta hand it to the club - they didn't do a bad job getting as close to the elite of judges as found on this board!!