Collingwood clearly need a ruckman

[daics cousin]

The problem with hudson is although a reasonably good player he has just come off a serious knee injury.I would like him at collingwood but would not trade didak for him.
dids is a game breaker and he is worth at least 2 first round picks nothing less.
But i seriously doubt whether we will trade him..
Meeson is worth zilch beacuse he is totally unproven.was a top pick in the 2004 draft but has hardly played a senior game?Why ?
Maric would be a better prospect.

 

[Crowked]

The problem with hudson is although a reasonably good player he has just come off a serious knee injury.I would like him at collingwood but would not trade didak for him.
dids is a game breaker and he is worth at least 2 first round picks nothing less.
But i seriously doubt whether we will trade him..
Meeson is worth zilch beacuse he is totally unproven.was a top pick in the 2004 draft but has hardly played a senior game?Why ?
Maric would be a better prospect.

All due respect but Hudson played a whole season since he did his knee, and shown no signs he's falling to bits. Actually he's looked as though he never did it.

I dont think anyone is really thinking Didak will be traded. I certainly dont anyway.

Meesen isnt worth zilch. He will attract a lot of interest.

 

[Geoffa32]

Didak will only leave the Pies if he wants out of Melbourne...this means Pies have to trade or have a disgruntled player on list...If the rumours are crap he is Magpie for at least the next few years...This is where a trade for Meesan comes in.

 

[scooter600x]

Hudson and Kmac are not worth a pick 5....

But to the Bulldogs they are...pick five is not going to get them in finals next year..

It will be 2010 one day.

 

[PrideOf]

It will be 2010 one day.

Ah yes, the Terry Wallace principle.