Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. Contracts. Trades. Draft. Other Assorted Crap. 2020 Edition

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

It should be noted that, with the Daniher and Williams compensation, our first round pick which Geelong has this year has slid to 15.

Are people still regretting the Kelly trade? Do some on here seriously think Geelong would be satisfied with pick 15 for Clark?
 
Silly me! I thought this was the trade/draft thread. Can the fruit/ meat/poultry discussion please piss off somewhere else. None of it is either funny or clever
I felt like that for days too. Now I've had 4 bourbons, I decided to join in.
Good to hear from a long standing member.
 
Silly me! I thought this was the trade/draft thread. Can the fruit/ meat/poultry discussion please piss off somewhere else. None of it is either funny or clever
How about we give this unfunny joke a rest?
Its right up there with posting Gee on anything to do with Venables and putting Jack Watts as a poll option as embarrassing crap just clogging up threads.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Everyone still seething we gave way to much for Kelly but that first round pick of our just keeps getting worse and worse.

Currently 15, with Crouch compo will push out to 16 and with Academy and F&S likely out to 20+

So let’s just call it 20 for the moment.

We gave pick 16,27 & 38 last year.

So we gave them 16,20,27 & 38 in two average drafts.

If you take out the pick we have from Geelong which I think will be mid 50’s or lower after academy clusters it’s around 2900 draft points.

Collingwood gave up picks 8, 9 and 65 for Treloar and got back pick 33. Essentially they paid 2547 points for Treloar.

Essendon gave up picks 11 and 14 and got back pick 42. Essentially 2100 points for Shiel.

So we essentially gave the equivalent of pick 45 more than Collingwood did for Treloar and pick 24 more than Essendon did for Shiel.

Hardly selling the farm.

I don’t know about everyone else but I’ll take Tim Kelly over those four picks and those two players any day of the week.
 
Last edited:
Everyone still seething we gave way to much for Kelly but that first round pick of our just keeps getting worse and worse.

Currently 15, with Crouch compo will push out to 16 and with Academy and F&S likely out to 20+

So let’s just call it 20 for the moment.

We gave pick 16,27 & 38 last year.

So we gave them 16,20,27
& 38 in two average drafts.

If you take out the pick we have from Geelong which I think will be mid 50’s or lower after academy clusters it’s around 2900 draft points.

Collingwood gave up picks 8, 9 and 65 for Treloar and got back pick 33. Essentially they paid 2547 points for Treloar.

Essendon gave up picks 11 and 14 and got back pick 42. Essentially 2100 points for Shiel.

So we essentially gave the equivalent of pick 45 more than Collingwood did for Treloar and pick 24 more than Essendon did for Shiel.

Hardly selling the farm.

I don’t know about everyone else but I’ll take Tim Kelly over those four picks and those two players any day of the week.
pick 24 would have rivers on our list right now
 
If we had kept pick 24 and we had finished top four where we were expected to finish then we would have been paying unders for Kelly. I agree we gave a little more than we needed to but I don’t buy into the “we sold our future” nonsense.

Our second round pick is more of a reflection of what we should have kept.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top