Charman two weeks

[Cooldude]

Originally posted by phatandphreaky
No, which was my point entirely.

Scarlett got off, and Charman should have as well. In the past, not seeing the POC was enough to have the case thrown out, but that all changed tonight.

Yes, it should've been thrown out, but they found him guilty and gave him weeks. Meaning they were confident that he did punch Deluca, so why didn't he get 3+? More of the length of the penalty that is wrong, rather than whether there was conclusive evidence or not, coz without proper footage, between you and I, both of us know he punched Deluca.

 

[BlueDozer]

Originally posted by The Old Dark Navy's
1. French
2. De Luca
3. Mott
4. Prendergast
5. Err .... umm ...... wow, look at that!! <runs away>

Didn't Callum Beasey fill in the ruck last year at times?

 

[Fall Out Boy]

Originally posted by bucksisbest
DeLuca has to have dobbed him in for this decision to make sense.
The video evidence has to be conclusive for Charman to go and it wasn't .

DeLuca said that Charman merely grabbed his jumper, and also said that the black eye was a result of another incident.

The tribunal chose to label DeLuca a liar and find Charman guilty on the 'balance of probabilities'.

 

[Red_Devil]

Originally posted by The Old Dark Navy's
1. French
2. De Luca
3. Mott
4. Prendergast
5. Err .... umm ...... wow, look at that!! <runs away>

What a ruck devision!

 

[Effes]

Dont Brisbane also have Llane Spandermen to ruck?

198cm beanpole?

 

[SpecialBruce]

Originally posted by Bluemike
Dont Brisbane also have Llane Spandermen to ruck?

198cm beanpole?

He's a long way off.

However having him in this weekend only as a backup ruck and nothing else might be a goer. He can't present himself up forward yet according to reports.

 

[Mead]

Just for the record-

5. Gardiner
4. Cox
3. Seaby
2. Johnson
1. Beeck

Gaspar, Lynch and McDougall can ruck but they're tall kpps rather than actual 'real' ruckmen.

 

[Cat In A Hat]

Originally posted by Mead
Just for the record-

5. Gardiner
4. Cox
3. Seaby
2. Johnson
1. Beeck

Gaspar, Lynch and McDougall can ruck but they're tall kpps rather than actual 'real' ruckmen.

I RECKON JOHNO IS BETTER THAN SEMEN

 

[Mead]

Originally posted by Cat In A Hat
I RECKON JOHNO IS BETTER THAN SEMEN

well, unlike you I haven't tasted both, so I don't think I can comment.

 

[topdon]

And this differs from the Scott/Scott vs Peverill incident in what way?

Oh ... i know ... C.Scott had Peverill in a headlock whilst B.Scott belted him.

 

[Portmanteau]

Brogan
Primus
Lade
Ackland
Thurstans
Bishop

After Primus, they are pretty much crap. Thurstans and Bishop are better in their pinch-hitting roles than Lade, quite sad.

 

[Pevers-Legend]

Originally posted by mark_johnson#1
1. Allan
2. Hille
3. Laycock
4. Bradley
5. Cartledge


seems alright...

Where's Henno or Bolts?

 

[Jimmae]

Two weeks is fair enough:

Going for a punch in the ruck contest - landed on the opponents face instead.

Reckless, but not with intent or malice - hence the decision.

 

[The Mission Man]

Originally posted by Mead
well, unlike you I haven't tasted both, so I don't think I can comment.

So you've either tasted semen or you've tasted Johnno. Don't tell us which. I don't wish to picture either unpleasantry.

 

[coasting]

Originally posted by Mead
Just for the record-

5. Gardiner
4. Cox
3. Seaby
2. Johnson
1. Beeck

Gaspar, Lynch and McDougall can ruck but they're tall kpps rather than actual 'real' ruckmen.

I wouldn't call Johnson a ruckmen either. No natural rucking instincts that I can see. Another tall kpp.

 

[Mead]

Originally posted by The Mission Man
So you've either tasted semen or you've tasted Johnno. Don't tell us which. I don't wish to picture either unpleasantry.

No doubt you were all aquiver when you thought of that, but personally I'd say that although 'both' might mean the two together, having not tasted 'both' doesn't necessarily imply that I've tasted one.

But hey, whatever does it for you, young mish. Go on, say something about Cox, I double dare ya.

 

[Mead]

Originally posted by coasting
I wouldn't call Johnson a ruckmen either. No natural rucking instincts that I can see. Another tall kpp.

iirc, he rucked during his TAC cup days. He's more a ruckman that we've converted to a KPP than a KPP who can be used as a ruckman.

 

[nonchalance]

Originally posted by Pevers-Legend
Where's Henno or Bolts?

Yep. According to Sheedy, we'd have:

1. Allan
2. Hille
3. Henneman
4. Bradley
5. Laycock
6. Cartledge

Happy with that, actually - especially after seeing some of the other lists.

Bradley's the only first year player in that list, and Henneman's the only one who is a KPP used in the ruck rather than a real ruckman - although the jury's certainly still out on Bradley.