Confirmed mike sheehan

[blues1985]

4 weeks ago said chris judd was not in the top ten players in the comp which confirmed his status as an over paid nuff nuff?

 

[true blue19]

it really sux when u start a tread and nobody write in it. so i thought i would write something.

 

[blues4flag]

it really sux when u start a tread and nobody write in it. so i thought i would write something.

I believe the correct phrase is "sympathy post".

 

[Crippa#9]

I totally agree.

Mike unfortunately rates potential or perception over the raw facts such as rating Cyril Riloi aheahd of Judd.

Cyril is a wonderful young player who will be a top 10 player but there is simply no evidence or facts to suggest he is a better, more influential player than Judd.

Mike, time & tme again, fails to look at the 'serious' stats such as who is the player in the competition that is the Number 1 contested possesssion gatherer? There's a job for you Mike..do some proper journalism work and let us know.

 

[HBF]

Hopefully Mike was at the 'G on Saturday afternoon. Another sublime effort by the skipper. Not a bad effort given he had about 4 different taggers on him, and he got that much contested footy.

Time for Mike to re-evaluate things.

 

[krayfesh]

Yeah.

Up yours, Mike.

 

[OnceWeWereKings]

Backed up by his mate Scott Gullan writing The Tackle in the Herald Sun today. Could not find Judd a spot in the All Australian team, had Cooney in front of Judd.

I know the stats are not everything, but can someone out there throw up a Cooney Vs Judd comparison in 2010 ?.

 

[Jabba73]

You needed further confirmation Sheehan is a nuff nuff?

 

[serenityNow]

Mike Sheahan is a deadshit, and not worthy of a thread.

 

[The Toad]

Mike Sheahan needs his arse removed.

 

[Jabba73]

Mike Sheahan needs his arse removed.

Don't do that ....... there will be nothing left.

On second thoughts ..................

 

[zeeCFC]

the tackle on the herald has left out Judd from their AA side.
Selwood and Montagna are nowhere near the level of Judd/Ablett ....the Essendon PR newspaper is a joke!

 

[NWTYRX]

Their reasoning behind his exclusion was that he missed the first 3 games

Rubbish

 

[KoutoufidesGhost]

Backed up by his mate Scott Gullan writing The Tackle in the Herald Sun today. Could not find Judd a spot in the All Australian team, had Cooney in front of Judd.

I know the stats are not everything, but can someone out there throw up a Cooney Vs Judd comparison in 2010 ?.

I love stats, so here you go. I should preface with I think Cooney should be AA too, Pendlebury was the one in Gullan's team that I don't think will make it. The selectors normally overlook a player's first breakout season (see Marc Murphy last year).

I think the stats show that Judd shades Cooney in most areas, and smashes him in a couple.


Chris Judd (17 games)
Kicks - 14.5
Handballs - 12.6
Marks - 3.2
Disposal Efficiency % - 68.8
Tackles - 5.3
Goals - 13.7
Goal Assists - 13
Clearances - 6.3
Contested Possessions - 12.0
Inside 50s - 5.1


Adam Cooney (19 games)
K - 13.8
H/B - 13.3
M - 4.1
DE% - 70.3
T - 3.2
G - 9.12
GA - 18
CL - 5.1
CP - 9.3
I50 - 4.4

 

[Team Mo']

Since when was this ever "unconfirmed?"

 

[OnceWeWereKings]

I love stats, so here you go. I should preface with I think Cooney should be AA too, Pendlebury was the one in Gullan's team that I don't think will make it. The selectors normally overlook a player's first breakout season (see Marc Murphy last year).

I think the stats show that Judd shades Cooney in most areas, and smashes him in a couple.


Chris Judd (17 games)
Kicks - 14.5
Handballs - 12.6
Marks - 3.2
Disposal Efficiency % - 68.8
Tackles - 5.3
Goals - 13.7
Goal Assists - 13
Clearances - 6.3
Contested Possessions - 12.0
Inside 50s - 5.1


Adam Cooney (19 games)
K - 13.8
H/B - 13.3
M - 4.1
DE% - 70.3
T - 3.2
G - 9.12
GA - 18
CL - 5.1
CP - 9.3
I50 - 4.4