changes v eagles

[ant555]

If there are no injurie problems i could only see one change.
In ev
Out: Houli.

They obviously rate Nash pretty highly to put him in the side after pretty much only half a game with Bendigo so i dont see him being dropped after one game. Houli has had a bit of a taste and has done ok but it is time for him to have a few games back with bendigo to refine a few things he has learnt. Laycock to stay in , the Eagles have two good ruckman and our defence looked well ballanced with Ryder back there all night. Altough Bolts is not in our best 22 he would be unlucky to be dropped on last weeks game.

 

[stander]

Surely he could do a better job than Laycock, he's better around the ground and when wer'e not using him in the ruck, we could even trial him in the forward line.

I like your thinking. Sheedy also needs to think hard this week and come up with something groundbreaking to handle the speedy West Coast rovers. Tagging just won't do it.

 

[kelvin_sheedy]

Very tricky selections this week.

Outs : Houli, Bolton maybe, Laycock maybe, Nash maybe
Ins : Pev, Campo maybe, Bradley Maybe, Lonergan maybe

 

[jhgoat]

bolton didnt kick 10 goals or get BOG - so of course he deserves to be dropped... fools


bolton stays imo - as long as their is a matchup for him

 

[Bombs Away]

In Pev, Campo

Out Houli, Bolton (should never have been there even though did ok, should not promote players who arent going well at BB level)

Close to being selected, Hislop, Lonergan, Cole (if gets of report) and Bradley (another good game on weekend)

 

[bomberstomake8]

Surely he could do a better job than Laycock, he's better around the ground and when wer'e not using him in the ruck, we could even trial him in the forward line.

personally i would like to see laycock dropped.. ryder is extremely mobile for his size and i think could run with cox/seaby.... i would like to see ryder running with cox, make cox very accountable and restrict his influence on the game (what was it 27 possys on the weekend?) ryder probably wont win the hidouts but if he restricts cox's influence to around 10-15 possessions its a win, our hitouts can come when hille beats seaby..

we are probably going to have at least 2 tagging jobs (judd and kerr) so hitouts arent that important anyway seeings our midfeild will be largely defensive.

 

[Jono B]

personally i would like to see laycock dropped.. ryder is extremely mobile for his size and i think could run with cox/seaby.... i would like to see ryder running with cox, make cox very accountable and restrict his influence on the game (what was it 27 possys on the weekend?) ryder probably wont win the hidouts but if he restricts cox's influence to around 10-15 possessions its a win, our hitouts can come when hille beats seaby..

we are probably going to have at least 2 tagging jobs (judd and kerr) so hitouts arent that important anyway seeings our midfeild will be largely defensive.

I would prefer Ryder to run with Seaby as he could probably win a few hitouts to advantage over him. Meanwhile Hille's best attribute is that he nullifies good ruckmen by affecting thier taps. Hille should face Cox.

 

[Burzum]

Out: Houli, Nash
In: Pev, Bradley

 

[jhgoat]

In Pev, Campo

Out Houli, Bolton (should never have been there even though did ok, should not promote players who arent going well at BB level)

Close to being selected, Hislop, Lonergan, Cole (if gets of report) and Bradley (another good game on weekend)

hislop had 14 touches on the weekend.... hes not close! he needs to perform at BB level first

 

[Big John]

Houli needs to go back to the 2's. He's had his taster now he can go back and work on his game. I'd also drop Laycock, not playing well and we don't need Ryder down back as much against the eagles.

Bring in Pev, and Cole probably and i wouldn't be against dropping Bolton for another runner.

Mcveigh to tag Judd

 

[RED AND BLACK SOLDIER]

personally i would like to see laycock dropped.. ryder is extremely mobile for his size and i think could run with cox/seaby.... i would like to see ryder running with cox, make cox very accountable and restrict his influence on the game (what was it 27 possys on the weekend?) ryder probably wont win the hidouts but if he restricts cox's influence to around 10-15 possessions its a win, our hitouts can come when hille beats seaby..

we are probably going to have at least 2 tagging jobs (judd and kerr) so hitouts arent that important anyway seeings our midfeild will be largely defensive.

I think we should stop moving Ryder around and just leave him down back, because when Ryder goes into the ruck, it leaves a huge hole in our defence which i don't like.
Just bring Bradley in, he'll do just the same as Laycock, except do a way better job around the ground.

 

[Shane Hird]

I'm a big fan of Jay Nash,leave him in I say and let him play.


Out: Bachar

In: Pev or Cole

 

[BurnleyBomber]

Bradley will go close to playing, as will Dyson and Camporeale. Pev should come back in, but who goes out could be between a number of players.

Houli, Laycock, Nash and possibly Davey, Monfries and Slattery could be omitted.

I say Davey because his influence on games have gradually decreased since round 1.

Gus needs to add consistency to his game, he's lost too often.

I know Slattery plays defensively but Pev and Heffernan do too and Heff's form could possibly warrant him being selected.

 

[JIM BEAM]

In Pev, Campo

Out Houli, Bolton (should never have been there even though did ok, should not promote players who arent going well at BB level)

Close to being selected, Hislop, Lonergan, Cole (if gets of report) and Bradley (another good game on weekend)

BOLTON CAME IN TO TAG GOODES BECAUSE HE HAS THE HEIGHT AND RUNNING CAPACITY TO GO WITH HIM.
WHEN ARE YOU PEOPLE GOING TO UNDERSTAND ITS NOT ALL ABOUT FORM IN TH VFL IT ALSO COMES DOWN TO MATCH UPS ESPECIALLY AGAINST THE TOP SIDES.
THERE SHOULD BE 5-6 PLAYERS IN EACH VFL SIDE CAPABLE OF DOING A JOB AND STEPPING UP TO THE HIGHEST LEVEL ITS CALLED DEPTH.
IF SHEEDS THINKS BOLTONS FORM WAS UP TO SCRATCH SATURDAY NIGHT AND THERE IS A MATCH UP THERE HE WILL PLAY AGAIN.
FOR ME HOULI OUT PEV OR HISLOP IN

 

[High Ryder]

Lonergan should get a game ahead of Hislop.

 

[jhgoat]

Lonergan should get a game ahead of Hislop.

+ 1

 

[DonMania#5]

In: Camporeale, Peverill
Out: Nash, Houli

 

[RED AND BLACK SOLDIER]

Lonergan should get a game ahead of Hislop.

Agreed, he better get a game this week. I want to see some young talent and see how they are proggressing! Lonergan In for Houli at least. Pev, Bradley other possible ins with Laycock and Bolton making way for them.