Collingwood vs Adelaide thread

[Benno_900]

I cant see who else is going to get dropped when Thompson and the rest come back.

He's doing enough to earn another game. Doesn't have to be a like-for-like change.

 

[Souup]

Should have stayed with Vince..

Ah well, only round 1.

 

[AjsGuns]

Petrenko playing a solid game. Shouldnt be dropped .... yet.

 

[DerpWerls]

Goodwin off

 

[BluesMan]

Need Bock to lift his game, i want 90!

 

[Deenamite]

Was hoping for more from Bock.

 

[Souup]

Lockyer 94
Otten 69 (Emerg for Anthony)
Mackay 58 (Give him more TOG please)

Good enough.. players got about what i'd expect from thier prices.

 

[Hodges]

Happy with that result. Got what I expected out of Bock, Hentschel and Otten. Mackay did alright, was hoping for 70. Walker faded in and out of the game, but looks the goods.

Great game though, high skills throughout.

 

[samwise]

edwards you gun love unique picks paying off. goodwin shoulda owned donna why he didnt maybe cuz mcleod didnt get tagged

 

[DT_fanatic]

Swan captain.
Didak will have better days i reckon.
Petrenko surely did enough for another game? played forward and back so doesn't necessarily have to be replaced for Johncock.
Pissed that I didnt pick up Vince. He's going to avg 90+ easy this year imo. Shuda gone with him instead of Mclean or Selwood.

 

[Lakey91]

Goodwin = 86
Cloke = 69
Otten = 69

Walker = 37 (emer)

I just would of wanted 15-20 more overall, but thats life. Cloke was horrible and still notched 70ish, so i am happy. Last 2 years this would of been a 30-50 id reckon.

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

Swan captain.
Didak will have better days i reckon.
Petrenko surely did enough for another game? played forward and back so doesn't necessarily have to be replaced for Johncock.
Pissed that I didnt pick up Vince. He's going to avg 90+ easy this year imo. Shuda gone with him instead of Mclean or Selwood.

I cant believe your happy! Your team just lost.

YEWWWWWWWWWWW GO YOU CROWSSS!!

Swanny as captain too Pendles came back sharp - and Petrenko (dont have him) will get a Rising Star Nomination.

 

[sdsdsdsd]

Just the 3 in that game

Vince - 131
Swan - 115
Walker - 37 (bench)

Not a bad first round

 

[Saint KFC]

Swan 115 (C)
Lockyer 94
Didak 88
Otten 69

Walker 39 (emg)

Happy with that.

 

[DT_fanatic]

I cant believe your happy! Your team just lost.

YEWWWWWWWWWWW GO YOU CROWSSS!!

Swanny as captain too Pendles came back sharp - and Petrenko (dont have him) will get a Rising Star Nomination.

Not happy at all. But I try to keep the DT and club emotions separate lol. Trust me I was devastated when that siren went. And to think I cheered Petrenko's goal thinking we had it in the bag...

so you reckon petrenko will play next week? id assume that given what u've said but he was all but gone for next week until his effort today..

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

Not happy at all. But I try to keep the DT and club emotions separate lol. Trust me I was devastated when that siren went. And to think I cheered Petrenko's goal thinking we had it in the bag...

so you reckon petrenko will play next week? id assume that given what u've said but he was all but gone for next week until his effort today..

Naww ok haha. Yeah I try and do that too but if I had a loss like that I would probably express it lol.
Yeah I thought you fellaz had it in the bag too - and I had a feeling we were gonna lose!

Yeah I rekon Petrenko will play next week, his hardness and agression was just awesome. I thought that Johncock would of replaced him, but we cant drop him after a preformance like that. Nab Rising Star Nominee
I dont think any of our youngsters deserve to be dropped next week after there preformace today. Walker was probably the worse out of all of them!

Do you rekon Beams is a lock for next week?

 

[swans4eva]

Very happy with this game, all expectations exceeded
Expectation before game in brackets

Pendlebury 119 (100)
Swan 115 (110)
Otten 69 lol (60)
Hentschel 46 (40-50)
Thomas 81 (80)

Reserves
Petrenko 66 (50)
Walker 37 (35)

Pretty solid effort to go with my excellent game last night (travis Tuck )

 

[AjsGuns]

Naww ok haha. Yeah I try and do that too but if I had a loss like that I would probably express it lol.
Yeah I thought you fellaz had it in the bag too - and I had a feeling we were gonna lose!

Yeah I rekon Petrenko will play next week, his hardness and agression was just awesome. I thought that Johncock would of replaced him, but we cant drop him after a preformance like that. Nab Rising Star Nominee
I dont think any of our youngsters deserve to be dropped next week after there preformace today. Walker was probably the worse out of all of them!

Do you rekon Beams is a lock for next week?

Who do u think will be dropped for Thompson + Johncock + Symes?
Imo it would be Cook + Walker with Symes missing out?
Curious to see what you think.

 

[Benno_900]

Do you rekon Beams is a lock for next week?

Don't think Beams played for the reserves today. Sidebottom was one of their best.

 

[DT_fanatic]

Naww ok haha. Yeah I try and do that too but if I had a loss like that I would probably express it lol.
Yeah I thought you fellaz had it in the bag too - and I had a feeling we were gonna lose!

Yeah I rekon Petrenko will play next week, his hardness and agression was just awesome. I thought that Johncock would of replaced him, but we cant drop him after a preformance like that. Nab Rising Star Nominee
I dont think any of our youngsters deserve to be dropped next week after there preformace today. Walker was probably the worse out of all of them!

Do you rekon Beams is a lock for next week?

Sweet. Need him with Raines and probably Hodge out. Broughton is the other reserve I have

Well given that we lost today there will be pressure on Malthouse to play Beams. Ben Johnson I thought played OK but didn't provide much. Always pressure on his spot so I wouldn't be surprised if he got dropped.

 

[Saint KFC]

Guess I'm the only person who wasn't all that impressed by Petrenko.