Cooney or Walker

[Kade Simps]

Who would you pick at this stage of their career?

 

[Neutral_observer]

GEE I WONDER


Conney easily. Sure he is soft and will never be a leader, but he is a gamebreaker

Walker is simply a dud


But Mclean is better than both, so who cares

 

[gandaal]

GEE I WONDER


Conney easily. Sure he is soft and will never be a leader, but he is a gamebreaker

Walker is simply a dud


But Mclean is better than both, so who cares

Shouldn't you be doing your homework? Your mommy is going to be upset.

 

[Top Dog]

But Mclean is better than both, so who cares

McLean will never, ever play a game like Cooney's today.

McLean may end up being more consistent, but as I have said many times on here, I wouldn't swap him for any one else taken in his draft. This includes McLean.

Cooney could be anything, and will be by far the best, most damaging player out of the 2003 draft.

 

[mark73]

McLean will never, ever play a game like Cooney's today.

McLean may end up being more consistent, but as I have said many times on here, I wouldn't swap him for any one else taken in his draft. This includes McLean.

Cooney could be anything, and will be by far the best, most damaging player out of the 2003 draft.

Its early days to be THAT confident, some of his lows are pretty low.But he is right up there no doubt about it.Part of the Bulldogs biggest worry in years to come will be hanging on to him.


PS - Is he still living in Altona Meadows? Could've sworn I saw him leaving Karingal golf course last wednesday.

 

[Art Vandelay]

Cooney every day of the week.

 

[wizzard74]

cooney by far but walker will have a standout season next year]

 

[Neutral_observer]

McLean will never, ever play a game like Cooney's today.

McLean may end up being more consistent, but as I have said many times on here, I wouldn't swap him for any one else taken in his draft. This includes McLean.

Cooney could be anything, and will be by far the best, most damaging player out of the 2003 draft.

Might wanna check out Brocks game today

You really have poor timing

 

[Sylvia Saint]

Might wanna check out Brocks game today

You really have poor timing

36 touches, but the scary thing is this.... he ain't even 100% fit (hence the extended time he spends on the bench).

McLean for PM.

And for the record Cooney is twice as good as Walker. But Brock > All.

 

[MrAaron]

Cooney quite easily. Ask again in 2008

 

[Donsforever]

Cooney

 

[SIR SAINT HOTDOG]

Cooney by a long way

 

[Patty#32]

COONEY.. see his game yesterday haha freak

 

[Top Dog]

Might wanna check out Brocks game today

You really have poor timing

Give me 33 touches, 6 tackles, 2 clearances & 5 goals any day of the week.

You really have poor judgement.

 

[Top Dog]

36 touches, but the scary thing is this.... he ain't even 100% fit (hence the extended time he spends on the bench).

McLean for PM.

And for the record Cooney is twice as good as Walker. But Brock > All.

Nor is Cooney.

Has carried a groin problem, rumoured to be OP, for the last 8 or so weeks.

 

[Neutral_observer]

Give me 33 touches, 6 tackles, 2 clearances & 5 goals any day of the week.

You really have poor judgement.

Give me contested possession, toughess, leadership, clearances and the next captain of the MFC any day of the week

 

[Sylvia Saint]

Give me contested possession, toughess, leadership, clearances and the next captain of the MFC any day of the week

McLean could prove to be as good as the Dogs very own Scott West.

 

[Upgrayedd]

cooney

 

[Neutral_observer]

McLean could prove to be as good as the Dogs very own Scott West.

he is better already

 

[Top Dog]

he is better already

Hahahahahahahahah

McLean isn't worthy to polish Westy's Diadora boots, let alone be mentioned in the same breath as the great man.

 

[Neutral_observer]

Hahahahahahahahah

McLean isn't worthy to polish Westy's Diadora boots, let alone be mentioned in the same breath as the great man.

Disagree


West really isnt that good mate. Sorry to break it to you. he is the king of cheap possession, and has little impact on games


Its not hard to win so many best and fairests in a team that never makes the Finals

 

[Benno From Berwick]

Disagree


West really isnt that good mate. Sorry to break it to you. he is the king of cheap possession, and has little impact on games


Its not hard to win so many best and fairests in a team that never makes the Finals

Oh dear. How do you get it so wrong so often.

 

[Kade Simps]

Disagree


West really isnt that good mate. Sorry to break it to you. he is the king of cheap possession, and has little impact on games


Its not hard to win so many best and fairests in a team that never makes the Finals

What a shocking thing to say, West is an absolute superstar. does the job week in week out and is one of the most consistently incredible players in the league!

 

[Bulldog1954]

Disagree


West really isnt that good mate. Sorry to break it to you. he is the king of cheap possession, and has little impact on games


Its not hard to win so many best and fairests in a team that never makes the Finals

You really have no idea, West has won 7 best a nd fairests, four of those years we played finals. If McLean has a career anywhere near Scott Wests you should be absolutely delerious

 

[Neutral_observer]

You really have no idea, West has won 7 best a nd fairests, four of those years we played finals. If McLean has a career anywhere near Scott Wests you should be absolutely delerious

All signs say McLean will be twice the player of West