Preview Changes and Prematch Discussion Round 4: Richmond (MCG)

[GutsyBug]

I think we really need to beat Richmond to get a good launch for the top 8, and they need to prove that they are worthy of the 8 after losing to the Doggies

Should be an interesting game. In's and Out's?

 

[TheFreshBanana]

No way Young out for Ben Ken.

I'd probably go Dwyer out for Ben Kennedy.

If anyone steps up in the VFL, maybe take Blair out.

Our biggest problem is the ****ing sub. Atm, I just think 1) Adams isn't suited for the sub, 2) it's wasted on him.

We could go Ben Ken, but... I think it's a waste to play him as a sub.

I would look at Goldsack as the sub next week.

 

[Baird]

^Agreed, Dwyer for Kennedy

 

[Baird]

I would look at Goldsack as the sub next week.

I like that idea. He was very influential as the sub on ANZAC day last year.

 

[dubber]

Josh Thomas in for Adams who will be out for a few for hit.

Ben Ken for Dwyer who seems to have injured himself?

 

[jmac70]

Adams could be in trouble for that late bump on Selwood and Dwyer might be injured. Kennedy to come in and maybe JT?

 

[mike123]

Outs: Sam Dwyer, Taylor Adams, Alan Toovey

Ins: Ben Kennedy, Tony Armstrong, Jarrod Witts

 

[blaze036]

Out: Dywer (inj) Adams (susp)

In: Kennedy and... well does anyone else really deserve a call up? We are really lacking depth

 

[Baltimore Jack]

Dwyer looked injured, so Kennedy is the obvious change
If Reid is fit, maybe he comes in for Keeffe

 

[Adz]

Out Young and Fasolo

 

[jmac70]

Outs: Sam Dwyer, Taylor Adams, Alan Toovey

Ins: Ben Kennedy, Tony Armstrong, Jarrod Witts

Toovey had his best game yet and you want to drop him?

 

[jmac70]

Out Young and Fasolo

?

 

[mike123]

Toovey had his best game yet and you want to drop him?

I don't think we can have both Toovey and Langdon in the side.

 

[SnakePlisskin]

Goldsack back and Sidebottom forward .
Replace the injured Dwyer with JThomas.

 

[half_back_flank]

Outs: Sam Dwyer, Taylor Adams, Alan Toovey

Ins: Ben Kennedy, Tony Armstrong, Jarrod Witts

Why?

 

[jmac70]

I don't think we can have both Toovey and Langdon in the side.

Why?

 

[mike123]

Why?

We need good kicks in the backline. IMO we can't have both Langdon and Toovey down there.

 

[jmac70]

We need good kicks in the backline. IMO we can't have both Langdon and Toovey down there.

Why?

 

[The Royal Sampler]

OUT: Dwyer (inj), Adams (susp), Blair
IN: Thomas, Kennedy, Martin

Young to be a permanent omission once Seedsman or Williams available.

 

[mike123]

Why?

Why?

They're both shut down defenders that aren't really good kicks of the footy. I don't think our kicking out of the backline was good enough tonight.

 

[Adz]

Why is Williams still not available. Pick him or delist. Not interested in this other bull.

 

[jmac70]

They're both shut down defenders that aren't really good kicks of the footy. I don't think our kicking out of the backline was good enough tonight.

No. They are not shut down defenders only. They provide drive from the backline AND are accountable for their man. Something that your man Armstrong just cannot do.

 

[mike123]

No. They are not shut down defenders only. They provide drive from the backline AND are accountable for their man. Something that your man Armstrong just cannot do.

Not really. They don't break lines or hit targets. Armstrong might not break lines either but he hits targets. Armstrong isn't as uncountable as everybody says. He isn't going to shut down the best small forwards but he will man his opponent up.

 

[jmac70]

Not really. They don't break lines or hit targets. Armstrong might not break lines either but he hits targets. Armstrong isn't as uncountable as everybody says. He isn't going to shut down the best small forwards but he will man his opponent up.

Let's just agree to disagree Mike. Put it this way...if Armstrong is selected next week this board will melt down.

 

[jmac70]

Why is Williams still not available. Pick him or delist. Not interested in this other bull.

The club cannot pick him (for obvious reasons). You want to delist him before his sentence. Tad harsh don't you think?