Preview Changes v WCE, Sunday 8 June, 320pm, Bunbury WA game (AFL+VFL bye week beforehand)

[Disco Dew]

Ok Sheezel and Wardlaw play VFL then.

I know you’re trying to be hilarious and edgy but if we were a serious football club, they shouldnt be immune from being dropped to the magoos if they’ve been stinking it up in the ones.

 

[chubbspeterson]

3.5 then. he was subbed off at HT

A rest? they've just had 2 weeks off.

I reckon Maley has shown more in his few games, and he's our future more so than Teakle, so I'd rather get more games into him

Ah yeah good point. Forgot about the bye week. Brain is a bit fried this week. Apologies.

Oh for sure. I've liked what I've seen from him. Hope he comes back in, but maybe they've seen enough for a contract.
They'll probably give CCJ some games as well when he hits some decent form to make a call on Teakle vs CCJ.
I don't reckon we need both of them and looking at the list spots, I think one goes for sure imo.

 

[King Hansen]

I know you’re trying to be hilarious and edgy but if we were a serious football club, they should be immune from being dropped to the magoos if they’ve been stinking it up in the ones.

Which midfielder do you drop???

Sheezel and Wardlaw been our 2 worst mids lately.

 

[Disco Dew]

Which midfielder do you drop???

Sheezel and Wardlaw been our 2 worst mids lately.

Wardlaw.

 

[chubbspeterson]

I don’t understand the selection committee.

Cooper is the only one from those in’s who has actually earnt his chance.

I genuinely don’t think our coaches watch the AFL or VFL games. There is no way Logue or RHJ have done enough to earn a recall while Maley never deserved to be omitted. He has been more of a contested marking threat than Darling has been all season.

We are just a ****ing joke all round.

Maley is stiff. WillPhil should've at least been acknowledged on the bench, even if he didn't make the team.
I thought RHJ was sold, got 2 coaches votes, squad mention fine, but not as good as Cooper.
Who would you play with Corr injured then down back, if not Logue?

 

[King Hansen]

I know you’re trying to be hilarious and edgy but if we were a serious football club, they shouldnt be immune from being dropped to the magoos if they’ve been stinking it up in the ones.

LDU is our best mid this year.
Powell best mid in our last game.
Parker in there for leadership and can play forward and kick goals.
Colby and Stephens aren't mids so Phillips isn't taking their spots.
Jy is the captain and been far from bad and is actually have a good consistent year.

This means Wardlaw or Sheezel play in Werribee on Saturday since you want WP in SSSOOOO badly like he's the difference between a win and loss.

 

[Zondor]

I don’t understand the selection committee.

Cooper is the only one from those in’s who has actually earnt his chance.

I genuinely don’t think our coaches watch the AFL or VFL games. There is no way Logue or RHJ have done enough to earn a recall while Maley never deserved to be omitted. He has been more of a contested marking threat than Darling has been all season.

We are just a ****ing joke all round.

Spot On. :stern look

 

[King Hansen]

Wardlaw.

Can you imagine the outrage though????

 

[trooroo4life]

I don’t understand the selection committee.

Cooper is the only one from those in’s who has actually earnt his chance.

I genuinely don’t think our coaches watch the AFL or VFL games. There is no way Logue or RHJ have done enough to earn a recall while Maley never deserved to be omitted. He has been more of a contested marking threat than Darling has been all season.

We are just a ****ing joke all round.

Which defender has? We can’t pick Tomlinson who has been the pick of the defenders in the 2’s for us. Go one short and have LMac defend one of their 197cm+ talls?.

Whitlock isn’t ready. Kal Dawson is a hack. What did you want them to do?. Instead of putting it on the selection committee how about the hack who assembled the list and provided such weak options.

 

[Disco Dew]

since you want WP in SSSOOOO badly like he's the difference between a win and loss.

Never said that. Not sure why you’re so fired up about this. Bit odd really.

 

[chubbspeterson]

Which defender has? We can’t pick Tomlinson who has been the pick of the defenders in the 2’s for us. Go one short and have LMac defend one of their 197cm+ talls?.

Whitlock isn’t ready. Kal Dawson is a hack. What did you want them to do?. Instead of putting it on the selection committee how about the hack who assembled the list and provided such weak options.

It's really a choice between Logue (not thrilled about it), KD (couldn't beat a blind person) or Wawson (moving him down back) or two guys learning a new position in Ford and Duursma. Maybe Finbar down back? Don't think he'd keep up.
Hopefully Corr recovers or you bring in Trembath soon enough when he's comfortable in the system.

 

[My Left Foote]

What the heck does WP have to do

It’s abundantly clear that Clarko doesn’t rate him so he either has to leave the club or ride it out until Clarko gets sacked.

 

[King Hansen]

Never said that. Not sure why you’re so fired up about this. Bit odd really.

Is it though? All I read here is people annoyed WP isn't getting a game.

 

[My Left Foote]

People acting like not selecting WP is like not selecting prime Gary Ablett Jr.

Give it a rest. He's very average.

It’s not about this at all it’s about the fact that we have no selection standards whatsoever. We are selective as to what players are rewarded for good VFL form and selective as to which player’s poor VFL form is irrelevant when it comes to senior selection. Went through this same shit with Brad Scott and Clarko is no different.

 

[King Hansen]

It’s not about this at all it’s about the fact that we have no selection standards whatsoever. We are selective as to what players are rewarded for good VFL form and selective as to which player’s poor VFL form is irrelevant when it comes to senior selection. Went through this same shit with Brad Scott and Clarko is no different.

Not really. Clarko has dropped notable players this year.

 

[King Hansen]

It’s not about this at all it’s about the fact that we have no selection standards whatsoever. We are selective as to what players are rewarded for good VFL form and selective as to which player’s poor VFL form is irrelevant when it comes to senior selection. Went through this same shit with Brad Scott and Clarko is no different.

If you really want standards, he'd drop Wardlaw for WP for example. Would that make you happy?

But I think Wardlaw has more upside and impact. So happy WP misses.

 

[danj]

I know you’re trying to be hilarious and edgy but if we were a serious football club, they shouldnt be immune from being dropped to the magoos if they’ve been stinking it up in the ones.

Mate I agree with you but Luke LDU and Bull are ahead of those guys, even larkey

 

[danj]

It’s not about this at all it’s about the fact that we have no selection standards whatsoever. We are selective as to what players are rewarded for good VFL form and selective as to which player’s poor VFL form is irrelevant when it comes to senior selection. Went through this same shit with Brad Scott and Clarko is no different.

Different real estate portfolios

 

[justroyal]

Yikes. Hard to get up and about with those in’s. Is cooper the likely Mayley replacement?

 

[My Left Foote]

If you really want standards, he'd drop Wardlaw for WP for example. Would that make you happy?

But I think Wardlaw has more upside and impact. So happy WP misses.

For me it’s not about who gets dropped but who gets rewarded for good (VFL) form. I think he’s very selective as to who he rewards, it’s certainly not a meritocracy.

Logue was selected after one very underwhelming game in the VFL earlier this year. He picked Bailey Scott after showing nothing in the VFL recently.

I’m glad Cooper Harvey got picked I think he deserves another go a senior level.

 

[Disco Dew]

Mate I agree with you but Luke LDU and Bull are ahead of those guys, even larkey

Largely agree, though I think bulls been pretty good.

 

[Disco Dew]

It’s not about this at all it’s about the fact that we have no selection standards whatsoever.

 

[Disco Dew]

Anyway, whatever. Hope the campaigners, whoever gets selected, ****ing put in and thump the weagles.
Not sure why I bother with hope but

 

[Shermanator]

Anyway, whatever. Hope the campaigners, whoever gets selected, ****ing put in and thump the weagles.
Not sure why I bother with hope but

 

[Gasometer]

It’s abundantly clear that Clarko doesn’t rate him so he either has to leave the club or ride it out until Clarko gets sacked.

Wat are Adam Simpson’s thoughts?