Remove this Banner Ad

Oppo Camp Dangerfield's Gone (Zero tolerance to trolling) - READ THREAD LINKED IN OP BEFORE POSTING

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

If we don't match it would want to be one hell of a side deal we've lined up
Waste of time .....won't get AFL approval ...and FFS after Tippetgate why would the club do anything remotely controversial that will raise the ire of the other AFL clubs :confused:
 
Kane McGoodwin .....Kane am i dumb or does this article just not compute

AFL trade period 2015: Your club-by-club guide
Date
October 4, 2015 - 7:36PM

    • ADELAIDE

      Who's in play?

      Everything revolves around the Patrick Dangerfield situation. The Crows need to get maximum compensation for a franchise player. A potential deal with Geelong could involve the two clubs agreeing to trade without the Crows officially matching the Dangerfield offer. That way the Crows can use the AFL compensation pick in an exec age of picks and players. They should end up with the Cats' first-round pick in any event.
 
The only way I see Adelaide not matching is that the AFL have decided to give us another compensation pick.
Other AFL clubs will raise hell as it impacts the draft order too much
 
Other AFL clubs will raise hell as it impacts the draft order too much
Agree, however can also see the AFL falling back to their 'secret herbs and spices' formula to justify any changes. This will be quickly followed by the scrapping of any compensation so they won't have to deal with it ever again! ;)
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Waste of time .....won't get AFL approval ...and FFS after Tippetgate why would the club do anything remotely controversial that will raise the ire of the other AFL clubs :confused:
My biggest fear in all this is that there might be a Tippett type side deal with Dangerfield. Hopefully not but once bitten twice shy!
 
My biggest fear in all this is that there might be a Tippett type side deal with Dangerfield. Hopefully not but once bitten twice shy!
They'd be raving mad to have done anything .....as i understand the clubs protocols after Tippettgate make another side deal almost impossible
 
The key bit of the article is that Geelong believes Adelaide won't match.

The rest of the sentence is Ralph's opinion - that if we do have to trade, Danger is worth it. You won't find a Geelong supporter who disagrees with that, though of course we would prefer to keep our picks and players if possible.

Ralph has obviously been talking to someone/several people at Geelong to know that the club is not expecting the deal to be matched. He was one of the first reporters to say on the record that Danger would be a Cat in 2016, earlier this season.

If Geelong still believe that Adelaide will not match their offer (rumoured to be about 800k), they are dreaming. Jay Ralph have been keeping the same line for months now, other clubs know it's going to the trade table and rumoured to see if they can trade for Danger if the trade with Adelaide fails.
 
They'd be raving mad to have done anything .....as i understand the clubs protocols after Tippettgate make another side deal almost impossible
Yeah but Danger re-signed midway through 2012 and the Tippett secret deal broke towards the end of 2012 and we put things in place after that. Remember that what is said publicly is not necessarily the truth.

Not saying there is a side deal but I am nervous about it given the history. It makes no sense to not match unless AFL is in one some dodgy deal and guiding us through it (i.e. don't match and we will approve the heavily favoured deal for pick 9 for you).

AFL copped a shallacking for Buddy compo and they might be navigating both clubs on trade "ideas"!
 
Waste of time .....won't get AFL approval ...and FFS after Tippetgate why would the club do anything remotely controversial that will raise the ire of the other AFL clubs :confused:
I meant the proposed swap of picks and a player that some in the media have been suggesting (alongside accepting the compo pick), with the pick(s) then jagging us a quality player from a 3rd club. Not suggesting any funny business .. we've proven we don't do that well.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

So people are basing their case for us not matching on the AFL approving a seriously lopsided and dodgy side-deal for Geelong's first round pick?

That's ridiculous. It's also draft-tampering.

But this it the AFL so I could certainly see it happening with the AFL's approval. The AFL will then penalise us for draft-tampering.
 
Kane McGoodwin .....Kane am i dumb or does this article just not compute


maybe something like 9 and murdoch for kerridge and our 2nd, we get compo from afl for not matching
 
If I'm to be objective taking into consideration how we've behaved in past trades, especially where the player has walked out on the club, the evidence suggests that we'll be accommodating rather than hard lined.
If we dont make a stand now and just roll over it will be the last straw for many afc supporters.
 
I just think that some posters are using double standards when it comes to players either leaving the club, or being recruited by your club. That's all.

Nature of the beast though really.

When Betts came here I could completely understand that Carlton fans might be pissed. It's not their fault their club thought Thomas was a better investment. Likewise I dont blame Geelong fans for being over the moon, doesnt mean I can't think Paddy is a complete campaigner though.
 
If we dont make a stand now and just roll over it will be the last straw for many afc supporters.
gotta say if we roll over I'm not sure it will be worth forking out for membership. I can handle sticking it out in the natural cycle of up's and down's. But after getting ripped off in '05 and '06, and with the year we've had, if this is handled badly it will cut us off at the knees before our run even starts. The club need to match and make a stand.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Oppo Camp Dangerfield's Gone (Zero tolerance to trolling) - READ THREAD LINKED IN OP BEFORE POSTING

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top