Create a 'Worst 18' using one spud from each club

[Rainfall]

Those two good games Butcher played back in 2011 are two more good games than Josh Walker has ever played. Now there's an underrated spud.

Walker played two good games against Norf n Hawks

 

[Starburns_]

WHAT?!

I didn't want to go with the obvious answer of Zac Dawson, so I picked a guy who's even worse.

Geez this thread would've been derailed if Shoenmakers had been traded.

Nah, then we would've just used Rioli.

 

[JoseMourinho]

I didn't want to go with the obvious answer of Zac Dawson, so I picked a guy who's even worse.



Nah, then we would've just used Rioli.

I would have expected Colon Sylvia, Chris Mayne, Danyle Pearce or Zac Clarke ahead of Silvagni! Didn't think he was that bad.

 

[Bender_]

I would have expected Colon Sylvia, Chris Mayne, Danyle Pearce or Zac Clarke ahead of Silvagni! Didn't think he was that bad.

He's terrible dude.

 

[JoseMourinho]

He's terrible dude.

Ok . I think he is average.

 

[Starburns_]

I would have expected Colon Sylvia, Chris Mayne, Danyle Pearce or Zac Clarke ahead of Silvagni! Didn't think he was that bad.

Forgot about Pearce and Clark, the others were pretty obvious. That said, Silvagni is horrible.

 

[jacko57]

Season's greetings campaigners.



Your task is to compile a side full of your favourite shit trucks and soft boiled potatoes with one from each club.


R:

OK, let me see : Shannon Byrnes, Cam Pedersen, Chris Dawes.....oh, wait, is that what you had in mind?

 

[jacko57]

B: Tony Armstrong (Coll), Zac Dawson (Freo), Ryan Schoenmakers (Haw)
HB: Sam Gilbert (StK), Matthew Watson (Carl), Matt Shaw (GC)
C: Kane Mitchell (PA), Jordie McKenzie (Melb), Kane Lucas (WCE)
HF: Nick Kommer (Ess), James Podsiadly (Adel), Dylan Addison (GWS, genuinely thought he'd been delisted)
F: Luke McGuane (Bris), Josh Walker (Geel), Jarrad Grant (WB)
R: Tom Derickx (Syd), Ben Jacobs (NM), Taylor Hunt (Rich)

Ben Jacobs for captain-coach?

 

[Sprout]

OK, let me see : Shannon Byrnes, Cam Pedersen, Chris Dawes.....oh, wait, is that what you had in mind?

No, especially since Byrnes is retired. Silly jacko.

Similarly, Robin Nahas, Aaron Black, Magic Door and Shaun Atlol in the same team would also not qualify.

 

[Whit3y]

lock jordie mckenzie in

a shoe in

 

[Vikingblood]

No, especially since Byrnes is retired. Silly jacko.

Similarly, Robin Nahas, Aaron Black, Magic Door and Shaun Atlol in the same team would also not qualify.

Not sure Magic Door will be around to press his case for selection in this team or any other.

 

[MAXIMUM GRUNDAGE]

lock jordie mckenzie in

a shoe in

So bad that even us Melbourne fans forgot he was still listed. Good call!

 

[MAXIMUM GRUNDAGE]

Watson of Carlton in the middle, spoiled a superb effort. Curnow, Armfield and Ellard have all played in the guts for Carlolton.

Noted and fixed. Ellard in for Watson, although I wish McLean was still listed.

 

[Barry_Badrinath]

If your selection for Richmond is anyone other than Shaun Hampson you have absolutely no idea about football.

 

[Barry_Badrinath]

Derickx is a worse ruckman than Hampson, as well as coming from a club without too many other massive spuds to pick from (unlike Richmond). And give it time, you'll see how shit Taylor Hunt is soon enough.

Derickx plays for Sydney, so you can just plonk Hampson in the forwardline.

 

[jacko57]

No, especially since Byrnes is retired. Silly jacko.

Similarly, Robin Nahas, Aaron Black, Magic Door and Shaun Atlol in the same team would also not qualify.

'Shaun Atlol'. Really? You spent time working on that, and that was the best you could manage?

Poor Sproutlol.

 

[MightyHawks]

B Cheney (A) Schoenmakers (H) Siposs (St)
HB Gwilt (E) Tape (GC) Goodes (WB)
C Bewick (B) Ellard (Ca) Rohan (Sy)
HF Blease (G) Waite (NM) Hill (WC)
F Lloyd (R) Karnezis (Co) Butcher (PA)
Foll Spencer (M) Sylvia (F) (c) Scully (GWS)

Don't think you've missed any former Demons there

You know your spuds

 

[Sprout]

'Shaun Atlol'. Really? You spent time working on that, and that was the best you could manage?

Poor Sproutlol.

I'll just stick with "Shatley" then. Atlol seems to cut too close to the bone

 

[MAXIMUM GRUNDAGE]

Don't think you've missed any former Demons there

You know your spuds

Can't help it if other clubs love picking up our rejects.
Martin, Bennell, Thompson, Petterd, Frawley, Clark and Rivers all got reprieves.

 

[razaxp360]

B: Tony Armstrong (Coll), Zac Dawson (Freo), Ryan Schoenmakers (Haw)
HB: Sam Gilbert (StK), Matthew Watson (Carl), Matt Shaw (GC)
C: Kane Mitchell (PA), Jordie McKenzie (Melb), Kane Lucas (WCE)
HF: Nick Kommer (Ess), James Podsiadly (Adel), Dylan Addison (GWS, genuinely thought he'd been delisted)
F: Luke McGuane (Bris), Josh Walker (Geel), Jarrad Grant (WB)
R: Tom Derickx (Syd), Ben Jacobs (NM), Taylor Hunt (Rich)

Rofl, think you left out John Butcher (which would make that 2 spuds) which is kind of embarrassing for a team who considers itself to be favorites for the premiership next year.

 

[Hollins]

I think Nick Holland is a disgrace to HFC and the worst character ever to pull on our jumper.
Shittruck player also...utter slagend.

 

[MightyHawks]

Can't help it if other clubs love picking up our rejects.
Martin, Bennell, Thompson, Petterd, Frawley, Clark and Rivers all got reprieves.

Only one former Demon per club though...

 

[MAXIMUM GRUNDAGE]

Only one former Demon per club though...

Then there was still room for Martin, Bennell, Petterd and Frawley.

 

[jedi mind tricks]

B: Tony Armstrong (Coll), Zac Dawson (Freo), Ryan Schoenmakers (Haw)
HB: Sam Gilbert (StK), Matthew Watson (Carl), Matt Shaw (GC)
C: Kane Mitchell (PA), Jordie McKenzie (Melb), Kane Lucas (WCE)
HF: Nick Kommer (Ess), James Podsiadly (Adel), Dylan Addison (GWS, genuinely thought he'd been delisted)
F: Luke McGuane (Bris), Josh Walker (Geel), Jarrad Grant (WB)
R: Tom Derickx (Syd), Ben Jacobs (NM), Taylor Hunt (Rich)

Zac Dawson surely you jest?

 

[Kangaroos4eva]

Walker played two good games against Norf n Hawks

Spuds love playing norf. Lol norf.