Opinion Changes V Dees

[avishka5]

OUT: Redden, Mcginnity, Hutchings, schoey
IN: Sheed, Duggan, Nelson, Emac

 

[Ochre]

In: Karpany

 

[Crimson King]

Really hoping Jetts comes straight back in.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

OUT: Redden, McGinnity, Hutchings, Brown
IN: Sheed, Karpany, Adamson, Giles

 

[Quinz]

OUT: Redden, McGinnity, Hutchings, Brown
IN: Giles, Sheed, Adamson, Nelson

Reward WAFL form.

 

[larrikin]

OUT: Redden, McGinnity, Hutchings, Brown
IN: Sheed, Karpany, Adamson, Giles

Yeah, I don't think the Brown to ruck experiment has worked.

 

[ep2018]

Did Schoey injure himself?

 

[Biggie]

Adamson in thanks.

 

[Zuma]

Masto and Redden should find themselves in contention for dropping.

 

[the harry]

Did I hear Gov broke his thumb?

 

[eaglesfan84]

Out: Redden
In: Jetta

They just need to keep rotating these two until one of them puts in a good game.

I don't think they should change a winning team too much.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

I don't think they should change a winning team too much.

I wouldn't call the 22 out there today a 'winning team'.

A 'bunch of losers' seems more appropriate.

 

[Ilkka Sinisalo]

Out: Redden, Masten, Brown, McGinnity
In: Jetta, EMac, Giles, Nelson

Hutchings needs to be better.

 

[Gods_Son23]

OUT: Redden, McGinnity, Hutchings, Brown
IN: Giles, Sheed, Adamson, Nelson

Reward WAFL form.

Just last week Simmo said that Giles was more of a #1 ruck only. So I can't see him playing unless Lycett and Nic were both out.

 

[WCErevival]

Out:
Hutchings or Redden - I'm not seeing what others see here with Hutch. He doesn't give us much. Redden is obviously too good for WAFL but they need to sort him out or drop him
McGinnity - His 4 goals against the Bombers were a one off. Not sure what his role is.
Brown - Should never have been picked to play forward/ruck

In:
Giles
Sheed - Had a poor game yesterday but he was tagged and poor conditions
Karpany - Controversial but he has been playing well in the WAFL

 

[Carbine Chaos]

Just last week Simmo said that Giles was more of a #1 ruck only. So I can't see him playing unless Lycett and Nic were both out.

Giles is more of a number 2 ruck than Mitch bloody Brown.

 

[The Passenger]

Not sure where Duggan and Sheed are with fitness but we've got to get some games into them leading into finals. I'm not convinced Jackson Nelson deserved to be dropped either. We could also do with something a bit more X-factor amongst our smaller blokes instead of the multiple options of vanilla we currently have. Whether that's Jetta (who I'm not even close to being sold on) or someone else I'm not sure, but I think that would add a lot to our team.

McGinnitty, Redden and Hutchings are the obvious ones in the firing line. All really fall into the aforementioned category of vanilla footballers. Masten would be the next in line to get the axe.

McKenzie is struggling a bit for a variety of reasons but we know he is a quality defender and surely he brings more to the team than Brown. In any case it looks like Schofield might have done an injury right on the final siren so that might become a forced changed anyway.

 

[ioppolo]

OUT: Redden, Mcginnity, Hutchings, Emac
IN: Sheed, Duggan, Nelson, Schofield

Emac and Schoey

 

[ChampRevesby]

Giles was BOG against the falcons. Still not sure if he should get a call up.
Out: Redden, Brown
In: Jetta (shuffling the deck chairs on the titanic), Giles

 

[ioppolo]

Serious note

Outs: Redden, McGovern (inj./rest), McGinnity
Ins: Jetta, Emac, Duggan/Sheed/Nelson

 

[random260]

Mcginnity gone for Jetta
Hutchins for sheed/Duggan

Fun over.

 

[ioppolo]

Giles was BOG against the falcons. Still not sure if he should get a call up.
Out: Redden, Giles
In: Jetta (shuffling the deck chairs on the titanic), Brown

Harsh to drop Giles after a BOG performance.

 

[the harry]

Giles is more of a number 2 ruck than Mitch bloody Brown.

Agreed.

He's spent time forward at various times too in his career iirc. Can't be any worse than Brown.

 

[WCErevival]

Just last week Simmo said that Giles was more of a #1 ruck only. So I can't see him playing unless Lycett and Nic were both out.

Put Giles as first ruck and Lycett as the back up. Lycett is decent as a ruck/forward.

 

[Hap Hapablap]

If people still think mcginnity brings anything to the table you have no footy nous. Without a doubt one of the worst players in the league.

Out mcginnity hutch redden

In sheed duggan nelson

Maybe emac for barass or schofield.



Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk