Cameron or Franklin?

[DangerSloane]

Ok my question is who would you prefer to recruit this offseason (if it was possible) Buddy or Cameron?

You'd say Buddy is currently the better player, but with Cameron's upside and youth its a tough decision.

 

[juss]

Ok my question is who would you prefer to recruit this offseason (if it was possible) Buddy or Cameron?

You'd say Buddy is currently the better player, but with Cameron's upside and youth its a tough decision.

Not really that tough, based on time left in the game, potential, when our premiership window will be open etc, I'd happily take Cameron first. I'd imagine so would any other developing side.

 

[DangerSloane]

Not really that tough, based on time left in the game, potential, when our premiership window will be open etc, I'd happily take Cameron first. I'd imagine so would any other developing side.

This is why the poll matters though. Will teams that are in their window prefer Buddy?

 

[Danair]

This is why the poll matters though. Will teams that are in their window prefer Buddy?

Nope, I'd still take Cameron, he's that good already and imagine him with the service of a top class midfield and another preseason

 

[juss]

This is why the poll matters though. Will teams that are in their window prefer Buddy?

To be honest I don't think any team would pick Franklin. Maybe though a team who thinks they can win it in the next year or two. Beyond that no one would take Buddy.

 

[dajesmac]

Franklin is probably the obvious choice but Cameron seems like less of a tool.

 

[Danair]

Can I change my vote?

 

[Rainfall]

Cameron will have no problem hitting 500+ goals in his career

 

[Big Tom 2013]

I'd vote Cameron. Heaps of upside, exciting and would love him at the cats

 

[jiphoc]

Same age Franklin. Hindsight of how Franklin has evolved to present day... Cameron.

Difference being Cameron has a contested mark. Franklin is obviously better below his knees. Depends what you rate as a KPF.

 

[Engimal]

Cameron. Franklin is essentially a giant flanker now. A shaodow of what he was in '08.

 

[The GOAT]

Don't think anyone would vote for buddy right now, which says a lot about Cameron

 

[shorehawk]

Cameron for me. Just awesome to watch. Imagine what he could achieve in a top 4 side.

 

[Jade]

Cameron by a bloody mile.