Coach Carlton and Michael Voss - where to now

[Xtreme]

What a load of crap. There's 95% of that team that should be sent back to to the VFL before Cripps name is even jokingly mentioned.

He is by far the Blues worst performing player, a shadow of his brownlow winning self. Doesn't go when it's his turn (barely standing by as the wizard bolted past him and kicked the goal!!).

 

[Bostonian]

He is by far the Blues worst performing player, a shadow of his brownlow winning self. Doesn't go when it's his turn (barely standing by as the wizard bolted past him and kicked the goal!!).

More garbage.

You're one of those types that watches football at such a basic level you have no idea what's going on around the ground.

He goes constantly.

Then when a play unfolds and he's already put in 2-3 efforts in a short space of time you think he's standing by rather than noticing he's spent for that period of play due to to previous efforts.

Get a clue.

 

[BringFevBack2021]

More garbage.

You're one of those types that watches football at such a basic level you have no idea what's going on around the ground.

He goes constantly.

Then when a play unfolds and he's already put in 2-3 efforts in a short space of time you think he's standing by rather than noticing he's spent for that period of play due to to previous efforts.

Get a clue.

 

[Xtreme]

You're one of those types that watches football at such a basic level you have no idea what's going on around the ground.

Get a clue.

I get all of my footy info from Hodgey, Hamish and BT!!

The fact remains the players are responsible for kicking goals and stopping the opposition from scoring their own. The Carlton players and players alone should be copping the blame for their winless start to the year.

 

[demondavey]

The players are not performing to AFL standard, Cripps should be the first player axed and made to play VFL until he improves.

Well that won’t happen

 

[Bostonian]

I get all of my footy info from Hodgey, Hamish and BT!!

The fact remains the players are responsible for kicking goals and stopping the opposition from scoring their own. The Carlton players and players alone should be copping the blame for their winless start to the year.

Ok I concede.

You win the shit takes award for 2025.

Dust off that mantle piece. The trophy is coming home.

 

[Pistol Night]

We need to get Longmire.

Two of the only players at Carlton that turn up every week and give their all and get more out of the ability they have than others supposedly more talented are both ex-Swans players.

That says a lot about culture and coaching.

Horse looks happy and refreshed and enjoying life. Why would he want a whole draw full of knives plunged into his back by taking the Carlton job when the plum Tassie job is in the offing if he was considering a comeback?

 

[Bostonian]

Horse looks happy and refreshed and enjoying life. Why would he want a whole draw full of knives plunged into his back by taking the Carlton job when the plum Tassie job is in the offing if he was considering a comeback?

Maybe he likes the ultimate challenge.

 

[Dtennent94]

The problems have been around much longer than Voss, so why do we think Voss is the problem?

 

[Bostonian]

The problems have been around much longer than Voss, so why do we think Voss is the problem?

Because he can't coach.

There was an article which mentioned when he arrived and how he sat down with the players and asked them what kind of game style they would like to play.

At the time I thought who the **** cares what the players want. You're the coach, you're the one that has to come up with the game plan to bear other teams game plans.

Voss is utterly clueless when it comes to that aspect of the game.

He's the league's easiest coach to out coach.

 

[Dtennent94]

Because he can't coach.

There was an article which mentioned when he arrived and how he sat down with the players and asked them what kind of game style they would like to play.

At the time I thought who the **** cares what the players want. You're the coach, you're the one that has to come up with the game plan to bear other teams game plans.

Voss is utterly clueless when it comes to that aspect of the game.

He's the league's easiest coach to out coach.

I guess the main thing is that you can’t just fire your playing list and get a new one next week.

Whether it’s the list or Voss that’s the problem, only one of those can be changed quickly. Might as well try sacking the coach and see what happens.

 

[WillHayward]

We need to get Longmire.

Two of the only players at Carlton that turn up every week and give their all and get more out of the ability they have than others supposedly more talented are both ex-Swans players.

That says a lot about culture and coaching.

Who is available right now?

Buckley
Longmire
Simpson
Bevo (uncontracted?)
Kenny

 

[Bostonian]

Who is available right now?

Longmire
Simpson
Bevo (uncontracted?)
Kenny

Buckley perhaps.

Pyke doesn't seem interested in a top job anymore.

 

[Percel]

Time for Carlton and Richmond to be relegated to Sunday afternoon timeslots.

Brisbane
Giants
Hawks
Collingwood
Swans
GC

The above should be filling the prime tv opportunities. Or, if you have to play at the MCG then fixture the games against interstate sides that are actually good against MCG tenants. But stop putting in spud sides because they’re supposed ‘big 4’.

Carlton v North in a few weeks will probably have 110 points in total.

10 points total

 

[WillHayward]

Buckley perhaps.

Pyke doesn't seem interested in a top job anymore.

Pyke way too much baggage after the stance and the camp.

 

[Bostonian]

Pyke way too much baggage after the stance and the camp.

He can coach better than Voss though. All of his baggage is less baggage than this club has itself.

 

[Purple Suit]

Pyke way too much baggage after the stance and the camp.

Pyke would be on more as the CEO of WC. No way is he leaving that cushy role he can keep till retirement to go coach Carlton where he would be lucky to last 3 years.

 

[Pistol Night]

Buckley perhaps.

Pyke doesn't seem interested in a top job anymore.

Would you take Bucks after the Mick debacle?

 

[Bostonian]

Would you take Bucks after the Mick debacle?

One was old and past it.

The other is still young enough to understand the current football landscape after having a break from it.

 

[Seedsfan]

Sam Walsh developed his game as a junior to maximise his own disposal count. He got rewarded and praised for this.

Sadly he hasn't adjusted his game to adult AFL football and still plays the same game of a little kid. Running around in circles trying to get maximum stats.

He's actually a liability.
Can't play adult team football.

31 disposals, 21 uncontested, 80% in the back half and only 177m gained. Just plays it safe as you say to look good on the stat sheet. Doesn’t take the game on at all. Really is a fake elite player

 

[Delisted]

 

[Enviable Tradition]

We were all aware how Crazy Vossy went at Brisbane yet Carlton ploughed ahead regardless. It was a bizarre appointment at the time and looks worse now.

Oh well, at least Cripps got the 3 votes last night.

They were seduced by the cult of Ken Hinkley. We understand how that feels.

On SM-G975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Enviable Tradition]

Carlton won't sack Voss. Not yet.

They will stubbornly keep him for the next 3 seasons due to the shame of not wanting to sack another coach.

Then they will hire Damian Drum on a 6 year deal.

8 more years for the full Hinkley experience

On SM-G975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[iameviljez]

Would you take Bucks after the Mick debacle?

Buckley did coach a bits-n-pieces side to within two minutes of a flag, in fairness.

 

[Pistol Night]

Buckley did coach a bits-n-pieces side to within two minutes of a flag, in fairness.

Yeah i think i remember that..