Remove this Banner Ad

Game Day Crows Vs Dockers night game, no chance of fog.

Who wins?

  • Adelaide

    Votes: 34 54.0%
  • Fremantle

    Votes: 29 46.0%

  • Total voters
    63

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

So far the season has gone

Nicks vs coaches he has a >30% win rate against: 4-0

Nicks vs coaches he has a <30% win rate against: 0-2

20% win rate against Longmuir. It's time for Nicks to start winning against a broader range of coaches
If we lose tonight, sack him straight away before the season is wasted?
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Has regularly given Tex a bath in previous matches.
It will be interesting as Thilthorpe is a different problem than Tex. Tex while no less strong is quite a bit shorter than Thilthorpe who excels at marking the ball at its apex so Pearce is going to need 3rd man up support as if its one v one, Thilthorpe might be too hard to contain.
 
I'll be there with an honorary Crows supporting friend to take away 2 seats worth of home ground advantage.

I read somewhere that when there hasn't been a sitting Pope, Freo have never won a game and the Crows have never lost one. I think that would have to be a pretty small sample space.

For another small sample space, the only other time I have attended a Crows/Freo game we kicked ten times their score for a 19.16.130 to 1.7.13 drubbing. Hoping for a similar result!

Feeling pretty pumped about now.
 
It will be interesting to see where Alex Pearce plays.

Tex has trouble with him and Balta. Perhaps Tex is a decoy, lead him up the ground so TT and Rachele can work together? If Pearce goes to TT then Tex should be able to get hold of Cox and/or Draper.

OPTUS (I hate stadiums with sponsor names) stadium is a bit like the MCG so I think it suits us somewhat, especially players like Keays, Rachele, Rankine, Cumming, Draper can use their leg speed/hard running to stretch the ground.

We go all right there but never beaten Freo, although we were subjected to a Pyke 2018 half time pep talk and Burton dished out some more hamstring awareness.

In 2024 we were in the depths of our 0-4 Zombieball strategy.

Should be good, Crows win if we kick straight.
 
It will be interesting as Thilthorpe is a different problem than Tex. Tex while no less strong is quite a bit shorter than Thilthorpe who excels at marking the ball at its apex so Pearce is going to need 3rd man up support as if its one v one, Thilthorpe might be too hard to contain.
I wouldn’t be counting out Curtin as an offensive threat. His leading and marking are actually very impressive, and playing in front of his family and friends, and being given licence to play closer to goal, I could easily see him with 3 or 4 majors.
 
I wouldn’t be counting out Curtin as an offensive threat. His leading and marking are actually very impressive, and playing in front of his family and friends, and being given licence to play closer to goal, I could easily see him with 3 or 4 majors.
It would be well within his ability to do that and it will only serve to make the WA sides come extra hard after him unfortunately imo. As I noted previously, I just wish we had already secured him on a very long term deal as if he does start to fire, its only going to get much harder to do and much more expensive if we can do it.
 
If we lose tonight, sack him straight away before the season is wasted?

Look I will always support sacking Nicks, so yes

So far the season has gone largely as expected. St Kilda, Essendon and North all relatively poor teams and should have been pencilled in as wins before the season. None of those teams/coaches have (or should have) troubled Nicks all that much

Gold Coast and Geelong, coached by two coaches Nicks has struggled against, lost both of those. Roughly on par with expectations.

I had us winning one of the GWS or Fremantle games, leaning towards GWS due to Nicks better record against Kingsley vs Longmuir.

So if we beat Fremantle tonight we would be one win ahead of expectations.

Following that throughout the rest of the season I think the expectations are us beating Carlton, Port Adelaide, West Coast and Richmond. Similarly, losing to Collingwood, Brisbane, Hawthorn, Bulldogs. And a couple of question marks over teams like Sydney and Melbourne (Nicks poor record vs those teams poor form).

Applying that to the season I'd have us somewhere around 11-13 wins heading into North Melbourne in the final round which is a really dangerous game. Wouldn't want us needing that win to make finals, weight of expectations and so on.

Basically I want to see us do more than just match expectations. This is not a game I expect a coach like Nicks to win, similar to how I don't expect him to beat Collingwood at the MCG. Even though I believe the team itself, the players, are good enough to beat Fremantle. Winning those sorts of games goes a long way to proving Nicks is better than we all think he is, and that as a team we are projecting to be better than a fringe finals chance.

Lose our three upcoming tests (Fremantle away, Collingwood away, Sydney away) and heading into games against Brisbane and Hawthorn... Nicks would be basically cooked at the bye
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Look I will always support sacking Nicks, so yes

So far the season has gone largely as expected. St Kilda, Essendon and North all relatively poor teams and should have been pencilled in as wins before the season. None of those teams/coaches have (or should have) troubled Nicks all that much

Gold Coast and Geelong, coached by two coaches Nicks has struggled against, lost both of those. Roughly on par with expectations.

I had us winning one of the GWS or Fremantle games, leaning towards GWS due to Nicks better record against Kingsley vs Longmuir.

So if we beat Fremantle tonight we would be one win ahead of expectations.

Following that throughout the rest of the season I think the expectations are us beating Carlton, Port Adelaide, West Coast and Richmond. Similarly, losing to Collingwood, Brisbane, Hawthorn, Bulldogs. And a couple of question marks over teams like Sydney and Melbourne (Nicks poor record vs those teams poor form).

Applying that to the season I'd have us somewhere around 11-13 wins heading into North Melbourne in the final round which is a really dangerous game. Wouldn't want us needing that win to make finals, weight of expectations and so on.

Basically I want to see us do more than just match expectations. This is not a game I expect a coach like Nicks to win, similar to how I don't expect him to beat Collingwood at the MCG. Even though I believe the team itself, the players, are good enough to beat Fremantle. Winning those sorts of games goes a long way to proving Nicks is better than we all think he is, and that as a team we are projecting to be better than a fringe finals chance.

Lose our three upcoming tests (Fremantle away, Collingwood away, Sydney away) and heading into games against Brisbane and Hawthorn... Nicks would be basically cooked at the bye
When you couple that with the unreal injury run, the quality of our side and we should be where we are at a minimum.

People look at the improvement from last years shit show and think we’ve done well, we’ve done par.
 
When you couple that with the unreal injury run, the quality of our side and we should be where we are at a minimum.

People look at the improvement from last years shit show and think we’ve done well, we’ve done par.
People can’t seriously be discussing sacking a coach 6 games into a season when they sit 4 and 2. Even more so when you consider we could easily have won both losses as well.

I get some people don’t like Nicks but come on.
 
Let's make a board pact not to mention you know what

6. McAsey, 7. Young, 8. Serong

Freo storm to early 5-goal lead. Crows claw it back over the next three quarters, but kick horrifically inaccurately. Gain lead with a minute to go, but Serong bursts from the stoppage and lays it off to Young, who delivers perfect pass into the 50.

It is marked by Oscar McDonald, inexplicably kicking his fifth goal to claim the victory for Fremantle and Callum Chambers prize for himself.

Final Score: Fremantle 11.8.74, Adelaide 9.18.72.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

People can’t seriously be discussing sacking a coach 6 games into a season when they sit 4 and 2. Even more so when you consider we could easily have won both losses as well.

I get some people don’t like Nicks but come on.
I’m not saying he should be sacked now, I’m saying the club or anyone sit here and think he’s done a great job.

Winning a final has to be a minimum.

We don’t want another Hinkley and we are already 6 years and he’s demonstrated time and again shit judgement.
 
People can’t seriously be discussing sacking a coach 6 games into a season when they sit 4 and 2. Even more so when you consider we could easily have won both losses as well.

I get some people don’t like Nicks but come on.

He hasn't done enough yet either way. Not enough disaster losses to be sacked, not enough impressive wins to put his position beyond doubt. As far as I see it, he's in limbo
 
I’m not saying he should be sacked now, I’m saying the club or anyone sit here and think he’s done a great job.

Winning a final has to be a minimum.

We don’t want another Hinkley and we are already 6 years and he’s demonstrated time and again shit judgement.

It has to be winning a final as the measuring stick. Last year was the finals making year and he survived by the injury excuse. No worries, that’s done. But it doesn’t mean the expectations are delayed by a full season.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Game Day Crows Vs Dockers night game, no chance of fog.

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top